ILS dual nav coms

banjo

Well-Known Member
Talking to some other cfii,s today and had this discussion.

1. You have dual nav coms with gs and your doing a ils app.

2. Do you tune both to the ils or tune one to the ils and the other to the ma procedure.

3. The ils has a ma procedure to a vor and hold.

Discussion was split about 50/50 what to do
 
It's a question of technique. But how about a true story to help the discussion along?

I was returning home after a trip and shot the ILS into my home airport. I was in the clouds. Nav 1 ( HSI) was tuned to the ILS. Since the missed instructions were radar-based and the missed approach hold would be at an NDB anyway, Nav 2 wasn't tuned into anything.

I intercepted the glideslope normally and followed it down. Tower came on the air with a low-altitude alert :eek:

Turns out the glideslope was broken in an interesting way: worked normally until intercept and then stayed there — perfectly centered — no matter whether I flew high or low or right on target.

So my technique is to load the ILS into both.
 
Very few GA installations I've run across actually have dual glideslopes. Of course anything with a modern setup (ie 530/430 stacks, G1000) will have dual GS but typically your KX165 or KX170/175 stacks are set up where only one nav radio actually has a GS receiver. So there's that.
 
I personally like to have both on the ILS.

When you execute the missed, as you're climbing away through 400' AGL, I flipflop the radio frequencies and adjust to OBS as required. That's just me though, I've yet to fly an airplane where this all happened so fast that I didn't have time to do that.
 
If you have it, and don't use it, you are doing yourself a disservice. Be ready to re-tune on a missed. But you DO want both on an approach.
 
In the non radar environment I rarely had both on the final approach course. With full approaches you're usually using #2 for cross radials or something.
 
Unless I need the second vor to identify a fix on the approach I will have both tuned to the ils. I once had a cdi get stuck in about a half dot deflection as I was joining the fac. I would have flown through the localizer had I not seen my second nav still moving.
 
I usually have Nav 1 tuned to the ILS and Nav 2 tuned to a NAVAID for the missed or for crossing restrictions/cross radials (SA) on the LOC. Second Nav has the frequency tuned in standby for the missed NAVAID in the latter. Of course you win if the NAVAID is the same frequency for both.
 
I often will put the ILS in both the NAV 1 and NAV 2, but I will have the OBS set in the #2 for the missed approach, not necessarily the ILS course, so it is easier to just flip the frequency in the event of a missed approach.
 
I used to put the ILS in 1 and the missed in 2 and thought that backing them up was wasting my time and effort in the event of a missed, then I did it as per my company's SOP during VMC and saw the #1 HSI GS sticking and completely changed my philosophy
 
Depends on the equipment. If you're /U, you almost always need another navaid tuned in to number 2. I usually keep the missed in standby for nav 1 and secondary nav aid for cross radials active in nav 2.
 
I normally set in the ILS to both nav radios, with the VOR in the standby. Wouldn't want something weird to happen and cause a NAV to read inaccurate, especially shooting an ILS close to minimums
 
Depends on the equipment. If you're /U, you almost always need another navaid tuned in to number 2. I usually keep the missed in standby for nav 1 and secondary nav aid for cross radials active in nav 2.
...both radios on the final approach navaid, please.

I'd rather have to mash the flip flop a few times than follow a stuck glideslope pointer, which I've had not a few times.
 
Back
Top