First off, I would NEVER give up the experience that I had going to a real, 4 year institution. Secondly, I would NEVER get an online degree, but especially one from any for profit "college" (i.e. University of Phoenix, etc) (I didn't look, but I'd be VERY curious to know if "Mountain State University" is for profit). Thirdly, I would NEVER recommend anyone obtain a degree in "Airline Transport Professional Pilot Operations."
Given that I'm quite certain that the entire mess created by for profit colleges is going to be the next housing bubble, and that in the real world (i.e. outside of aviation, if you ever have to actually look for a job that requires a degree) no one is going to care that you have a degree in "Airline Operations," but especially not one that you got at some virtual school that was operated for the benefit of Wall St financial institutions.
ATP is only going this direction due to the fact that if they don't, they'll be out of business in short order. Make no mistake, they do not have your best interests in mind, just like any company operated for profit does not.
I hate to sound like grandpa, but seriously kids, there's nothing wrong with "doing it right." Go to a real college, get a degree outside of aviation, and better yourself academically and mature while in college, then worry about the rest of this flying airplanes business.