People have mentioned workrules, time away from base, etc., as important qualifiers to the dollar amount listed on the W2. Something I have grown to particularly appreciate is also where we chose to live.
Marcus, as a younger FO, makes 37,689.66 and resides in the Atlanta metro area. To maintain the same quality of life where I live in the San Jose, CA metro area would require a salary of $62933.15 (according to some basket of goods compared with an online calculator). From reviewing the items listed I don't think that includes the higher tax burden out here. In short, a regional FO in Atlanta seems to equal a regional captain in coastal California.
Many things affect where we live, such as proximity to family, the activities we enjoy, and job openings at any given moment. However, those of us living in high cost areas always have the option of giving ourselves an immediate 50% raise through moving. I know I hear Texas calling me home daily.