FSDO's Response On The Pre-Solo Written

mtsu_av8er

Well-Known Member
I spoke to my POC from the Nashville FSDO about 10 minutes ago, and he confirmed that The Pre-Solo Knowledge Test does NOT have to be written.

Just wanted to pass that on . . .
 
Interesting. But the paper trail is always a good idea. I mean in 6 months lets say this student has an accident or violates an FAR. They will go back to you and ask, did you teach this and did he/she get it right. You then can pull out the pre-written solo test and show them yes. B/C your word may not just cut it in an accident investigation. Also I keep copies of everything when I was instructing. Remember records need to be kepted for 3 years.
 
Interesting. Did he give any reasons why an instructor should or should not do a written exam?

I've always thought it was kind of odd to give a student the written exam and have to admit that nothing happens if they do poorly...they just keep retaking it until they're good enough. Most people do fine the first time, but it's still an odd system with no consequences.
 
SFLAX said:
Remember records need to be kepted for 3 years.

Not every possible record though. Only records of endorsements given to a student pilot for solo flight privileges or the endorsements given to a person for a written or practical test.
 
jrh said:
Interesting. Did he give any reasons why an instructor should or should not do a written exam?

Well, we talked about it in detail, and he didn't give any reason (I don't think any of them can really say WHY, they just interpret that facts). We both agreed that the paper trail could hurt you as much as it could help you. He also said that your endorsement is proof enough that you administered the test. He said that the regs pretty much lay out what we NEED to keep records of.
 
My initial CFI quized me orally on everything in the pre solo test, which allowed me to talk through some of the questions I wasn't strong on. It also allowed him to teach some things as he did it. After that he gave me a written test that esentially had the same material on it. After the verbal, the written test was no problem.
 
Downside to this: it's only useful for the BNA FSDO. I can guaran-damn-tee you that there are several FSDOs out there that will tell you it HAS to be written. It's all a matter of geography. For us, especially the 141 part, the Ft Worth FSDO wants it in writing.
 
Philip said:
then why don't you call and confirm instead of speculate?


????? No speculation involved. Did I not say "the Ft Worth FSDO wants it in writing?" This is one of those grey areas that are abundant in aviation that leaves a lot of room for interpretation. Your answer will not only vary from FSDO to FSDO, but probably from inspector to inspector in the same FSDO. It sorta falls in with things does the clock have to be installed in the aircraft and working or is a stopwatch okay for IFR flight.
 
Of course it doesn't have to be "written". It can be done by computer. The FAR says so. Why do you need a FSDO stamp of approval for a clear regulatory requirement?
 
MidlifeFlyer said:
Of course it doesn't have to be "written". It can be done by computer. The FAR says so. Why do you need a FSDO stamp of approval for a clear regulatory requirement?

According to my POC, it can be oral.
 
Wow. So "knowledge test" doesn't mean "knowledge test." Cool.

Hope you got it in writing. New POC might come along who likes the rules the way they are written and doesn't make up his own.
 
i don't do • as a CFI without keeping a record on paper somewhere. doing anything required by the FAR orally is a really, really bad idea. even if one POC at one FSDO says it's ok.....i wouldn't do it.



CYA, buddy.
 
roundout said:
i don't do • as a CFI without keeping a record on paper somewhere.
That's a separate issue, but neither do I.

I can't buy the "you're better off not keeping a record of it" philosophy. Sounds like one of those pseudo-legal arguments with no knowledge backing it up. I guess no record is better than really lousy record, but even then it would be a close call.
 
MidlifeFlyer said:
Wow. So "knowledge test" doesn't mean "knowledge test." Cool.

Well, I could go by your FAQ over the FSDO's word, but I won't . . .:p

Hope you got it in writing. New POC might come along who likes the rules the way they are written and doesn't make up his own.

Doesn't really matter to me - I give written tests, so it doesn't affect me. New POC comes along, won't bother me any!
 
mtsu_av8er said:
Well, I could go by your FAQ over the FSDO's word, but I won't . . .:p!
Touche. Of course, I'll take the FAR's plain language over a FSDO operative who loses nothing by being wrong.
 
Back
Top