FAR 61.51 brain teaser

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lazy8
  • Start date Start date
MidlifeFlyer said:
You can't. Period. If you do and they are listed in your logbook in a way that could lead the FAA to think you were logging them for currency, you could lose your ticket. The FAR is a bit unclear on whether you may log them if you and the student are in actual, but you absolutely can't log them for currency if you are visual any more than you can log an approach that you fly yourself in visual conditions.

Thanks, I'll make those changes then.

MidlifeFlyer said:
And that's your ultimate error - you are trying to justify "logging" with rules that apply to responsibility. They don't.

The rule on logging landing for currency is absolutely clear; not misleading at all:

==============================
§ 61.57 Recent flight experience: Pilot in command.
(a) General experience.
(1) Except as provided in paragraph (e) of this section, no person may act as a pilot in command of an aircraft carrying passengers or of an aircraft certificated for more than one pilot flight crewmember unless that person has made at least three takeoffs and three landings within the preceding 90 days, and -
(I) The person acted as the sole manipulator of the flight controls;
==============================

I'm not sure what part of that you find unclear.

The FAA needs to get it right then. Whats the point of logging things to reflect what you have done if you haven't done them? Whats the point of logging PIC if you weren't PIC? Know what I mean? When you walk into an interview and your logbook says 500 PIC, in reality its not 500 PIC, probably something much less. So then why have a total that doesn't reflect the truth? Not saying that you aren't correct, you are. The FAR's do spell it out. I log PIC because in my *mind*, the FAA wants you to log PIC when you are either sole manipulator of the controls or the responsible authority, I see myself as the responsible authority which *means* if something happens, they are coming for me.

As far as landing goes, according to this FAR, if I had my hands on the controls because a student was going to botch a landing, and THEY had their hands on the controls, then who logs the landing? Nobody? Thats not possible right because a take-off is always accompanied by a landing. So who logs the landing according to this FAR definition? See this is where I find it unclear.

Its not that I'm an idiot and can't read the FAR's. I can, but the above mentioned situation is not covered. If the FAA wants us to comply with black and white regs, then I think they should be black and white.

I'm not saying that this Reg. isn't black and white, but if I have to help a student control the airplane on a landing, there is nothing in the FAR's that state "If a student makes an instructor assisted landing, then both log the landing" or "only the student logs the landing" . The student was not "sole manipulator of the controls". The same can be said if I take the airplane from a student on an approach because they went below an altitude or off course, and I get the airplane back on course and give it back to them, how would that be logged? While I didn't fly the whole approach, the student was not the sole manipulator of the controls during the entire approach.

I'm not trying to be controversial here, I'm a new instructor so I'm trying to do things legally here, thats why I pose the question. I know instructors that just log everything, and I'm trying to be cautious on how I do this because I talk to different instructors who log different things and each has their own interpretation of how to log despite the black and white regs, like the above mentioned situations.

Now I'm not trying to maintain currency by having the student do the work. I usually have the opportunity to demonstrate an approach or landing now an then, which of course I really enjoy because I get to fly it :) , and those I consider currency. I have left my landing column blank so far except for the landings I've demonstrated. I've done this because I know instructors that log them, and ones who don't. If the student makes a totally unassisted landing, of course I know the FAR says I can't log it, so I don't. But the ones where I have to have my hands and feet manipulating the controls so we don't land on a taxi light, I consider those a landing.

Again please don't take this a personal attack or that I don't disagree with you. This is just an area that I want to make sure I get correct. I'm learning as I go along and I'm not ashamed to ask for clarification or help. Thats all. :)
 
Airdale said:
The FAA needs to get it right then. Whats the point of logging things to reflect what you have done if you haven't done them? Whats the point of logging PIC if you weren't PIC?

It's to make it easier to meet the requirements for various ratings. Like how the instrument rating requires 50 hours XC PIC. If a student and instructor do a XC together, that is legitimate XC experience. Both pilots get to log it.

Airdale said:
As far as landing goes, according to this FAR, if I had my hands on the controls because a student was going to botch a landing, and THEY had their hands on the controls, then who logs the landing? Nobody? Thats not possible right because a take-off is always accompanied by a landing. So who logs the landing according to this FAR definition? See this is where I find it unclear.

That's correct, technically neither of you should log the landing...for currency. That reg deals strictly with maintaining currency for carrying passengers. Remember, you only need to log the experience/training required for a checkride or what is needed to maintain currency. Everything else is optional.

Airdale said:
I'm not trying to be controversial here, I'm a new instructor so I'm trying to do things legally here, thats why I pose the question. I know instructors that just log everything, and I'm trying to be cautious on how I do this because I talk to different instructors who log different things and each has their own interpretation of how to log despite the black and white regs, like the above mentioned situations.

Thanks for caring! Seriously. I talk to way too many instructors who don't know what the regs really say and they just do whatever makes sense to them, which may or may not be correct.
 
Airdale said:
Again please don't take this a personal attack or that I don't disagree with you. This is just an area that I want to make sure I get correct. I'm learning as I go along and I'm not ashamed to ask for clarification or help. That's all. :)
It didn't even cross my mind to think it was an attack. I think it was Red Skelton who used to say when a joke bombed, "Hey, I just say 'em, I don't explain 'em." I guess I take the opposite point, I just try to explain 'em, but I didn't write 'em. :)

jrh's explanation is perfect. "61.51 PIC" is for the purpose of allowing pilots to log certain things for certificates and ratings. I think the problem is just that the FAA used PIC a word that has another, far more important meaning.

I don't think that many folks have a problem with the FAA saying that time spent by a pilot manipulating the controls of an airplane on a cross country flight, whether or not he's the one in charge, should count toward the instrument rating cross country requirements. And if the FAA decided to call it sortoflikepicbutnot time and you had a column for that in your logbook, most folks would think that was ok also.

BTW, at one time it =was= called something else. Before the FAA Act, under the old CAR (we're talking 60 years ago), advanced certificates and ratings had requirements for a certain amount of "solo" time. And "solo" didn't mean "alone in the aircraft" like it does under the FAR. It meant (you probably guessed it) "sole manipulator" of the controls.
 
Back
Top