JetBlue VP Back to the Line

PhilosopherPilot

Well-Known Member
So I've been reading the web boards, and I've gotta say I'm really shocked at the downright mean things people are saying about the VP now that he is going back to the line. He may have made some unpopular decisions, but don't people realize that part of being an executive is making those decisions? He wasn't doing anything out of malice or to be intentionally mean to the pilots. He was doing his job, and arguably any one of those people calling him names would make the same decision if they were in his shoes. I've met the guy, and he is actually a very kind hearted person who takes the decisions he makes very seriously.

I guess I just don't understand the " you" mentality. I find it unprofessional and beneath us as pilots to revel in his return to the line, including some of the just plain nasty things people are saying.

What do you guys think? @kellwolf?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Can you share some specifics of his 'unpopular' decisions and what the other boards are saying?
 
Remember where a lot of your pilots came from. There is a VERY different view of "management", especially management pilots, at some places than you might have there.
 
Remember where a lot of your pilots came from. There is a VERY different view of "management", especially management pilots, at some places than you might have there.

Still, I don't think that excuses them to be classless jerks. Treat others the way you expect to be treated. Follow the "no hole" rule. He's a human being, who was just doing a job. His job wasn't to make friends or please pilots. His job was to run a flight operation. You can argue about whether he was effective, or if he did a good job or not, but nothing excuses the level of aggression displayed on BluePilots.

How can you demand to be treated as a professional when your behavior looks more like a petulant child?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Can you share some specifics of his 'unpopular' decisions and what the other boards are saying?
 
It's just a bunch of name calling (d-bag, •, etc.) and dropping of the F bomb.

As far as his decisions, I don't have any specifics. Probably most of what came down from him was just parroted from above.

The most interesting opinion was that any management pilot should resign his seniority number, and not be able to return to the line upon leaving management. I'm not sure why people are so hostile to pilots who choose to apply for a mgmt position, but something like that isn't really industry standard. Delta has plenty of pilots in management, and they rotate in/out to the office/back to the line on a regular basis. I actually think that's a good thing. Isolating the two sides just builds more mistrust and conspiracy theories.
 
It's just a bunch of name calling (d-bag, •, etc.) and dropping of the F bomb.

I have been called far worse from management folks at Colgan :).

I know what you are saying, but, if this guy made unprofessional decisions that affected these guys, well, the names will fly.

As far as his decisions, I don't have any specifics. Probably most of what came down from him was just parroted from above.

That is far from a valid excuse. Look at all the Nazi war criminals that used that defense.

Part of being a leader is being able to think for yourself, not push papers around, and deliever your own message, not the canned company message. For example, even though they would NOT be labeled as Scabs due to the definition of the struck work, hours before the Spirit Strike, the VP of Operations and Chief Pilot 'resigned' after they told their boss that they would not reposition airlines while the pilots were walking around in circles. How do you think those guys were treated once they went back to the line?

If your bosses want you to do something, you as as a Flight Operations Manager needs to be able to tell your boss that what they want is a bad decision because of whatever reason, or that is a good one for whatever reason and be able to use it down the road as ammunition of what to do when you may see a bad decision coming.

The most interesting opinion was that any management pilot should resign his seniority number, and not be able to return to the line upon leaving management. I'm not sure why people are so hostile to pilots who choose to apply for a mgmt position, but something like that isn't really industry standard. Delta has plenty of pilots in management, and they rotate in/out to the office/back to the line on a regular basis. I actually think that's a good thing. Isolating the two sides just builds more mistrust and conspiracy theories.

You want to have your Flight Ops Management folks to have some accountability for their actions. Having them resign their seniority number isn't that good of an idea as that corners that person to do what the company wants as their bread is buttered from management and that is it. Delta, and other airlines have in their contract that if a line pilot goes into management they become an Executive Inactive Member(that the right classification @ATN_Pilot?). Basically, they are still a member of ALPA, can't vote, still have to pay dues (at a reduced rate), but keep their place on the seniority list. That allows them to manage better as they can go back to the line if the company wants them to do what they want, even though it is wrong as they can fall back to the line. On the flip side, if they act like asses, and then come back to the line, the union can (this is REALLY rare I can't cite a time this happened for a management turned back to line pilot, but the point is it can happen) Article 8 them. Basically, you are kicked out of ALPA and then can potentially loose your job as you need to be a member (or pay a custodian fee, but the union doesn't need to accept the custodian fee) to be employed by that airline. So it does create some accountability.
 
I wasn't making any excuses for him. I don't have any specific examples, as I've only been there a year, and none of the things he put out in my tenure seemed very upsetting. I think people just are pissed that we don't have a union, and over react to every little thing that mgmt puts out. His emails and memos suffer from a lack of connection to the pilot group, but that's not worthy of the hatred. I suspect people just want someone to blame for their frustrations, and he is the most prominent figure to blame.

He didn't change our healthcare, the board and ELT did, but he gets the blame. He didn't write the PIlot Employment Agreement, but he's the point man for it. That's what I meant. But even those changes, while frustrating, don't deserve hatred and cursing. I know I'm in the minority, but I see it all as just business. When/if we get a CBA, we will have a seat at the table, and we can hold our MEC accountable for their actions as well.
 
My biggest problem with him is that he was so out of touch with line flying yet made decisions that affected it.

One of his decisions that I REALLY don't agree with was the whole "international pay" issue. Policy is you only get the international override on a route that requires a checkout. We have maybe four city pairs that fall into this, but we fly into a LOT more international destinations. He basically said things like we weren't going into tough fields to land so the override shouldn't apply. With that thinking, we should be getting an override anytime we land in DCA or on a contaminated runway. Most airlines pay the international override for any place that requires customs. Why can't we do the same?

Never got a good answer from him on any of that. He's also the one that put out the "dependability" policy with about 12 hours of notice.

I don't agree with a lot of the name calling and disparaging remarks, but he never really impressed me as a VP of Flight Ops.
 
Well, he seems like he sucks as a manager.

Once again, I don't buy the 'well the board put this policy in place'. He could have written a transparent letter to the company as this was coming down the pipeline, explaining that as the VP of Flight Ops, this type of policy is not benefitial to the pilot group and will burden his employees unnecessarily. Send that letter to the board, while copying the pilot group on it to show he has their back. If the board still puts the policy in place at least the pilot group knows were he stood on it. But sitting on his hands and being reactive instead of proactive as a manager is lame and not a good trait as manager.

Furthermore, @PhilosopherPilot, don't you have a safety background? Anyone that puts out a 'dependability policy', well......no comment...............
 
Last edited:
I do have a safety background. Dependability programs are not inherently unsafe. Quite the opposite, actually. The company needs a way to reign in abusers. Within any system there will be abusers, and even in a well designed program people will find a way to abuse it. The trick is finding a balance.

Any safety guy will say don't fly if you aren't fit. Period. So will the flight ops guy. The difference is that for the flight ops guy you may have to explain why you weren't fit. I have no problem explaining my sick calls.

At JetBlue, we needed a dependability program. Did they flub the rollout? Definitely. Clearly. Obviously. But we needed/need it. There was a ton of abuse going on.
 
I do have a safety background.

Uh huh.

Dependability programs are not inherently unsafe. Quite the opposite, actually.

That is a bunch of bull crap and I really hope you don't believe that.

How does a dependability program, that can lead to termination, embrace a just safety culture?

The company needs a way to reign in abusers.

At Colgan they watched those that used sick leave very closely. The company was quite willing to share with the union the number of people they felt were 'abusing' sick leave or other 'dependability' issues as they wanted to show the union that the company was just in how they tried to 'reign in' the abusers. Do you know what both sides (once they got pragmatic folks in some key positions) found? The number of people that actually abuse sick leave is extremely small.

So how do you fix it? With your safety work, you should know, that it really isn't a good idea to create policy change (like a dependability program) just because you have a small number of data points on the extreme that are statistically non-existent.

At Colgan, after the accident, we had a very vibrant Pro-Standards Committee, made up of line pilots, that worked with Professionalism issues. When the EXTREMELY rare sick call or late check-in came to the Chief Pilots that looked that suspicious, the Chief Pilots referred the call and the circumstances to the Pro-Standards Committee. Pro Standards would then talk to the Pilot, get the facts, and then report back to the Chief Pilot if it was handled or if the Pilot was being an ass, didn't want to talk about it, then it would be referred back to the Chief Pilots for follow up. We also dealt with questionable fatigue calls in that manner.

It worked REALLY good, gave the extremely rare Pilot who may have made the questionable sick call the choice if they want Pro-Standards to handle it or the Chief Pilot.

Within any system there will be abusers, and even in a well designed program people will find a way to abuse it. The trick is finding a balance.

See above.

Any safety guy will say don't fly if you aren't fit. Period. So will the flight ops guy. The difference is that for the flight ops guy you may have to explain why you weren't fit. I have no problem explaining my sick calls.

What is that ops guys going to do with that data on why you (and others) weren't fit to fly? If you had to call in sick four times over two months because your young kid in day care during the week has various illnesses they passed along to you is flight ops going to force you to get a vasectomy to prevent you from having more kids? How are you going to respond the next time you are sick, but are still pissed that flight ops suspected you of abusing sick leave, and you just don't want to deal with them?

At JetBlue, we needed a dependability program. Did they flub the rollout? Definitely. Clearly. Obviously. But we needed/need it. There was a ton of abuse going on.

No you don't need a dependability program. You guys need some line Pilots that can mentor the occasional sick call abuser.
 
Last edited:
We were supposed to be checking in? Oops! I must have missed that memo...:-) On a serious note, leadership vs. supervising/managing is a very fine line...Creating synergies within an airline pilot group, and particularly at a regional is very difficult. The culture at Colgan was a very unique one due to the nature of it's ownership, and their intimate involvement in the day-to-day running of the company. Once the company grew outside the realm of EAS, plus a few other routes, managing the company was very difficult.
Pilots are just as guilty as anyone when it comes to abusing the rules when it might benefit them, and being held accountable is necessary. Where I work now, we have a "pilot dependability program" as a way of trying to mitigate absences. I personally don't like the whole concept of even having to have this program in the first place, because it smacks of treating pilots like a bunch of unreliable delinquents. Unfortunately, like every organization you have that 1-2% of asshats that • things up for the rest of us. Going to be downright interesting to see how these programs are "enhanced" due to FAR 117 implementation. Poor sods on reserve, commuting, etc...gonna be hating life, and what is remedy? Call out sick? How do we effectively police ourselves to prevent that scenario? I don't really know, because the fallout of FAR 117 has yet to reveal itself.
 
Unfortunately, much of what we do is based upon that 1-2%. Not saying that I like it or agree with it, I just understand that is the way the world works, and not just the airline business. The military is notorious for the sudden "knee-jerk".
 
Unfortunately, much of what we do is based upon that 1-2%. Not saying that I like it or agree with it, I just understand that is the way the world works, and not just the airline business. The military is notorious for the sudden "knee-jerk".

Yep, you are right.
 
Last edited:
Shop politics often lead to the 1% holding sway over policy makers if said 1% screwing up could cost them their jobs...this is not germane to just the airlines, it's corporate America, Military, Government, etc...human behavior is a very tricky and unpredictable thing. Which I am sure you are finding out is the most fun, yet most frustrating thing about being a parent...You just never know what kids are gonna do next:)
 
Back
Top