Not a month went by at 9E that I didn't mutter the words "I miss Northwest."
So, basically, the fences were there.....unless they didn't need them, and they can disregard anything Bloch said. To give a quick run-down on the fences, there were staffing levels set for the -200, -900 and the Q400 on the CA side. FOs could more or less move between them with not near as many restrictions. The staffing levels had to be above X amount of pre-merger pilots for that airframe (maybe it was a percentage, my mind has blocked a lot of it out as a coping mechanism). For example, there was a set number of pre-merger XJ guys on the -900 and the same for 9E guys on the -200. If it went above that percentage/number, then guys from the other two lists could bid into that position. I don't recall more than a handful of guys bidding from 9E -200 CA to XJ -900 CA. I could have been a lineholder in MEM on the -900, but I couldn't bid across the fence.
My major problem with it was the staffing levels for the -200 were set at a realistic level, which 9E had never had in their entire existance. Thus, Colgan and XJ guys could bid -200 CA without issue, but Pinnacle CAs couldn't bid the -900 or Q400 except in VERY rare and limited circumstances since they were more or less at decent staffing levels from the get go. What wound up happening is a LOT of Pinnacle guys kept either a) getting pushed further and further back as XJ and Colgan guys bid over for better QoL OR saw their upgrades go from months to years. Meanwhile, things were protected on the XJ and Colgan side (well, Colgan side not so much since they got hosed and parked all the airframes). Fences were supposed to be up for 5 years. If the fences were intact, I would be looking at either bidding to DTW or being kicked back to the right seat on the -900 if I were still there. No fences? I could probably easily hold -900 CA in JFK with my relative seniority to XJ guys in the merger. You heard a lot of XJ guys talking about how 9E guys jumped them, but up until now (I guess), it didn't matter since none of those 9E guys could take advantage of the merged list seniority numbers.