Is Airbus A-380 Too Big for Its Own Good? - Report

TurdBird

Well-Known Member
Is Airbus A-380 Too Big for Its Own Good?

By BOB JAMIESON
ABC News

(May 4) - A long-awaited report from the Government Accounting Office concludes that the superjumbo Airbus A-380 will create safety and other concerns at U.S. airports. This could restrict the plane's operations when it begins arriving here next year.

The huge double-decked plane, almost as long as a football field with a wingspan of 262 feet and a tail fin as tall as 80 feet, weighs a massive 1.2 million pounds when fully loaded. With a maximum capacity of 853 passengers, one of the A-380's selling points is that it will ease congestion at crowded airports.

But the GAO report says that in the United States, at least, that may not be true. "The size of the A-380 presents a safety challenge because most U.S. airports were not built to accommodate such a large aircraft," the GAO says.

The report points out that the air turbulence created by the plane's four engines, each with 70,000 pounds of thrust, leaves a wake "bigger than any other aircraft in service today." The "wake turbulence" requires increased separation from other planes on landing and takeoff. That, the report says, would effectively slow down airport operations.

The report says the plane's size and weight would also mean slower operations because of taxiway restrictions. And it says the size will also mean new challenges for fire and rescue teams, which will need new training and new equipment.

But the report acknowledges that U.S. airports confronted and overcame the same challenges of safety and wake turbulence when Boeing 's 747 was introduced 30 years ago. And Boeing's new, bigger version of that plane, the 747-8, which is expected to enter service in 2010, will "be considered in the same category" as the A-380 and will also produce similar problems, the report says.

The first A-380 will enter commercial service in the fall, starting with Singapore Airlines, on routes outside the United States. The aircraft will not make its U.S. commercial debut until 2008. Asian and European airports, which will handle significantly larger numbers of the big Airbus, are well ahead of U.S. airports in making modifications to accommodate the plane.

"In complete fairness, the airplane is designed to increase capacity by decreasing frequency, making airports more efficient. The detriments here are very real," said ABC News aviation consultant John Nance.

The wake turbulence problem is a very serious concern. But you also have other airport problems." Those problems, says Nance, include moving 500 to 600 passengers aboard the plane in a short period of time, handling luggage in a timely way both on departure and arrival and fueling the A-380. The Airbus capacity is 81,890 gallons of fuel, compared to 57,285 for the 747-400 which is currently in use.

In winter, says Nance, a big concern will be deicing the super jumbo. "Airports will need much bigger deicing trucks with the ability to get up and over those big wings and with large capacity to make sure that by the time you deice one part of the play, the other doesn't need deicing again."

Nance believes all of the problems cited by the GAO can be overcome. "It will simply take money," he says. And maybe, Nance adds, "Airbus is right that the efficiencies are going to outweigh the costs." But that will be seen only once the plane is in commercial service.

London's Heathrow Airport, the GAO says, has spent $883 million on infrastructure improvements, almost as much as the $927 million 18 U.S. airports have spent.

The GAO says about 83 percent of those funds are being used to widen existing taxiways and runways, and in some cases relocate taxiways. In other cases, taxiways and bridges need to be reinforced to handle the plane's weight. Other infrastructure upgrades include changes at gates and terminals.

"Although these changes to airport infrastructure were driven by the introduction of the A-380," the report says, they "will also benefit current aircraft and other large aircraft that may be introduced." The GAO says airport operators also told them the cost of getting ready for the A-380 will likely be recaptured in the economic benefits of the new plane.

But, says the GAO in its 72-page report, "The airports also anticipate implementing some type of operating restrictions to safely accommodate the A-380. Specifically, all 18 U.S. airports we visited anticipated imposing some type of operating restrictions on the A-380 or on other aircraft that operate around the A-380."

The issue of how to handle the huge aircraft is also being studied by the Federal Aviation Administration, which may or may not impose its own operating restrictions sometime in the future.

One question the GAO report did not answer was what impact the A-380 would have on already strained airport capacity. The accounting arm of Congress said it was just too early to say.

Fourteen airlines have ordered 156 of the superjumbos. No U.S. passenger carrier has placed an order for the $300 million plane, which has faced severe production delays.
 
A prime example of the chicken before the egg. It is becoming more and more obvious that Airbus needs to revamp their market research criteria. Good luck Europe, cause the US surely ain't going to go overboard to accommodate it.
 
London's Heathrow Airport, the GAO says, has spent $883 million on infrastructure improvements, almost as much as the $927 million 18 U.S. airports have spent.
So the airport spends nearly a BILLION dollars just to be able to accomodate that abomination?

I wonder what the wake turb seperation requirements will end up being and if it will mean that 3 75-76-77 could have landed in the time that it takes for the vorticies to clear and for the thing to taxi clear of the runway.

To quote the Guinness guys "BRILLIANT!!!"
 
I would venture separation standards will be not that big a deal once it is operational.

All this really proves is that, as usual, Nance is an idiot. Another self-proclaimed "expert", with several obvious faulty statements attributed to him in just that article.
 
All this really proves is that, as usual, Nance is an idiot. Another self-proclaimed "expert", with several obvious faulty statements attributed to him in just that article.

I'm really curious about your attitude towards Nance. You've mentioned it before and I asked you to give me some examples where Nance was off base, no response. I've been reading him for years and he seems to be one of the few reliably reasonable aviation analysts out there. Along with his long career in commercial aviation (Braniff and Alaska) and his numerous books (the non-fiction ones based on lots of investigation) I think others have proclaimed him an expert. And again, I never hear him say anything unreasonable. So what were the several obvious faulty statements in this article?
 
The report points out that the air turbulence created by the plane's four engines, each with 70,000 pounds of thrust, leaves a wake "bigger than any other aircraft in service today." The "wake turbulence" requires increased separation from other planes on landing and takeoff. That, the report says, would effectively slow down airport operations.

And yet another example of those reporters who just don't get it. Wake turbulence (as ALL you pilot types know!) comes from the wingtips, not the engines. This behemoth creates its havoc based upon its sheer weight, not its thrust.

Here's what you'll hear next: "Well, do they really NEED engines that big? Smaller ones would reduce the turbulence..."
 
Yes, it's a waste of metal. Needs to be melted; and used as silverware instead.

I'm not looking forward to do the day when the headlines read;

"A380 Crashed outside of Paris; 750 expected dead."

Yup, great job.
 
Yes, it's a waste of metal. Needs to be melted; and used as silverware instead.

I'm not looking forward to do the day when the headlines read;

"A380 Crashed outside of Paris; 750 expected dead."

Yup, great job.
Can you imagine the media frenzy that would ignite?

"Air travel unsafe!, metal, fire, and death raining from the skies, nobody is safe, nobody!"
 
"In complete fairness, the airplane is designed to increase capacity by decreasing frequency, making airports more efficient. The detriments here are very real," said ABC News aviation consultant John Nance.

OK, not too much can be said about this statement, other than a bit overly dramatic.

The wake turbulence problem is a very serious concern. But you also have other airport problems." Those problems, says Nance, include moving 500 to 600 passengers aboard the plane in a short period of time, handling luggage in a timely way both on departure and arrival and fueling the A-380. The Airbus capacity is 81,890 gallons of fuel, compared to 57,285 for the 747-400 which is currently in use.

This is, at a minimum, misleading. It has already been shown that with the wider doors, stairs and jetway configuration, that the total time to board is LESS than aircraft like the 757. Handling luggage for one flight is, if anything, going to be faster and simpler than two flights going to the same place (which is what happens now on many of the lanes that the A380 is aimed at). Fueling as an issue is just inane, for both the reason that I just mentioned for the baggage, and also because it's not that much more and full fuel likely won't happen on each flight.

In winter, says Nance, a big concern will be deicing the super jumbo. "Airports will need much bigger deicing trucks with the ability to get up and over those big wings and with large capacity to make sure that by the time you deice one part of the play, the other doesn't need deicing again."

Give me a break. The amount of fluid used and time to spray won't be significantly different than a 747, for a variety of reasons, such as how the fluid would disperse over the wing surface, etc.

Nance believes all of the problems cited by the GAO can be overcome. "It will simply take money," he says. And maybe, Nance adds, "Airbus is right that the efficiencies are going to outweigh the costs." But that will be seen only once the plane is in commercial service.

Again, somewhat overly dramatic. Nance is one of the better ones the media uses, but that's not saying much. He is not really well respected at the various safety organizations, government and non-govt. At least, I've yet to hear anyone say anything good!

Anyway, he didn't give me enough to really tear into in this article, but those are some initial thoughts!
 
Yes, it's a waste of metal. Needs to be melted; and used as silverware instead.

I'm not looking forward to do the day when the headlines read;

"A380 Crashed outside of Paris; 750 expected dead."

Yup, great job.


I thought that monster was made out of composite materials - some sort of plastic or something. But what the heck do I know? I just put people on the airplanes.:o
 
Again, somewhat overly dramatic. Nance is one of the better ones the media uses, but that's not saying much. He is not really well respected at the various safety organizations, government and non-govt. At least, I've yet to hear anyone say anything good!

Anyway, he didn't give me enough to really tear into in this article, but those are some initial thoughts!

OK, your saying he did fair given he's a total idiot. I don't know why "various safety organization, government and non-govt" would have much to say about him at all. Unless they just don't have much to talk about. I do think over the years we've been lucky when we've been able to get voices like Nance's commenting on aviation as opposed to most that really don't know anything. But that's just mho.
 
And yet another example of those reporters who just don't get it. Wake turbulence (as ALL you pilot types know!) comes from the wingtips, not the engines. This behemoth creates its havoc based upon its sheer weight, not its thrust.

Here's what you'll hear next: "Well, do they really NEED engines that big? Smaller ones would reduce the turbulence..."

That's exactly where I stopped reading...
 
OK, your saying he did fair given he's a total idiot. I don't know why "various safety organization, government and non-govt" would have much to say about him at all. Unless they just don't have much to talk about. I do think over the years we've been lucky when we've been able to get voices like Nance's commenting on aviation as opposed to most that really don't know anything. But that's just mho.

I think that this particular article wasn't a good example. Most of the complaints have to do with him pontificating on accident causes when the NTSB investigators don't have enough information to come to the conclusions he seems to be reaching. That leads to a lot of loss credibility, in my book.

I agree he's better than most of the idiots they find for their news broadcasts, but, then, I already stated that!
 
I wonder what the wake turb seperation requirements will end up being and if it will mean that 3 75-76-77 could have landed in the time that it takes for the vorticies to clear and for the thing to taxi clear of the runway.

To quote the Guinness guys "BRILLIANT!!!"

It looks like it's gonna be 15 NM entrail (including 2000 feet below) and +1 minute to the already established 2 minutes/5 miles rule. I forget the 'landing behind' rule.

Plus they were refering to it as 'callsign'SUPER rather than the normal 'callsign'HEAVY.

1.2 - 1.3 million pounds...ummmmmm... wow! Too bad it'd be boring as he// to fly.
 
I have an idea, why dont we design an airplane that is 2 miles long and 1 mile high. That way, we wont ever have to worry about size.
 
Back
Top