FAR 61.51 brain teaser

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lazy8
  • Start date Start date
L

Lazy8

Guest
Hey folks,

A CFI trainee brought this up the other day... This is out of the 2006 ASA FAR/AIM:



61.51(e) Logging pilot-in-command flight time
(1) A sport, recreational, private, or commercial pilot may log pilot-in-command time only for that flight time during which that person-
(i) Is the sole manipulator of the controls of an aircraft for which the pilot is rated or has privileges;
(ii) Is the sole occupant of the aircraft; or
(iii) Except for a recreational pilot, is acting as pilot in command of an aircraft on which more than one pilot is required under the type certification of the aircraft or the regulations under which the flight is conducted


​
Okay so at first glance you're probably saying, "Yeah so?" But look a litte closer. Shouldn't subpart (i) have an or at the end like this: (i) Is the sole manipulator of the controls of an aircraft for which the pilot is rated or has privileges; or

It makes sense for recreational, sport, and private trainees;however, the way it reads to me is that a commercial trainee cannot log PIC time unless they are the sole manipulator of the controls AND sole occupant of the aircraft... Which I think is bogus. Am I missing some kind of gramatical meaning with the semicolon?

Yes I know I'm a nerd.:nana2:

Thoughts?

Lazy8
 
If I list three things in this sentence like one, two, or three did I put an or between each of them?
 
mikecweb said:
If I list three things in this sentence like one, two, or three did I put an or between each of them?

So a Private, Recreational, and Sport trainee can log PIC just by being the sole manipulator of the controls with the instructor in the right seat?

:)

l8
 
mikecweb said:
If I list three things in this sentence like one, two, or three did I put an or between each of them?

You'll notice this wording on all the regulations that are of multiple applications, as opposed to all inclusive. In that case, three subparts would be listed:
(i)........... ,
(ii)..........and,
(iii)..........

-ColM
 
Lazy8 said:
So a Private, Recreational, and Sport trainee can log PIC just by being the sole manipulator of the controls with the instructor in the right seat?

:)

l8


Not as a trainee --- read 61.51(e)(1)(i) again . . . the pilot must be rated.
 
Pilot Hopeful said:
Not as a trainee --- read 61.51(e)(1)(i) again . . . the pilot must be rated.

that makes sense... but then it says or has privileges. If your student is signed off to solo does he/she have privileges?

l8
 
A sport pilot does not technically have category and class ratings. He would have a logbook endorsement specifying the 'privileges' he is entitled to. That would fall under par. (i) also.
 
"(iii) Except for a recreational pilot, is acting as pilot in command of an aircraft on which more than one pilot is required under the type certification of the aircraft or the regulations under which the flight is conducted"

This referrs to a captain of an aircraft requiring more than one pilot, acting as NFP and logging PIC time even thoug he did not touch the controlls.
 
Lazy8 said:
Shouldn't subpart (i) have an or at the end like this: (i) Is the sole manipulator of the controls of an aircraft for which the pilot is rated or has privileges; or
No. As mikecweb said, the single "or" is enough to make all of the listed subsections in the alternative.

That wasn't an FAR brain teaser. It was an English quiz.
 
Lazy8 said:
So a Private, Recreational, and Sport trainee can log PIC just by being the sole manipulator of the controls with the instructor in the right seat?
Yes, so long as the pilot (other than a sport pilot) is rated in the airplane - that means that the airplane that is being flown fits the aircraft category and class ratings that are listed on the back of the pilot certificate (and the type rating, if a type rating is required).

(As B767 pointed out, sport pilots don't have ratings; to log PIC with an instructor they would need to already have a "privilege" endorsement for that make and model aircraft).

FWIW, here's the pointer to the logging PIC FAQ on my web site:

http://www.midlifeflight.com/faq/faq.php?s=2#3
 
MidlifeFlyer said:
No. As mikecweb said, the single "or" is enough to make all of the listed subsections in the alternative.

That wasn't an FAR brain teaser. It was an English quiz.

If it's and/or for any of the listed subparts then how do you distinguish which certificate/rating applies to all or just some of the subparts? (Is the sole manipulator of the controls of an aircraft for which the pilot is rated or has privileges;) For instance, a student pilot training for a Private certificate who is signed off to solo has "Privileges" does he/she not? Therefore, it looks to me like the FARs can be read as the student pilot now has the ability to log PIC time with the instructor onboard (because each subpart is considered an alternative).

I'm not asking 'how to log time' (I know how it's properly done). This one just threw me for a loop when it was brought to my attention. And I admit, I'm not an English master!

Thanks for the comments!

l8
 
Lazy8 said:
If it's and/or for any of the listed subparts then how do you distinguish which certificate/rating applies to all or just some of the subparts? For instance, a student solo pilot who is signed off to solo has "Privileges" does he/she not? Therefore, it looks to me like the FARs can be read as the student pilot now has the ability to log PIC time with the instructor onboard.
I'm not sure what you mean. Let's go back to the original "sole manipulator" part of the reg and read the words:

==============================
61.51(e) Logging pilot-in-command flight time

(1) A sport, recreational, private, or commercial pilot may log pilot-in-command time only for that flight time during which that person-

(i) Is the sole manipulator of the controls of an aircraft for which the pilot is rated or has privileges;
(ii) Is the sole occupant of the aircraft; or
(iii) Except for a recreational pilot, is acting as pilot in command of an aircraft on which more than one pilot is required under the type certification of the aircraft or the regulations under which the flight is conducted
==============================

Maybe I'm being dense but I really don't understand what words make you think that a regulation that says it applies to a "sport, recreational, private, or commercial pilot" applies to a student pilot?
 
Behold! I have seen the light!

Thanks Mark. One too many lessons this week. :)

l8
 
Lazy8 said:
Behold! I have seen the light!

Thanks Mark. One too many lessons this week. :)

l8
Not a big deal. The syntax is English, but of a technical outlining sort that we don't see except in technical manuals and "regulese." We don't use it every day (well, some of us don't; others have no real choice).

Besides, the FAR, like any other set of government regulations, has a tendency to make us think they are more complex than they sometimes are - we sometimes go out of our way to find things to be confused by.
 
I once read a joke called FAR part Zero. It was about how the FAA shall right the regulations so that no pilot can understand them, and if any pilot begins to understand the regulations they should be rewritten.

It was hilarious. It was about 5-6 years ago that I read them, and I haven't seen anything on it since. Anyone familiar with it. Would like a link or copy if it's available.
 
RynoB said:
I once read a joke called FAR part Zero. It was about how the FAA shall right the regulations so that no pilot can understand them, and if any pilot begins to understand the regulations they should be rewritten.

It was hilarious. It was about 5-6 years ago that I read them, and I haven't seen anything on it since. Anyone familiar with it. Would like a link or copy if it's available.
Looking for this?

==============================
Proposed Federal Aviation Regulation Act

1000.A No pilot or pilots, or person or persons acting on the direction or suggestion or supervision of the pilot or pilots may try, or attempt to try or make or make attempt to try to comprehend or understand any or all, in whole or in part of the herein mentioned Federal Aviation Regulations, except as authorized by the Administrator or an agent appointed by, or inspected by the Administrator.

1000.B If the pilot, or group of associated pilots becomes aware of, or realizes, or detects, or discovers or finds that he, or she, or they, are or have been beginning to understand the Federal Aviation Regulations, they must immediately, within three (3) days notify, in writing, the Administrator.

1000.C Upon receipt of the above mentioned notice of impending comprehension, the Administrator will immediately rewrite the Federal Aviation Regulations in such a manner as to eliminate any further comprehension hazards.

1000.D The Administrator may, at his or her option, require the offending pilot, or pilots, to attend remedial instruction in Federal Aviation Regulations until such time that the pilot is too confused to be capable of understanding anything.
==============================
 
Hey Midlife, excellent FAQ page you have. I learned a few things from reading it. :)

I do have a question though.
At the school I graduated from and now work for, our students start off by getting their Private Multi-Engine add-on. Once they have this, we start instrument training. This raises two questions that I have that no one has really pointed out to me during my training or during my CFI training.

Once the student is rated in the airplane, they are told to log "PIC" time from then on. My question is, can they do that when I'm training them for their Instrument rating? What about when we are training in actual IMC? Can they log PIC then although they are not instrument rated?

Now I logged what I was instructed to log when I was a student, but now as an instructor when I take my students flying, especially during the instrument training, I can't see how they are acting PIC. Because I am responsible for the flight as the instructor, I am constantly monitoring and tasking them throughout the flight. Their job is flying the airplane, shoot the approach and take directions. My job is monitor them, watch for traffic, pay attention to FAR'S, maintain sit. awareness etc. I always tell my students that in the event of an actual emergency, it's my airplane. How do you feel about that?

My second overall question is reguarding how I log time as instructor. Now according to the FAR's, my student is rated in the airplane and is sole manipulator of the controls UNTIL they screw up and I take the controls. So because I am sitting there doing my "instructor" thing, can I log that as PIC? I do log it as PIC because in the event of an accident, the FAA is coming after me because I'm the Instructor, reguardless of who is "supposed" to be the PIC. So because its my tail, I log PIC anytime I instruct in the airplane (of course I am fully rated in that airplane). Is it wrong to log PIC time in this case?

Also I log approaches, even when the student does them under the hood. I log them because I, the instructor, am once again responsible for the safety of the flight and compliance with the approach procedures. When my student is doing their procedure turn, I'm already flying the missed in my head. So while I'm not physically touching the controls (in most cases of course :) ) I am always one step ahead of the student on the approach. It is because of my role during the approach, that I log the approach. Once again if we were to violate a FAR or have a safety infraction during the approach, the FAA is coming after me, not my student, so I log the approach. Is this correct also? Because the FAR's aren't totally clear on that.

Basically my philosophy is, that during the flight, at anytime, I am responsible for the safety of my student, myself and the safety of the airplane. I log PIC because of this.

Many a times I have to "help" a student on the controls landing the aircraft, so I log those landings too. I just try to be honest with logbook logging, because the FAR's tend to be a little misleading on this. Thanks!
 
Airdale said:
Hey Midlife, excellent FAQ page you have. I learned a few things from reading it. :)
Thanks. I try.

Once the student is rated in the airplane, they are told to log "PIC" time from then on. My question is, can they do that when I'm training them for their Instrument rating? What about when we are training in actual IMC? Can they log PIC then although they are not instrument rated?
Yup. Since you read the FAQ, it's covered by Rule No. 1. 61.51 says you can log PIC when the sole manipulator of the controls of an =aircraft= you're rated for. It doesn't require that you be rated for the =conditions= you are flying in.

Now I logged what I was instructed to log when I was a student, but now as an instructor when I take my students flying, especially during the instrument training, I can't see how they are acting PIC.
They're not. They are NOT "acting" PIC. They are "logging" PIC. That's the whole point.

"Acting" and "logging" PIC are completely different things. it's sometimes hard to get our heads around this because the FAA decided to use the same word to mean two different things, but try this:

"Acting" as the pilot in command of a flight is all about authority, duty and responsibility. The rules about being the pilot in command reflect that. Special endorsements, currency requirements, etc.

"Logging" PIC time under 61.51, however, has nothing to do with any of that. It just reflects a series of completely arbitrary decisions by the FAA about what kind of flight time it will let you count toward certificates and ratings. It really doesn't man anything more than that. That's why employers often have their own definitions of what they want to see on an application.

My second overall question is regarding how I log time as instructor. Now according to the FAR's, my student is rated in the airplane and is sole manipulator of the controls UNTIL they screw up and I take the controls. So because I am sitting there doing my "instructor" thing, can I log that as PIC?
My FAQ doesn't cover instructors very much. But instructors all log PIC when they are teaching in an aircraft. But, remember that it has nothing to do with duty authority or responsibility for the flight. A CFI who hasn't had a medical in 10 years and hasn't passed a FR in 30 still logs PIC when giving instruction because part of 61.51 says so:

==============================
61.51(e)(3). An authorized instructor may log as pilot-in-command time all flight time while acting as an authorized instructor.
==============================

Also I log approaches, even when the student does them under the hood.
You can't. Period. If you do and they are listed in your logbook in a way that could lead the FAA to think you were logging them for currency, you could lose your ticket. The FAR is a bit unclear on whether you may log them if you and the student are in actual, but you absolutely can't log them for currency if you are visual any more than you can log an approach that you fly yourself in visual conditions.

Basically my philosophy is, that during the flight, at anytime, I am responsible for the safety of my student, myself and the safety of the airplane. I log PIC because of this.
And that's your ultimate error - you are trying to justify "logging" with rules that apply to responsibility. They don't.

Many a times I have to "help" a student on the controls landing the aircraft, so I log those landings too. I just try to be honest with logbook logging, because the FAR's tend to be a little misleading on this.
The rule on logging landing for currency is absolutely clear; not misleading at all:

==============================
§ 61.57 Recent flight experience: Pilot in command.
(a) General experience.
(1) Except as provided in paragraph (e) of this section, no person may act as a pilot in command of an aircraft carrying passengers or of an aircraft certificated for more than one pilot flight crewmember unless that person has made at least three takeoffs and three landings within the preceding 90 days, and -
(I) The person acted as the sole manipulator of the flight controls;
==============================

I'm not sure what part of that you find unclear.

There was a recent article in a magazine that gave the top three words to understanding regulations:

1. read the words.
2. read the words.
3. read the words.

Good advice. I think you need to go back to those regulations and just read them. They're in regulese, but they really aren't that difficult.

I'd add a fourth rule:

4. Don't think about what it =should= say.
 
Back
Top