Ground Effect

92128

New Member
Anybody wanna talk ground effect? I'm looking for a clear explanation of ground effect. The Jepp says "induced drag is decreased, due to the changes in the upwash pattern ahead of the wing and the downwash and wingtip vortices behind the wing". That seems a little vague to me. Can anybody here do better than that? This has always been one of my weak points. I understand that induced drag is decreased due to the ground's interference with airflow around the wing. But I don't really get how the ground interferes or how it's interference decreases drag. Thanks in advance!
 
But I don't really get how the ground interferes or how it's interference decreases drag.

Here's one way to look at it:

squashedvortices.png

​
Induced drag is caused by the wingtip vortices, which cause the lift vector to be tilted backwards. The larger the area of the wing affected by the vortices, the greater the induced drag. A longer wingspan means that the wingtips are further away from most of the wing, so induced drag is lessened. In the same way, ground effect pushes the tip vortices further out, just as if the wing were longer, reducing induced drag.
 
Induced drag is caused by the wingtip vortices, which cause the lift vector to be tilted backwards.

Nice explanation, but let me ask you this. The vortices cause the lift vector to be tilted backwards. This is because they (the vortices) change the local relative wind at the wingtips, thus reducing the AoA at the wingtips. I guess what I don't understand is HOW the vortices cause a change in the relative wind.
 
I guess what I don't understand is HOW the vortices cause a change in the relative wind.

Vortices curl up and then down. The downward flow of the vortices combines with the relative wind to produce a small downward deflection of the relative wind as seen by the wing. The vortices affect the entire wing, not just the tips, but the effect decreases along the span toward the root.
 
Vortices curl up and then down. The downward flow of the vortices combines with the relative wind to produce a small downward deflection of the relative wind as seen by the wing. The vortices affect the entire wing, not just the tips, but the effect decreases along the span toward the root.

Understood, so in ground effect, with the ground being in the way, there is no room for this downward deflection?
 
Understood, so in ground effect, with the ground being in the way, there is no room for this downward deflection?

There is no room for the airflow that causes that deflection, the vortices. That's why my image is titled "squashed vortices". When that airflow is distorted by the ground, the lift vector "straightens up", reducing drag. And increasing lift, until the pilot pushes forward on the yoke to stop from ballooning.

Keep in mind that the lift and drag vectors are different all along the wing span. The single lift vector we typically draw is just a fiction that is useful for analysis. It's the average, so the numbers work out right.
 
The downward deflection decreases, hence decreasing rearward acting lift (drag).

For every action, there is an equal and opposite force. We sum this up as drag. While near the ground, we have an increase return in our deflected air. If we apply 20 kN in the air, we get back 10 kN, near the ground that goes to say 12 or 13 kN as an example. We still are losing to thermal, sonic, and other energy losses, but we don't lose as much near the ground as the air was before being deflected say 15 degrees down and is now only being deflected 7 or 8 degrees down. F=ma, don't accelerate the air as much (downwards) and it takes less total energy.


Short answer, the rearward vector of lift decreases... less drag. Live happy. :D
 
The single lift vector we typically draw is just a fiction that is useful for analysis.

That is what I find interesting about the jepp book. They draw the lift and drag vectors as individual forces and the aerodynamic force as the resultant. However, my aerodynamics texts draw the aerodynamic force as the force and the lift and drag as vector components. :rolleyes:


OP: This may be oversimplified, but I'm sure I'll be corrected if there is an inaccuracy in this example. Take a kitchen sink and fill it with water. Now take a knife and run it through the water, notice the spiraling water that trails off the tip. Notice how it trails both behind and below the knifes blade, just like tip vortices on an aircraft.

What do we know about spiraling air? Let's relate it to something we do know, a tornado. We know that a tornado acts to suck up objects, now imagine attaching two tornados to the back of your aircraft, one on each wingtip. They would act to pull back (create drag) on the airplane.

Now remember, this spiraling air is both behind the wingtip and below it. Now move the aircraft into ground effect, this spiraling air is now disrupted by the ground. The closer to the ground we get the more it is disrupted. The more disrupted it gets the less drag it can impose on the aircraft.

Don't know if that helps, but it's a mental picture that's worked for me for years. Is it a bad mental picture tgray?
 
That is what I find interesting about the jepp book. They draw the lift and drag vectors as individual forces and the aerodynamic force as the resultant. However, my aerodynamics texts draw the aerodynamic force as the force and the lift and drag as vector components.

Yes, and neither is more correct than the other, although treating the lift and drag vectors as more real than vector result seems slightly more arbitrary. You could resolve the resultant into components along an infinite number of coordinate systems, it just so happens that the coordinate system whose horizontal axis lies along the flight path is most convenient.

Don't know if that helps, but it's a mental picture that's worked for me for years. Is it a bad mental picture tgray?
I don't know. There are a number of correct ways to interpret the physical reality, but I don't know if the net pressure reduction at the core of the vortices is one of them.
 
The lift vector is tilted slightly rearwards, and there is most definitely a rearward component of that vector.

I think shdw is quibbling that the lift vector, by definition, can never be tilted backwards. He's correct on that, but still, this is the someone sloppy language that even some aerodynamics books use. It's more correct to say that the net force vector generated by the wing is tilted backwards. The lift vector, by definition, is the portion of that resultant force that acts perpendicular to the flight path.
 
I think shdw is quibbling that the lift vector, by definition, can never be tilted backwards. He's correct on that, but still, this is the someone sloppy language that even some aerodynamics books use. It's more correct to say that the net force vector generated by the wing is tilted backwards. The lift vector, by definition, is the portion of that resultant force that acts perpendicular to the flight path.
Understand. I think it would have been more beneficial to the person who quoted if he said that instead of the quibbling with the confused smiley. But I digress..
 
Understand. I think it would have been more beneficial to the person who quoted if he said that instead of the quibbling with the confused smiley. But I digress..

It would have been, but it wouldn't have hinted at the thought process that arrived him at that statement. I was curious as to his thinking, that is why I used a question. Learning thought processes helps me learn.

Apologies if it seemed cruel, I had no ill intentions.
 
Yes, and neither is more correct than the other...

Exactly. Displaying it as a lift vector and a drag vector leaves one to picture them as being acted on separately. It is a messy mental image if you work with them as individual vectors and I believe can more easily lead to misconceptions.

It is, IMO, simpler to always work with what jepp calls the "Resultant Vector," taught to me as "Aerodynamic Force," first. Any change would result in a shift in that vector which would effect change to the lift and drag components of that vector.

Edit: Aerodynamic Force by definition is the net force vector developed by the wings.


I don't know if the net pressure reduction at the core of the vortices is one of them.

Could we agree it clearly demonstrates a reduction, using a 'why' that is accurate? If so, we are leaving the student with an unquantified reality. One they can quantify in flight when they feel the effect.
 
Could we agree it clearly demonstrates a reduction, using a 'why' that is accurate? If so, we are leaving the student with an unquantified reality. One they can quantify in flight when they feel the effect.

I don't quite understand that sentence, but, yes, there is a reduced pressure at the core of a vortex, because that's what causes the vortex. It provides the centripetal force that causes the air to rotate, rather than moving in a constant direction. But I will otherwise remain agnostic regarding its significance. ;)
 
Just tell your student it's like a "cushion of air."

...what?

Telling someone what happens is simple, but an instructor must learn the why's. All instructors wish their students would study, I hope. Well, a student who studies is sure to come to us with some of the why's, just as the OP has here.

I'm sorry, but you simply can't answer

"But I don't really get how the ground interferes or how it's interference decreases drag"

with

"Well, its just like a cushion of air." I suspect the student would be a bit unsatisfied with this reply.
 
Back
Top