Inneresting read so far.
Well, I used to sit on the interrogator side of the interview table. I used to pick and choose. FWIW, here's 5 dollas worth of my 2 cents:
Low time guys: Get the CFI/CFII/MEI. You don't have to use them.
If I saw a resume with CFI/II/MEI, even if that indivdual never used the certificates, it showed that they could accomplish tough training and checking. It has little to do with going around saying "pitch up, just a bit more, and add right rudder" ad nausem. Look at it as "college" for pilots. Just like a 4 yr degree. You don't have to have it, but it's one more box checked.
Why else do I advocate the certificates? Marketability. During downturns like this one, jobs will be few and far between. There are individuals like ppragman and JDP that, through tenacity, timing, and luck-based introductions can navigate up the ranks. I applaud those individuals. The rest of us, like me included, need to have another way to pilot professionally. CFIing is a great time-filler between real gigs to keep you current or a great way to build time, but not the only way.
As for the tales of "there's a million CFI/CFII/MEI s out there". Well, that's sorta true. Obviously most MIL pilots don't have those quals, although the vast majority do instruct during their time in service. Pilots like pragman don't have the certs. The numbers of CFI/II and MEI certs seem to ebb and flow with the market. The lower times that people are getting into 135 and 121 SIC gigs, the less CFIs are out there.
Does that mean an individual with no Instruction certificates can't be successful? Of course not. One of my buddies got hired at 250TT, no CFI's. He went on to be a Captain and a Checkairman, and on to a JFK based LCC.
How cool would it be to land on gravel bars in AK? Or fly fire bombers? Or cruise the beach at 60kts? Or get an SIC gig on some movie company's sweet ride and take the hot starlet on her around the world press junket? There are a number of cool jobs, with cool flying to be had. How many? I don't know. How many go un-advertised and get filled by word-of-mouth? I don't know.
Now, go out there, have fun and get experience!! Some time we'll be over the North Pacific, and you can tell me how JC helped you! :yar: