I have a question my CFI can't answer...

Correctomundo. That's why I edited my last post. We were straying off topic. Simple answer is, if the OP is only missing XC and TT...then it's beneficial to finish that up in a SE then take the CMEL ride (since they have already met all the other requirements for commercial).
 
That's incorrect. Whichever you do as the initial, there are only certain things that you need to do in the other to add-on the rating. You don't need to do everything all over again. For instance, if you do the CSEL as the initial, you don't need to repeat any of the cross-country flights nor the night take-offs & landings to add on the multi rating just as you don't perform all of the required single engine maneuvers in the multi for the flight test

I understand that, I think I wasn't clear. You can't combine some of the items from 61.129(a) and (b) to take either one of them as the initial commercial. You either have to do everything as stated in (a) and take the CSEL exam or do everything in (b) and take the CMEL. Then, you can do the appropriate class add-on checkride.

To reiterate, if you are doing the CSEL as the initial commercial exam, you will need to do everything as stated in 61.129(a).
 
Mojo you are right you cant combine them but you can take 2 rides. 2 8710s. It is just that you have to meet both the requirements in a and b before you take the ride. Sorry if I confused everyone. If you have all the multi requirements met though I would think about doing that first. If you would like to talk to me about how I did it I sent you a PM with my number. You can also do an add on later on as well then the requirements might be a little different.
 
but I'm still confused about this one... 5 hours in night VFR conditions with 10 takeoffs and 10 landings (with each landing involving a flight in the traffic pattern) at an airport with an operating control tower. It doesn't say single engine for this but I did this in a multi already with a CFI.

Contrary to popular belief, the legal nerds who write the regs don't just jot down a bunch of incoherent sentence fragments that are unrelated to each other. You have to read ALL of the words, and make sure that you are putting each item in its proper context, according to those words. This one is really pretty simple. Quoting from the post by jhugz, and leaving out some unnecessary words that clutter things up, this is what I get:

(4) Ten hours of solo flight time in a single engine airplane ... that include—

(i) One cross-country flight of not less than 300 nautical miles total distance...;and

(ii) 5 hours in night VFR conditions with 10 takeoffs and 10 landings (with each landing involving a flight in the traffic pattern) at an airport with an operating control tower.

Now here are those same words without the numbers separating them, and removing the part about cross country:

"Ten hours of solo flight time in a single engine airplane that include 5 hours in night VFR conditions with 10 takeoffs and 10 landings (with each landing involving a flight in the traffic pattern) at an airport with an operating control tower."

I don't want to come off as a jerk, I'm only breaking it down like this because you really need to learn to read the regs this way, especially if you hope to become a CFI. I'm pretty shocked that your instructor wasn't able to figure that out. The FAA inspector who did my CFI ride ripped me a new one over the phone when I asked him a question about AC 61.65. He told me that I was about to be a CFI, I should be able to figure it out.

Just remember that each section can have multiple subsections, so when you read a subsection make sure you are putting it in the context of the main section, and try to read it like a normal sentence.
 
Mojo you are right you cant combine them but you can take 2 rides. 2 8710s. It is just that you have to meet both the requirements in a and b before you take the ride. Sorry if I confused everyone. If you have all the multi requirements met though I would think about doing that first. If you would like to talk to me about how I did it I sent you a PM with my number. You can also do an add on later on as well then the requirements might be a little different.

Maybe Im misunderstanding you, but you do NOT have to meet the requirements of both "a" and "b".

If your taking your Initial ride in a single, then you have to meet "a"
If you taking your Initial in a Multi, then you must meet "b"

If you do a Initial in a single or multi, then you can do an add-on rating without meeting the other part.

Maybe Im just misreading you. If so my bad.
 
Maybe Im misunderstanding you, but you do NOT have to meet the requirements of both "a" and "b".

If your taking your Initial ride in a single, then you have to meet "a"
If you taking your Initial in a Multi, then you must meet "b"

If you do a Initial in a single or multi, then you can do an add-on rating without meeting the other part.

Maybe Im just misreading you. If so my bad.

You are correct the only time you have to meet both of them is if you do it the way I did which was to take 1 initial commercial ride you are just using 2 different airplanes. (A single and a multi engine)

Looking back at is now I probably could have done the requirements of 61.129 B for my multi and then just done the requirements of 61.63 for my single add on however you would have to use a complex airplane for the add on where as they way I did it I could use a warrior for the maneuvers.
 
Contrary to popular belief, the legal nerds who write the regs don't just jot down a bunch of incoherent sentence fragments that are unrelated to each other. You have to read ALL of the words, and make sure that you are putting each item in its proper context, according to those words. This one is really pretty simple. Quoting from the post by jhugz, and leaving out some unnecessary words that clutter things up, this is what I get:

(4) Ten hours of solo flight time in a single engine airplane ... that include—

(i) One cross-country flight of not less than 300 nautical miles total distance...;and

(ii) 5 hours in night VFR conditions with 10 takeoffs and 10 landings (with each landing involving a flight in the traffic pattern) at an airport with an operating control tower.

Now here are those same words without the numbers separating them, and removing the part about cross country:

"Ten hours of solo flight time in a single engine airplane that include 5 hours in night VFR conditions with 10 takeoffs and 10 landings (with each landing involving a flight in the traffic pattern) at an airport with an operating control tower."

I don't want to come off as a jerk, I'm only breaking it down like this because you really need to learn to read the regs this way, especially if you hope to become a CFI. I'm pretty shocked that your instructor wasn't able to figure that out. The FAA inspector who did my CFI ride ripped me a new one over the phone when I asked him a question about AC 61.65. He told me that I was about to be a CFI, I should be able to figure it out.

Just remember that each section can have multiple subsections, so when you read a subsection make sure you are putting it in the context of the main section, and try to read it like a normal sentence.

Could not have said it better. I am also shocked your instructor did not know this or could not figure it out. I knew I once had a crappy instructor when he told me to do a navlog with no ground on how to do it. When I showed up the next day, having figured it out on my own, but with several questions, he said "eh, I don't know. We all use fltplan.com these days". I got a new instructor.
 
You are correct the only time you have to meet both of them is if you do it the way I did which was to take 1 initial commercial ride you are just using 2 different airplanes. (A single and a multi engine)

Looking back at is now I probably could have done the requirements of 61.129 B for my multi and then just done the requirements of 61.63 for my single add on however you would have to use a complex airplane for the add on where as they way I did it I could use a warrior for the maneuvers.


Except thats where your wrong, If you do the single add-on you do NOT need a complex airplane.
 
I may be there. I didn't have the regs or the PTS in front of me last night. I was going by memory.never a good thing to do.
 
Back
Top