I killed 50 people today

Just so ya'll know, unless they've DRASTICALLY changed the training profile, there are VERY few cases you should be getting the sim to red screen.

It's not... normal.

There are a couple of "accidents" programmed into the sim so that we can experience what happened to other crews. Plus we had a couple of demos that didn't go according to plan... the sim kicked off motion, controls released, and a few seconds later.... red. But, I think that normally it wouldn't happen except we have new instructors in an unfamilier sim.

Anyhoo... mock checkride went great. Told that as long as I perform the same way tomorrow as I have for the last two days I should pass. Yippee!
 
Eh I dunno Ethan... I mean when its your first flight and all and you are trying to land the thing people tend to get the wind strike or a sink rate trying to land it. Its just that different perspective that a lot arent use to. the flight safety guys said its normally on the first few sims for people to do that. I dunno though.....

And maybe that right there is the difference in 500 hours?

In my new hire class of 8, the only crashes anybody had were during wind shear recoveries. No "first time" landings. No "demos" that got out of control.

As I said, maybe the profile has changed.
 
And maybe that right there is the difference in 500 hours?

In my new hire class of 8, the only crashes anybody had were during wind shear recoveries. No "first time" landings. No "demos" that got out of control.

As I said, maybe the profile has changed.

Maybe.... but again on the 1st sims and what not when its all new to you, and then you add the fact that you are nervous its possible is all I am saying. I honestly think at some point in my class of 10 all 10 had a "red" screen moment. Now that's not saying all were as a result of things. My partner told and called out a go around and the instructor wanted him to try to land it. Needless to say a sink rate came too rapid and thing happen. IN addition the demos of yaw dampners being inop and a sim instructor allowing the partner to hit the rudde "hard" and causing it to have issue, and of course the wind shear...... Just saying it happens and maybe things changed but from the sounds of the guys at flight safety who do this all the time with new hires they say its not an uncommon thing for one during their initial to get a red screen.
 
Just so ya'll know, unless they've DRASTICALLY changed the training profile, there are VERY few cases you should be getting the sim to red screen.

It's not... normal.
No it is not normal. It was a wakeup call on day one. Three good landings and then a red screen.
 
I guess I have to say I'm not following you. If you are a professional pilot that should not happen...and definitely should not be a lot of fun.

I'm old school...but I always walk into the simulator as if it is the real thing.

You got it all wrong.
1) I took it pretty hard that I got a red screen, and I was taking it very seriously. I learned right up front, to go around if you are not stable. Had it happened in a real plane it would have had serious consequences.

2) You don't know me and you weren't in the sim. I will chalk up your comments about my professionalism, which I intrepret as an insult, as either my failure to convey an experience in my post or just a misunderstanding on your part.

3) You can take something serious still enjoy it.
My comment about the sim being fun was just that, a stand alone comment saying I had fun in the sim. I was not referring to getting a red screen as fun. I make no apologies for enjoying my first sim experience nor do I feel the need to beat myself up over a botched landing in my first sim.
4) Interesting checkride story, but not applicable to me. There is no "goofing off" here.
5) In my experience, it is the arrogant guys who are "incapable" of mistakes who end making the worst. I don't know you, but I doubt you are perfect.
 
Just so ya'll know, unless they've DRASTICALLY changed the training profile, there are VERY few cases you should be getting the sim to red screen.

It's not... normal.

Don't know for sure, but the sim in STL is FSI, and I think the one in charlotte is BAE? We did the dutch roll today with and w/o YD, induced with full rudder and we both recovered right away, but some guys they had to stop the sim, when they rolled it upside down. He says the FSI sim goes nuts with the Dutch roll with the yaw dampers off.
Also, according to my instructor, getting a red screen in the first sim is not abnormal.

Glad to make my mistakes early.
 
You got it all wrong.
1) I took it pretty hard that I got a red screen, and I was taking it very seriously. I learned right up front, to go around if you are not stable. Had it happened in a real plane it would have had serious consequences.

2) You don't know me and you weren't in the sim. I will chalk up your comments about my professionalism, which I intrepret as an insult, as either my failure to convey an experience in my post or just a misunderstanding on your part.

3) You can take something serious still enjoy it.
My comment about the sim being fun was just that, a stand alone comment saying I had fun in the sim. I was not referring to getting a red screen as fun. I make no apologies for enjoying my first sim experience nor do I feel the need to beat myself up over a botched landing in my first sim.
4) Interesting checkride story, but not applicable to me. There is no "goofing off" here.
5) In my experience, it is the arrogant guys who are "incapable" of mistakes who end making the worst. I don't know you, but I doubt you are perfect.


Hey, I'm a pretty easy going guy...but whenever I see these posts that resemble a cavalier attitude toward training...it always irks me. Hand flying an ILS to minimums shouldn't be "too big" for a pro pilot's "britches". It's the basic standard of a pilot.

There's obviously an art to simulator flying...and that is probably what got you. At that point the post should have been focused on the nuances of the stability of the simulator and not reflecting your ability to fly an ILS approach.

Stating that you killed 50 people because of your poor skills displays a less than professional attitude that your pro piloting brethren are not going to look kindly towards. It is not amateur hour at the level you are qualifying for.
 
767pilot,

Ok, thanks for your input. Can't say I disagree with comments on taking the sim seriously as we are in agreement. Not going to try to again convince you that I have anything other than a cavalier attitude towards training as you simply will not believe me.
 
767pilot,

Ok, thanks for your input. Can't say I disagree with comments on taking the sim seriously as we are in agreement. Not going to try to again convince you that I have anything other than a cavalier attitude towards training as you simply will not believe me.

Some people no matter how hard you try you cant change... 767 is going to have his thoughts and there was nothing by your post that was less then professional in my personal thoughts. Fact of the matter is when you go to sim yes you are there to brush up and fine tool some items. There are many factors and to be honest after flying the sim there in STL I know for a fact its a lil weird..... Anyways your post was perfectly fine as you can tell some others who are experience did post back saying certain things about it and none were OMG you are unprofessional...... Fact of the matter is it happens while you are at Sim.... To be honest from talking to many people at various airlines it happens more often then apparently some think...... Maybe when 767 went through training he was the one who was the ace and nailed thing and therefore he doesnt see how anyone can do it. People are at different levels but he isnt the one who ultimately is going to judge your flying. Therefore take what he has to say with a gain of salt..... If you dont you will be like a certain JCer who said SO LONG not too long ago ;)!
 
I believe that you are a consumate pro. I come off looking like a jerk to most people, I'm sure, but it's kind of my thing to interject that we are educated professionals, not amateurs, and that pro pilots operate with measured discipline and skill.

There are many young professionals on this board without a lot of professional working experience and not far removed from high school. I believe that the way we communicate about our experiences sets a standard that ultimately reflects how we fly and do our jobs and how others perceive our profession.

Unfortunately, you undeservably caught the blunt of my input.
 
I believe that you are a consumate pro. I come off looking like a jerk to most people, I'm sure, but it's kind of my thing to interject that we are educated professionals, not amateurs, and that pro pilots operate with measured discipline and skill.

There are many young professionals on this board without a lot of professional working experience and not far removed from high school. I believe that the way we communicate about our experiences sets a standard that ultimately reflects how we fly and do our jobs and how others perceive our profession.

Unfortunately, you undeservably caught the blunt of my input.

Understandable.... And they should and a lot of guys are freshly removed from High School. However I know Shawn is a vet who has had pleanty of experience as an army navigator and is a gentlemen in his upper 30's..... Anyways I can see your point as long as it wasnt a direct bash towards him I'm sure he wont take it that away nor should anyone. However I can see where "killed 50" could erk some people the wrong way but it was not suppose to be in a bad way. More so an update to us all to show how he is doing in STL. Unfortunate though he did experience one and I'm sure he will be fine from there on out. Again I understand your point and respect it but just wanted to throw that out there. And for myself I have indeed graduated college and spent the past four years in non profit work with at risk youth of Indianapolis.
 
Some people no matter how hard you try you cant change... 767 is going to have his thoughts and there was nothing by your post that was less then professional in my personal thoughts. Fact of the matter is when you go to sim yes you are there to brush up and fine tool some items. There are many factors and to be honest after flying the sim there in STL I know for a fact its a lil weird..... Anyways your post was perfectly fine as you can tell some others who are experience did post back saying certain things about it and none were OMG you are unprofessional...... Fact of the matter is it happens while you are at Sim.... To be honest from talking to many people at various airlines it happens more often then apparently some think...... Maybe when 767 went through training he was the one who was the ace and nailed thing and therefore he doesnt see how anyone can do it. People are at different levels but he isnt the one who ultimately is going to judge your flying. Therefore take what he has to say with a gain of salt..... If you dont you will be like a certain JCer who said SO LONG not too long ago ;)!



The OP's message is not that offensive or unprofessional. He presents a viewpoint from his and his company's training department that it is a fairly relaxed and unthreatening environment. That's a great training environment to have.

I merely present another viewpoint that not all companies operate that way. I've been employed by companies before that consider that a serious deal. I've had a simulator session stopped before because I was flying 50' above an assigned altitude. I've been strongly counseled on inadvertantly flying a couple of knots below Vref on approach. The list is long.

I wish to present a view that sometimes bringing less than your A game to the simulator is going to afford you extra training sessions...and not all standards departments have a philosophy that "minimum standards" are good enough. I've seen good guys wash because of extremely strict standards and seeing standards guys not deeming the applicant "good enough".

Seeing these guys leave the property sometimes steels you in regards to the seriousness of the game.

A lot of times training and the simulator has not been very fun.
 
Back
Top