How to decline giving a recommendation

Don't lie to people because the truth makes you uncomfortable. The dude I told that to needed to hear it. Its been about 4 years now and he's really turned around. Am I the reason? No, but I'm sure he thought good and long on what I said.



You're dreamy. Where have you been all my life? :love:
 
So we all know internal recs are a great way to get started.. Every job I've had in flying so far has been thanks to a recommendation. That said have you ever been approached by someone you felt would not be a good fit for whatever the position is? How do you tactifully say no?

Since you haven't provided any details like if you know the person well, if they went to prison, or are being investigated by the FAA for being insane.... I would have to give you a general answer. I knew this person that did not belong in an airplane. However, being the type of person that I am, I recommended them anyways. What if the tables were turned and you were in their position? If you know that person and you don't recommended then really it's not right, you never ever burn bridges with anyone. You would be surprised where people end up. However, if you don't know them then it's pretty easy.
 
I knew this person that did not belong in an airplane. However, being the type of person that I am, I recommended them anyways. If you know that person and you don't recommended then really it's not right, you never ever burn brides with anyone. You would be surprised where people end up. However, if you don't know them then it's pretty easy.


Whew, I'm glad to read you don't believe in burning brides! :insane: :D
 
I had it happen once, luckily he just left a voice mail. I ended up not calling him back. It was a • way out of it, but for me it was more comfortable than direct confrontation.
 
I knew this person that did not belong in an airplane. However, being the type of person that I am, I recommended them anyways. What if the tables were turned and you were in their position? If you know that person and you don't recommended then really it's not right, you never ever burn bridges with anyone. You would be surprised where people end up.

Apparently, Steve Dickson, SVP-Flight Ops @ Delta disagrees with you.

"I ask that you carefully consider any recommendation you make, since they carry substantial weight. Recommending an applicant is not a decision to be taken lightly, so please take time to consider the qualifications, professionalism and character of any pilot you recommend."
 
Apparently, Steve Dickson, SVP-Flight Ops @ Delta disagrees with you.

"I ask that you carefully consider any recommendation you make, since they carry substantial weight. Recommending an applicant is not a decision to be taken lightly, so please take time to consider the qualifications, professionalism and character of any pilot you recommend."

That's for Delta................. My story was on entry level flying. People got to start somewhere.
 
That's for Delta................. My story was on entry level flying. People got to start somewhere.

Doesn't matter at what level we are talking about. The criteria for recommending someone shouldn't change based on who it's for. Some people just don't have the aptitude or ability to operate aircraft. It does no one any good to move them along, hoping that they will get weeded out in the future by someone else.

In order to go to med or law school, you have to demonstrate a minimum level of aptitude to even go to school. Should be the same to start flight training.
 
I like Boris' example, with the person who is continually late, etc... they do need to hear why their work-behavior is unacceptable and what it is costing them. It's hard to be frank with people like that, but when you recommend someone you put YOUR name on the line too, think if you really want that person representing YOU.

Things can be said nicely, one doesn't have to be a jerk about it. Use specific examples of their actions/behavior, and perhaps offer to give the recommendation if they turn the behavior around & change.

Perhaps say it as, "Well, I'd love to give you a recommendation, but there's a couple things that concern me. I've noticed that most days you're here 10-15 minutes late. At XYZ company, that's really frowned on, they'll come after you for that. If you can come in on time for a couple weeks, we'll talk about a recommendation."
 
Back
Top