FBO vs Elsewhere and Rookie CFI

therookie

New Member
Hello. I’ve got a slew of questions for you all.

I’m currently taking flight lessons at the local FBO (PUW, tiny airfield in Pullman, WA) and ground instruction through both there and the University of Idaho as well as studying Business Management at UI. I’m on track to have my PPL as of summer and am debating whether I will be better off staying with this program or heading elsewhere.

Hoooold on, before you say read previous posts!
wink.gif
I have looked, but possible missed what I was looking for. Ok, now you can say it. Just wanted to try and save a little face if in fact “John, here is what we think” has already been posted.”

My biggest question is whether I will gain the experience necessary staying here and finishing out school. I plan to be here until Spring 07, when I graduate and then would likely try to move somewhere more city-like and build hours as a CFI until I could get on either at a regional or something corporate. Pullman is an uncontrolled airport surrounded by Class G airspace for at least 25 miles in any direction. If I stay here, I will quite likely be able to land a CFI job with the FBO and gain hours, but I’m not sure how applicable flying from here would be.
The main reasons for being here are that I am established, (housing, school, etc) and my family is nearby, (a two hour drive). While I realize being a pilot I will more than likely be away from them in the future, I figure why not enjoy it now…
For alternative options, I was looking mainly at UND. I am accepted there (I applied a while ago) but financially staying at U of I is a lot better. My tuition here is covered by scholarships, so all I have to pay for is flight training. I’ve also heard mention that UND has a distance learning option based in Spokane, WA, which is somewhat cheaper, but have not looked as much into that as of now.

Separate topic: the FBO I’m taking lessons from has 4 flight instructors, one of which is a brand new CFI. He is the one I am flying with, because the others are booked up for a long way out and his schedule was almost totally open when I started. On my intro flight I went up with a CFI who was very relaxed, confident, and calming to a rookie like me. However, the new guy I am with (the other instructor got a freight job) seems nervous a lot (no doubt because he has to sit and let me fly
shocked.gif
) Today we did some landing practice (first time for me) and he kept grabbing the controls and changing little things, nothing very serious but basically helping me keep attitude. I understand perfectly the safety aspects of it, while on the other hand, if I never have to do it myself, I will end up depending on him and………any advice?

Thanks for reading.

-John
 
So your question is... Should I stay at my uncontrolled airport, find a busier controlled airport, or transfer to UND? Is that right?

Well, IMHO if your goal is to get to an airline job at some point, it might be a good idea to at least get some consistent experience in some busy airspace. It will certainly sharpen up your radio work, your ability to pick out other traffic, and quicken up your thought process.

UND is a good school from what I have heard, and if you can take advantage of the extention school in Spokane, or find an airport that is busy as can be for that neck of the woods that might help you out. The tough part is that it sounds like you have a pretty good setup right now.

DE727UPS is from your area, and I am sure he will have some good advice for you.
 
Well, I can't really help you on your school options, but about the Rookie CFI... give him some slack, he will be more relaxed as he get's more experienced with you. Remember, you will be sitting in his seat too. I guarantee you will be a jumpy as him.

I have 100 hours of dual given and I still get mildly jumpy with new students. Flight Instructors only have one thing going through thier mind... especially on landings... "this kid/guy/chick/whatever is is gonna try to kill me... don't kill me... don't kill me... is he trying to kill me?... don't kill me."

Remember, you are always learning... especially when you are teaching. So just bare with him... he is getting the hang of it.
laugh.gif
 
You registered a day before my 22nd birthday
smile.gif


I live in Coeur d'Alene, little neighbor to the north
smile.gif


My first flight instructor got his first teaching experience from me. You kinda learn from each other, unfortunatly it's on your dime.

If you're not comfortable, or not connecting, or feel you're not learning from the CFI, I would consider another CFI.

No point in wasting money, if all you're thinking about, is how much you don't like your CFI.
 
I'd say cut the CFI some slack. He's just learning, and I'd give it a few more lessons. However, I would at least bring your concerns to his attention. It's possible he's grabbing the controls and not even noticing. I have to keep myself from doing the same thing when flying with friends as a safety pilot. Generally it's the thought of "this landing is really gonna hurt and I should do something," but I have to fight the urge to save the landing. So, it falls under Kell's rule #1: always tell your CFI what's going on in your head. He isn't a mind reader.

As far as the future, it sounds to me like you've got a good set up. Any CFI job is what you make of it. You should try to learn as much from your students as they learn from you, and if you want to get experience is busier airspace, it's not really necessary to pick up and move. Take a couple of cross countries to busier places. This will get you experience in busy airspace without becoming complacent. For example, there are a lot of guys that function well in the airspace around ORL b/c they know how it works. However, they have trouble in TPA and MIA. It's because they ONLY fly around ORL most of the time. When airspace becomes routine, you're not really learning or growing much.
 
I'd stay at PUW if you like it there. Especially, if you think you could get a CFI job at Interstate. I think they do a little charter work, too.

I have a friend from Spokane who just got hired at Ameriflight with 1200 total and 50 multi. He got a business degree at EWU, went the FBO route, instructed, flew VFR 135 in the San Juan's, and will now be logging PIC turbine within six months.

The most important thing for you to do is finish your degree and get your ratings.

I have a friend that's a CFI at UND Spokane. You'll spend more money if you go there than I don't see it as any better training. They fly nice warriors vs your 152 but I don't think it's worth the money getting all wrapped up in their program. I can give you his email, if you'd like.

New CFI's don't stay new for very long. Hopefully, he'll relax in time. Make sure he knows how you feel. He should be approachable and be able to explain why he does things. There is a big difference between him "grabbing the controls" or him giving them a gental tug....like helping you with a little back pressure during steep turns. Even when I get close to the ground, I'll try to help a guy by talking him out of the crash that is about to happen instead of taking over....I save that as a last resort.
 
Thanks everyone,

fyi I'm not trying to make the CFI out to be a bad guy/CFI/etc if it came across that way. Like you guys said, I realize he's as much of a rookie at what he's doing as I am at what I'm doing. Was more seeking reassurance that it's normal and will fade and I will land/practice stalls/maneuvers on my own pre-solo.
crazy.gif
Not the time to be figuring out just what the CFI did all those other times that escaped my notice.
Lol guess I'm still in a bit of $$ shock from paying for the first bit of my training and feeling a little twitchy about things that seem to not be the very fullest I could possible expect from the lessons.
I'm here at UI at least through spring so I've got a while to think on the school issue.
 
Back
Top