Icing

In the airplane I'm currently flying we have:
Hot wings (mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm hot wings....)
Boots on the horizontal stabilizer.
Heated engine nacelles.
Bleed air to heat the windshield (which is loud as hell)
Pitot/static and AOA electrically heated probes.
NACA fuel vents.
2 engines pushing out 2200 (or maybe 2400) pounds of thrust.

Know what we do when we find ourselves picking up ice? Start asking around to see if someone above/below us is out of the ice. Then we go there.

Now why is someone tooling around in ice in a 172/cherokee with pitot heat, window defrost and carb heat?

-mini
 
ERAU. . . . .I think I see what you are trying to say. Perhaps I should say in "from their perspective and based on the information they had" they were not being careless. Of course in hindsight their choice was a bad one, but based on what they knew, they felt the flight would be safe. In this case they were doing some IFR work in a layer several thousand AGL, with great clear visibility below. They figured ice would be unlikely that day but if they did find any they would just drop into the clear. Hence the "out." I wasn't there for the flight, just relating as it was told to me.
 
I've gotten Ice in single pistons multiple times, always turned around as there was no sense in pushing it, though I know for a fact that that most single engine cessnas and pipers can (and do) fly with quite a bit. Out west (Yukon-Kuskokwim Delta area) they'll just punch right through all day and all night, I've even heard of guys who wait to turn around in the 207s out there until the tire rolls over.

Its always a risky game if you're stuck in it and can't get out, just hope to god you're lightly loaded, and have plenty of altitude to trade for airspeed. 1/4" may not kill you, but as you approach that first inch the margin of error is dramatically reduced. Don't slow down. Fly your final approach as fast as possible, as there may be little or no warning if the airplane is going to stall. Cessnas like to get tail-plane buffet and stall, though I've never experienced it. Fly safe, and ditto on what Branagan said.

I heard a story a few years back from a guy I know who got into it so bad in bethel that he barely made it back in ground effect. Crazy, ridiculous, and stupid.

As soon as ice adheres to your wings, you're not going to fall out of the sky, but definitely don't linger if you don't have a way to get it off.
 
always check the freezing levels and look for visible moisture. If your flying at night always keep your flashlight up front so I can check the wings for clear ice .
 
It is pretty excessive for whoever said one should cancel a flight if the OAT is 10C, That would keep me grounded all year long up here in the northern Rockies.

There are many times I do IMC in clouds that is less then 0 C without picking up ice. Today I went though an overcast 1000 feet thick in an uncertified plane at -15 C without picking up even a trace. I aways have an "out" either higher or lower. either descending or climbing 3 thousand feet will get you out most of the time.

I know its easy for you southern guys to yell "NEVER FLY IN A CLOUD WHEN LESS THEN 10c" but seriously, 90% of my 80 or so hours of actual has been below zero without any ice. I got into ice 3 or 4 times that I remember and everytime I turned around and was out within a mintue or two. Now that being said, I have cancelled many many flights when there is no out, like when clouds are lower then MEA's, or I cant fly over it. I also wont fly at night IMC or without XM weather. Get there itus can make one very complacent, and its easy for people to get more and more comfortable. I LOVE that Icing course from ASF. Its a prime example how dangerous it is. I would have been tempted to fly the same flight if it was day time and forcasted like it was. scary stuff!

Its not illegal to fly in known icing condition, Its illegal to fly in known icing. Now if you pick up a trace of icing it just went from "known icing condition" to "known icing" and you GOT to get out of it!
 
Its not illegal to fly in known icing conditions

Cirrus POH, Page 2-15

"Icing
Flight into known icing conditions is prohibited"

I'm an east coast flat land boy, and I've never said, implied or had the notion that it is unacceptable to fly in a cloud that is less than 10*C. I've flown in 4-5*C clouds and never batted an eye. However, before doing so, I studied all information available to me; temps aloft, PIREPs, AIRMETs, CIP and FIP (Current/Forecast Icing Potential) charts, etc. If any one of them hinted at the slightest possibility of ice at my cruise altitude, I choose a lower altitude. If I couldn't reasonably expect to stay out of icing conditions at or above the MEA, I put the airplane back in the hangar and went home. Being in a mountainous region and claiming that you'd never be able to fly if you didn't go up in potential icing is, to put it politely, bull honky. You have to accept the fact that you are in a less forgiving environment and that there will be more days out of the year that you will have to put your ADM into use and give up the fight.
 
What is your definition of "Known Icing Conditions"? I just did a flight tonight from SD to western Wyoming with an airmet of moderate icing forecast from the SFC to 24000 (look at it now), without touching a cloud. Was I flying illegally?
 
What is your definition of "Known Icing Conditions"? I just did a flight tonight from SD to western Wyoming with an airmet of moderate icing forecast from the SFC to 24000 (look at it now), without touching a cloud. Was I flying illegally?

No. I'm sure you looked at enroute METARs and TAFs to ensure that you would stay out of visible moisture. Right?
 
I've had one encounter with icing in a light piston. Cruising down the coast, OAT was around 7C and had been warming for the last couple hundred miles. Had been in and out of some light clouds with no ice. Finally, though, we hit some thicker clouds, the OAT dropped to -1 in about half a mile and the ice started piling on. In the minute or two we were in that cloud, we probably picked up about 1/3" of rime.

We executed a 180, got the hell out of there, filed a PIREP, flew to a nearby airport outside of the icing area and called it quits for the day. The next day was clear and perfect for finishing our route.

Don't mess with ice in non-FIKI aircraft. If you hit some unforecast icing, get out of there immediately and file a PIREP for your fellow aviators.
 
What is your definition of "Known Icing Conditions"? I just did a flight tonight from SD to western Wyoming with an airmet of moderate icing forecast from the SFC to 24000 (look at it now), without touching a cloud. Was I flying illegally?


Operating in Icing Conditions
Visible Moisture Definition: Visible moisture includes clouds, fog with visibility 1 mile [1,500 meters] or less, rain, snow, sleet, or ice crystals.

Icing conditions exist in flight at a Total Air Temperature (TAT) of 10C or below and visible moisture in any form is present, except when static air temperature (SAT) is -40C or below.

So.... our icing conditions according to the book are these... and we've got heated wings and cowls (no heated tail).... it also mentions don't hold with the slats/flaps out in icing, and that if we don't apply these A/I measures, we could damage the engines and also compromise the airflow over the wing....

just to give you an idea of how the Minor Leagues do it....
 
Operating in Icing Conditions
Visible Moisture Definition: Visible moisture includes clouds, fog with visibility 1 mile [1,500 meters] or less, rain, snow, sleet, or ice crystals.

Icing conditions exist in flight at a Total Air Temperature (TAT) of 10C or below and visible moisture in any form is present, except when static air temperature (SAT) is -40C or below.

So.... our icing conditions according to the book are these... and we've got heated wings and cowls (no heated tail).... it also mentions don't hold with the slats/flaps out in icing, and that if we don't apply these A/I measures, we could damage the engines and also compromise the airflow over the wing....

just to give you an idea of how the Minor Leagues do it....

The FAA does not necessary consider mere presence of clouds or any visible moisture thats under freezing to constitute "known icing conditions" .....

http://download.aopa.org/epilot/2009/090126icing.pdf

I agree with the poster above, up North here where its extremely dry its you can fly IMC all day long some days without picking up ice below freezing
 
The FAA does not necessary consider mere presence of clouds or any visible moisture thats under freezing to constitute "known icing conditions" .....

http://download.aopa.org/epilot/2009/090126icing.pdf

I agree with the poster above, up North here where its extremely dry its you can fly IMC all day long some days without picking up ice below freezing

Well I quoted from an FAA-approved document. If you want to go tooling around in a non-FIKI aircraft with temperatures so close to freezing near clouds, go ahead, but please don't fly anyone I care about around. I'm merely trying to impress upon you that under these conditions we are already exercising extreme vigilance and monitoring the situation (and might I add, already applying anti-ice measures)....

Such a cavalier attitude towards ice from a few people on here.....
 
The air is considerably "drier" in the northern lats in winter also. Below is a link to a Brasilia icing upset coming out Nassau in March. Somewhere on the net, there is a video a pax took out the side window during the upset.
http://www.ntsb.gov/Pressrel/2001/010326.htm

Full
http://www.ntsb.gov/ntsb/brief2.asp?ev_id=20020124X00119&ntsbno=DCA01MA031&akey=1
See, now I was trying to get you to ease me of my fears of ice, but this just applifies it. Thanks a lot, now it's a phobia! :) Joking aside, this is the kind of thing I was referring to; Experienced crew members on airliner aircraft, nearly killing themselves and all passengers. I put myself in the captains seat, and everything he did seemed logical. But still the aircraft entered an almost uncontrollable bank and dive (60 degree dive, wow). Different conditions, and everyone on this aircraft would have died. It just makes you second guess your aeronautical decision making when you see very experienced pilots get into situations in which they cannot get out of. Is there anything different any of you pros would have done in this example?
 
I am surprised people are so scared of icing. Not that I go fly through known conditions but If you are IFR chances are you have to go through the layer either on the climb out or descent so you have to pick up ice at one point or another if there is precip. Just make sure you stop the icing asap by either climbing above it or down to warmer temps.
 
The FAA does not necessary consider mere presence of clouds or any visible moisture thats under freezing to constitute "known icing conditions" .....

Correct. The FAA reversed that line of thought last winter.

It's all about what prudent pilot would do...whatever that means.
 
Back
Top