Icing

troopernflight

Well-Known Member
...scares me more than anything. Probably because I have no experience with it. I've read numerous articles on icing and also took a look at the asf's course today. It was chilling listening to the atc communications with that Cirrus SR-22. Do you guys or girls have any wisdom to convey on this topic? Sharing your experiences would be very interesting. Any recommendations would be appreciated. Thanks.
 
Picked it up 3 times in a C172, light rime all 3 times, I was able to get out of it very quickly.

My friend picked up a ton of ice on his 172, I saw pictures, there was a lot of clear on the prop. It was just him and half tanks, he had to use full power to maintain the GS.

Another school picked up about 1.5 inches on their Piper, flew just fine.

I have a powerpoint I just put together to teach a bunch of student pilots, I could email it to ya.
 
The Piper flew just fine with 1.5"? What is your definition of fine? At what angle of attack would it stall? What speed would that equate to in straight and level flight? What are the characteristics of such a stall? What are the indications of such a stall? Would it stall at the tips first? The root? Would the ailerons be effective into the stall?

Nope. Don't screw around with ice in non-certified airplanes. Nomatter how many stories you hear from the superheros that had an icing encounter and lived.

If you get into icing in a single engine airplane (not certified for known icing) than you have made a mistake. You have eyeballs and an OAT gauge.

Picked it up 3 times in a C172, light rime all 3 times, I was able to get out of it very quickly.

My friend picked up a ton of ice on his 172, I saw pictures, there was a lot of clear on the prop. It was just him and half tanks, he had to use full power to maintain the GS.

Another school picked up about 1.5 inches on their Piper, flew just fine.

I have a powerpoint I just put together to teach a bunch of student pilots, I could email it to ya.
 
The Piper flew just fine with 1.5"? What is your definition of fine? At what angle of attack would it stall? What speed would that equate to in straight and level flight? What are the characteristics of such a stall? What are the indications of such a stall?

Nope. Don't screw around with us in non-certified airplanes. Nomatter how many stories you hear from the superheros that had an icing encounter and lived.

If you get into icing in a single engine airplane (not certified for known icing) than you have made a mistake. You have eyeballs and an OAT gauge.


Couldn't of said any of that better myself. Not really any excuse for hanging out in icing in an unapproved aircraft.
 
I have to agree with Zap here... You dont mess around with this stuff... AT ALL. A GA plane that is not meant to have ICE on it should not be flown into known icing. And that includes if the temperature is below zero and you are in a cloud. Dont be foolish and you will make it many years flying.... Be foolish it might be your last...
 
The Piper flew just fine with 1.5"? What is your definition of fine? At what angle of attack would it stall? What speed would that equate to in straight and level flight? What are the characteristics of such a stall? What are the indications of such a stall?

Nope. Don't screw around with us in non-certified airplanes. Nomatter how many stories you hear from the superheros that had an icing encounter and lived.

If you get into icing in a single engine airplane (not certified for known icing) than you have made a mistake. You have eyeballs and an OAT gauge.

I agree with this infallible logic.

However, more importantly: "You're back. You're really back!!!"

Doug was too cheap to buy the icon for bromance, so I'll have to substitute this one instead: :o
 
I'm not back. There was just nothing good on TV tonight and my wife was watching dance shows.
 
Figure skating Martin. When we met and you were doing mixed doubles figure skating with your "cousin" Keith... that's when I knew that we just HAD to be friends.

See, that's a lie.

I know you love dancing of all sorts. Ballroom, Ice Dancing...all manner of dancing.
 
Figure skating Martin. When we met and you were doing mixed doubles figure skating with your "cousin" Keith... that's when I knew that we just HAD to be friends.


"There's a place to try everything once. It's called 'college'" - South Park
 
A-frickin-men

If you're flying a non-FIKI airplane, don't even think about even "having a look-see". If there is the slightest chance of ice, regardless of PIREPs, AIRMETs, or lack thereof, and the flight can't be completed in VMC, put the plane back in the hangar and go home.

There is a 5+ page article on icing in this months Business & Commercial Aviation. It explains the scientific factors behind the accretion of ice on an airplane; none of it which I understand. My point is that ice is still a very mysterious phenomenon, even to the experts. Forecasting is still somewhat of a crapshoot. I don't want to be the one up there testing the hypotheses without the equipment to save my bacon.
 
Closest I've ever been, was this summer (July 4) to be exact. I was in a DA-40, IFR, in moderate precip, cruising along at 12,000 feet. Knew I was just under the freezing level, but felt ok with it. Temp gauge had me at about 1 Celsius. First time that I'd actively thought about incorporating it into the IFR scan. Really made me aware of what was going on outside. Especially when there were Saab 340's reporting moderate ice a mere 2,000 feet above me.
 
The Piper flew just fine with 1.5"? What is your definition of fine? At what angle of attack would it stall? What speed would that equate to in straight and level flight? What are the characteristics of such a stall? What are the indications of such a stall? Would it stall at the tips first? The root? Would the ailerons be effective into the stall?

Nope. Don't screw around with ice in non-certified airplanes. Nomatter how many stories you hear from the superheros that had an icing encounter and lived.

If you get into icing in a single engine airplane (not certified for known icing) than you have made a mistake. You have eyeballs and an OAT gauge.

The airspeed was dropping and losing RPM but they made it ok. The FAA did change their stance so flying through a cloud when the temp is below 0 isn't technically flying into known ice conditions anymore.

Wasn't by choice, every time I picked it up I was between 0 and +2C.

Three times percip under a cloud and once through a cloud at 8k (only way through some mod cells).

I'm well aware of the dangers of icing and would NEVER put a light GA airplane in a situation with no out.
 
...scares me more than anything. Probably because I have no experience with it. Do you guys or girls have any wisdom to convey on this topic? Any recommendations would be appreciated. Thanks.
Nothing to be scared about, but you need a healthy respect for it. Ice can be expected from +10 C and below and with visible moisture. If the aircraft is not approved for flight in icing conditions......stay out of the clouds when the temp is below +10C.


Picked it up 3 times in a C172, light rime all 3 times, I was able to get out of it very quickly.

My friend picked up a ton of ice on his 172...It was just him and half tanks, he had to use full power to maintain the GS.

Another school picked up about 1.5 inches on their Piper, flew just fine.

Do instructors and students just blow off regs and common sense these days? I got my PPL in High School, instructed, flew freight and have flown over 20+ years. Not once have I found myself in "accidental" icing conditions, nor have I flown a non-certified a/c in such conditions. I have also sat comfortably in a jet and listed to a Cherokee declare an emergency for icing. He was IMC over the mountains with ground temps well below freezing. Sobering to listen to, but you have to wonder what they were expecting. It's like jumping in a lake and being surprised you got wet.
 
Trust me fella's, I plan on keeping my butt as far away from ice as possible when in single engine non-cert. I think what got me thinking was the situation on the asf's course. There were no airmets or sigmets for ice on that guy's course, and no pireps on top of that. The freezing level was well below his planned altitude, but clouds were predicted at 7-9k and then >15k. For his 12k cruise, it should not have been an issue. He got into icing and then could not escape by climbing, and proceeded to far into it. The lesson I learned was #1, turn around immediately if not sure. (especially if over the mountains) #2, let ATC know immediately if you inadvertently run into ice. #3, Don't let your confidence get the best of you, even if you have weeping wings (or some other type of ice protection) or an aircraft parachute. It just makes me nervous knowing that the National Weather Service still does not always accurately predict ice.
 
The trouble with it flying "just fine" is that at any moment it may not be fine, the wing will pay off in a split second, and you may find yourself upside down and spinning.

Not so fine anymore.
 
\




Do instructors and students just blow off regs and common sense these days? I got my PPL in High School, instructed, flew freight and have flown over 20+ years. Not once have I found myself in "accidental" icing conditions, nor have I flown a non-certified a/c in such conditions. I have also sat comfortably in a jet and listed to a Cherokee declare an emergency for icing. He was IMC over the mountains with ground temps well below freezing. Sobering to listen to, but you have to wonder what they were expecting. It's like jumping in a lake and being surprised you got wet.

Again have to agree.. Sorry but going into clouds with a temp of zero and knowing that clouds hold moisture seems like the attitude of one who will eventually get into a situation they do not desire... FAA can change it all they want, but does that make it smart?
 
I'm not back. There was just nothing good on TV tonight and my wife was watching dance shows.

Whoo HOO! Zap is back.
Anyway, stay the F away from ice. If you feel you are at risk, make sure you leave yourself an out:

Cloud bases low enough you can get out of it.
Cloud tops low enough you can climb out of them.
Little to no mountains or towers.
Couple airports in mind on the route you know will have high ceilings.
Stay away from western NY, or anywhere around the great lakes during icing season. I'd give you even odds at living.
I have no rocky or sierra mountain icing experience, some of these mountain guys need to chime in.
 
The lesson I learned was #1, turn around immediately if not sure. (especially if over the mountains) #2, let ATC know immediately if you inadvertently run into ice. #3, Don't let your confidence get the best of you, even if you have weeping wings (or some other type of ice protection) or an aircraft parachute.

That's pretty sound advice.

It just makes me nervous knowing that the National Weather Service still does not always accurately predict ice.

Always take ANY forecast with a large grain of salt.
 
I agree that you shouldn't mess with even the possibility of ice in a non FIKI plane, but I will say I have encountered it twice. Once in a Seminole, when I really had no clue what icing was, and my instructor did most of the work, and once last Monday in a Twin Comanche. I had been up in the clouds all day and there was a temperature inversion, so even though it was 4 C on the ground the freezing level was at about 7000 feet, so I just kept it in the 2000 to 4000 range to shoot local approaches and everythign was good. Also for the previous two flights I had broken out on top at about 3300, so no icing issues. Anyways. I had one last flight of the day and it was going to be a quick cross country in the twin. I figured the temps were Okay and I knew where the tops were. PIREPS agreed. Next thing I know we are taking off as the sun is starting to set and as soon as I hit 4000 I looked at the OAT and it says -1 Then almost immediately the windscreen just completely iced over, I was still in a cloud and then comes the freezing rain. Needless to say it wasn't pretty. Then on the decent and turnaround for the approach back home (immediately after the icing encounter) I hit another cloud right before the final approach fix. This time at 2000 and got one more coating. The freezing levels plummeted in less that an hour. I guess the moral of my story is, sometimes weird things happen. I do concede i was pushing it to begin with and I have learned my lesson. My pre winter wake up call has come, but things do happen.

No IMC below +10 C sounds a little conservative. It gets to that at 4000 feet here in the middle of the summer, but do watch your temps and make sure you know what you are getting into. If there are any marginal conditions, always have a quick escape plan.
 
Back
Top