Flight instructor question (private/common carriage)

tcco94

Future GTA VI Pilot
I didn't really brief up on this as much in my CFI training but I don't want to go breaking any rules as a CFI either... or give a student the wrong information.

I have a buddy that wants some flight training back in my home town. I was going to get checked out in an airplane at a local flight school and then he was going to fly and I would teach him with a few lessons (probably 6-8 hours worth of flight training) and then transfer him off to a CFI at that school that would allow him to solo and continue his private training. Mainly he wanted to up with a few flights with me and we could go over some basic entry level stuff.

So, is this breaking any rules as far as common carriage if he's paying for the aircraft rental rate? Obviously, he's the only one I'd be offer any flight training too since he's a buddy and I'm an employee at a different flight school out of state.

As far as I know as an instructor, I can offer my services as a flight instructor out and that's why some pilot shops have tons of business cards for CFI training?.... but it's not my plane and not my company that I'm renting the aircraft from. I don't want to sign his logbook for training and then get myself in trouble. Just checking..
 
No issues with the FAR's, however, most likely major issues with the flight school & flight school insurance company. Most rental insurance policy's forbid just this type of situation. One phone call to the flight school should be able to find out the answer. One way around this issues is if the flight school would hire you as a part time CFI then the insurance wouldn't be a problem.
 
No common carriage issues. Flight instruction is exempt from needing an operator's certificate per FAR 119.1:

(e) Except for operations when common carriage is not involved conducted with airplanes having a passenger-seat configuration of 20 seats or more, excluding any required crewmember seat, or a payload capacity of 6,000 pounds or more, this part does not apply to—

(1) Student instruction;

​
Also, just for the sake of diving into Regs, it could be argued there would be no need for a 100hr inspection:

91.409:
(b) Except as provided in paragraph (c) of this section, no person may operate an aircraft carrying any person (other than a crewmember) for hire, and no person may give flight instruction for hire in an aircraft which that person provides, unless within the preceding 100 hours of time in service the aircraft has received an annual or 100-hour inspection​
 
When someone did this at the flight school I worked, we would publicly cane them.

It is generally school plane - school insurance - school instructor. Any deviation from that, you'd better talk to the school manager or owner.
 
No issues with the FAR's, however, most likely major issues with the flight school & flight school insurance company. Most rental insurance policy's forbid just this type of situation. One phone call to the flight school should be able to find out the answer. One way around this issues is if the flight school would hire you as a part time CFI then the insurance wouldn't be a problem.
Yeah I didn't want to lie to the school and say I'm renting it to take up some friends and then sign a logbook that I gave flight instruction. They do require me to buy renters insurance with my check out flight... so I'm not sure if that will cover it or not. I guess that's something I'll have to talk about on the phone tomorrow.

Thanks for the detail clarification though, guys.
 
Renters insurance ALMOST always prohibits flight training. Good luck! It is doable just need to make sure it's done the right way. Just work with the school odds are good that if it cost them nothing to check you out and it's fairly straight forward they would add you as a pastime employee and allow you to fly with your friend.
 
Flight instructing is one of those things that you can advertise and hold out to the public all day long and provide your own airplane for. There are a few other commercial operations where you're allowed to do this. I loved getting my students thinking with this question after we went into gory detail/grey areas on what was legal and not legal when carrying people for hire. "So there's a bunch of examples of what you can't do, now what can you advertise for and provide your own airplane for that is a commercial operation?" You can argue though, that you're not getting paid as a commercial pilot, but as a flight instructor for your instructing, but it's a moot point... It's legal regardless of what you call it when you're selling your instruction.

As to what other people said... The real elephant in the room is if you're covered by insurance, and is the school you're renting the plane from to instruct in okay with it? More than likely they're not ok with that...
 
Thanks for the help guys.

I ended up getting lucky and they allowed me to do it just because I was doing basic lessons for a week before I go home. They had some conditions though that I wasn't doing it for money (from my family friend) and I had to get flight instructors insurance which I ended up purchasing and doing the checkout flight. Since it wasn't serious training and they had the availability to get some money and possibly a new student, I think they allowed me to give him a few lessons.
 
Back
Top