I bought a house

It is productive, at least in the sense that it limits bubbles in prices to some extent.

And can also create them. Or cause legitimate increases to stall. Etc. The market should function based upon fundamentals. It currently does over the long term, but it's incredibly inefficient in the short term, which is the result of low-penalty liquidity for short-term holdings.
 
That is not correct. The 5 year "seasoning" rule determines whether you are making a "qualified distribution," in which case, it is possible that no tax may due on the earnings, or any penalty applied in addition.

The original contribution (not earnings), can be withdrawn tax and penalty free at any time.



The IRS says the same thing, but not as clearly:

http://www.irs.gov/publications/p590/ch02.html#en_US_publink10006523
I went and read again what you wrote and see that you said what you put in you can take out tax free. I read it last night that anything you take out is tax free.
 
You pay penalties on the earnings, not on the original deposit amount. For example, if you deposit $5k in the Roth, its value builds up to $6,500 a few years later, and you withdraw the entire amount, then you pay taxes and a 10% penalty on the $1,500 in earnings, not on the original principal.
Sleepy reading comprehension got the best of me with his post last night. :)
 
So when is the housewarming party??? I'll bring lots and lots of beer. Nice going, BTW. I've never understood how people with "normal" jobs can possibly afford to buy a house in California.. Honestly, I just don't get it. But, I'll still bring lots and lots of beer.

I rented the house back to the family I bought it from for 800 bucks for a month. I get to move in at the end of the month. I'm a big believer in Karma. So I wanted to help the people I bought it from also they picked my lower bid because of this.

But yeah both sides of the family kicked down to help me. No doubt I will spend the next 10 years paying them back. At least I have a hedge on rent now.
 
Back
Top