FAA / Drone regulations / pilot jobs

Discussion of capabilities is generally frowned upon. Certainly in a public forum like this.
I really am getting tired of this "national security" nonsense. Not specific to this issue, either.

If divulging secrets a la Bradley Chelsea Manning or Edward Snowden to the public is "aiding the enemy," then I have to wonder who the enemy really is.
 
All good points. But, like you, I have a close friend who is also UAV. He did it for the army when we first went over to Afghanistan, and now does it for a company who contracts through the government. He instructs and does acceptance flights. His view of what's going on is completely different over there. One the same note, you can't compare what's going on in a war zone to here the same you can't compare military aviation to civilian aviation state side. They are both their own animal. It's an apples to oranges look.

In short, I'm not to worried about UAV's flying around over here. I've already dealt with them. Palmdale is nearly in my back yard. As much as he is allowed to tell me, piston powered UAV's have the same level of redundancy built in as a single engine piston, and the Global Hawk has the same as a turbine powered aircraft if not more. But, all that information is supposed to be secret, so he can't go into much detail.
I guess my concern with UAVs in the NAS is what in the Sam Hill do we need those kind of capabilities over freaking US citizens for?
 
I guess my concern with UAVs in the NAS is what in the Sam Hill do we need those kind of capabilities over freaking US citizens for?

Agreed that the majority of the purposes will probably be less than desirable.

Edit to add: I can think of one thing that they can replace. I know for a fact that the FBI uses 182rg's to look for grow houses with IR cameras.
 
I really am getting tired of this "national security" nonsense. Not specific to this issue, either.

If divulging secrets a la Bradley Chelsea Manning or Edward Snowden to the public is "aiding the enemy," then I have to wonder who the enemy really is.

One of the posters asked about specific frequencies and that's no bueno. While it's not likely someone could hijack an aircraft using that information they could certainly jam it. The layman simply does not need that information.

The radar system I posted about earlier is unclass and available for commercial purchase so it's fair game. You can read all about it on the company website.

The guys who want to kill you and enslave your sisters, mothers, and girlfriends are the enemy in this case. Right now they're far more of a threat to me than you so you'll forgive me if I'm not worried about what you think is nonsense.

I guess my concern with UAVs in the NAS is what in the Sam Hill do we need those kind of capabilities over freaking US citizens for?

That fight was lost a century ago thanks to a 1924 supreme court decision called the Open Field Doctrine and yet again when the addition of gyro stabilized camera systems became common on police helicopters.

The two main functional differences between a police helicopter and a UAS are:
1. Loiter time
2. The police helicopter has two armed agents on board.
 
One of the posters asked about specific frequencies and that's no bueno. While it's not likely someone could hijack an aircraft using that information they could certainly jam it. The layman simply does not need that information.

The radar system I posted about earlier is unclass and available for commercial purchase so it's fair game. You can read all about it on the company website.

The guys who want to kill you and enslave your sisters, mothers, and girlfriends are the enemy in this case. Right now they're far more of a threat to me than you so you'll forgive me if I'm not worried about what you think is nonsense.
I'm really not even sure how to respond to that.

(And yes, I remember September 11th.)
 
I'm really not even sure how to respond to that.

(And yes, I remember September 11th.)

Then next time, don't.

These little one line responses that do nothing to further the debate (not just directed at you) are getting a little ridiculous. IMO, and again, not just directed at you, either post up something worth while, or post nothing. I may not like what your response may be, but at least it could show your to be intelligent, instead of appearing to just be trolling.
 
One the same note, you can't compare what's going on in a war zone to here the same you can't compare military aviation to civilian aviation state side. They are both their own animal. It's an apples to oranges look.

I am not. The work @esa17 does saves American lives. No argument from me about the necessity of UAVs in war zones or their usefulness. @esa17 did a very interesting write up and perspective.

In short, I'm not to worried about UAV's flying around over here.

You should be.

I've already dealt with them.

How so domestically? Or are you talking about the use of UAVs in military applications? Because like you said, you can't compare the two.

Palmdale is nearly in my back yard.

That is nice, but Palmdale isn't this whole country. Say the NYPD amasses a fleet of UAVs for various operations. If you can't see multiple scenarios where there is a high probability of a UAV and a civilian aircraft get close then you are being extremely naive to put it bluntly.

As much as he is allowed to tell me, piston powered UAV's have the same level of redundancy built in as a single engine piston, and the Global Hawk has the same as a turbine powered aircraft if not more.

Ok, then explain this...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran–U.S._RQ-170_incident

But, all that information is supposed to be secret, so he can't go into much detail.

I understand that, but there are going to be a multiple of problems with UAVs intermingled in the National Airspace System. Do I think UAVs play a useful role in the future of this country? Absolutely. However, we must be SUPER careful and hesitant to the application of them for various reasons mentioned in this thread.
 
I am not. The work @esa17 does saves American lives. No argument from me about the necessity of UAVs in war zones or their usefulness. @esa17 did a very interesting write up and perspective.

Yeah, but I don't like the idea that these things can watch me having sex with my sister and girl cousin, in the back woods of Louisiana. It's already stressful enough having alligators present!

**insert banjo music..... MEOW**

:sarcasm:<--------- just in case some of you actually believed me!
 
Last edited:
Then next time, don't.

These little one line responses that do nothing to further the debate (not just directed at you) are getting a little ridiculous. IMO, and again, not just directed at you, either post up something worth while, or post nothing. I may not like what your response may be, but at least it could show your to be intelligent, instead of appearing to just be trolling.
Alright, complete sentences you shall have.

My chief beef nowadays with the national security state has to do with the proliferation of "classified" or "sensitive" information. Before I go any further, I take seriously my obligations under 49 USC and 49 CFR to protect SSI, and I have an even deeper respect for people with full on secret/top secret/etc. real security clearances who take seriously their obligations to protect same. I have a similar admiration and a huge amount of gratitude for the fighting men and women of our uniformed forces, am hesitant to put them into danger and wish to see them brought home safely wherever they may be deployed.

Some secrets need to be kept. It's a Bad Idea for people to know, for instance, details of the deployment of forces and their plans. But what I don't understand is the proliferation of information classified since 9/11, and the disproportionate response that unauthorized disclosure, particularly of programs (renditions, PRISM, etc.) or actions (the murder of foreign civilians, and so on) that the American public does have, in my opinion, a right to know about. We pay for it, and these actions are performed by the government of, for, and by the people. I also think, more and more, the American public is shielded from the details of actions taken on their behalf. Military and national security forces work for, and are funded by, the American taxpayer - and I wish to be proud of and at least somewhat better informed of their actions on my behalf. And I'm extremely disappointed in the Obama Administration's approach to leakers (or whistleblowers, depending on your point of view).

Consider e.g. Syria. Right now the powers that be are trying to sell us on another war. It's 2002-2004 all over again - "Trust us, we know it was the Syrian government who used those weapons." The last time I trusted the government, at face value, on a matter of whether or not to involve the armed forces abroad, I got a trillion dollar plus boondoggle and the United States suffered severe damage to its credibility and international reputation -- and I'm not at all sure what, precisely, was accomplished beyond the deposing of Saddam Hussein, and growing al-Qaida in Iraq. I'd rather not repeat that without some credible information, Adlai Stevenson-at-the-United Nations-style.

And I guess, on another major front, I'm just tired.

I was 12 when a bunch of jerks hijacked airplanes and flew them into WTC and the Pentagon, and since then I and my fellow citizens have lived under a perpetual state of yellow alert. I have a severe case of terror alert fatigue, and I haven't been presented (beyond Osama bin Laden/al-Qaida) with just "who" the "enemy" is. To quote Top Secret America:
We believe that the primary reason [for the extended state of terror alerts] is that the government has still not engaged the American people in an honest conversation about terrorism and the appropriate U.S. response to it.
Edited indefinite pronoun for context.

I believe it is LONG past time for the American public to have this dialogue, for our liberties are worth protecting and have faced major damage since September 11, 2001. It's also damned expensive, and with such a major investment I want to see specific, credible outcomes data beyond "Look! No (big, foreign, Islam-associated) acts of terror!"

I exercise vigilance at work against acts of terrorism, sure - but I'm not going to live in continuous fear, and I don't want to see public policy decisions, which is what military/national security actions made based solely on the fear of the boogeyman. "Terrorism" is this generation's Communism.

This project and its companion book are amazing looks at the staggering size and implications of the homeland security-industrial complex. It's big, it's complicated, it's damned expensive and best (or worst, arguably) of all, nobody public knows about it or has meaningful oversight. Those who are supposed to oversee it (Feinstein, for instance) will merely say "THIS IS ABOUT PROTECTING AMERICA!" and leave it at that. Not. Good. Enough.
 
Alright, complete sentences you shall have.
...snip...

"THIS IS ABOUT PROTECTING AMERICA!" and leave it at that. Not. Good. Enough.

The contrast between what I originally responded to and what is presented here are apples to oranges and you'll get no debate from me. I whole heartedly agree that We the People should be made aware of the intel we have collected that makes Syria a national security threat. Share everything but the HUMINT so as not to endanger the lives of those imbedded....But, that's a different thread.

Having flown a parallel approach with a 737 loaded with PAX in a UAS I can tell you first hand so that as long as you have professionals flying both aircraft and and the tower this will be no more of an issue than me flying a Mooney into Dallas Love.
 
I'll buy the last part. And yeah, when you ask me to employ the military I'm going to be very leery. "Fool me once..."


SSSSSSEENT FFFFROMM FMS KEYBOAAAAAAARDDDDD
 
Just checked. uavcareers.com and uascareers.com are already registered.

I can imagine the posts. "I am an ATP-UAV and I can't even get an interview with my regional UAV operator."

I'm a OIT (Operator In Training), which means I assist the main operator by getting him coffee and giving him a massage as-needed. Can I log that time as OSIC time?
 
I'm a OIT (Operator In Training), which means I assist the main operator by getting him coffee and giving him a massage as-needed. Can I log that time as OSIC time?
Yes!
If not, contact the labor dept at once!!!!!
 
One of the posters asked about specific frequencies and that's no bueno. While it's not likely someone could hijack an aircraft using that information they could certainly jam it. The layman simply does not need that information.

NOWHERE in my post did I ask about your frequencies. I asked about lag, and explained the frequencies used in the hobbyist world.
 
I am not. The work @esa17 does saves American lives. No argument from me about the necessity of UAVs in war zones or their usefulness. @esa17 did a very interesting write up and perspective.



You should be.



How so domestically? Or are you talking about the use of UAVs in military applications? Because like you said, you can't compare the two.



That is nice, but Palmdale isn't this whole country. Say the NYPD amasses a fleet of UAVs for various operations. If you can't see multiple scenarios where there is a high probability of a UAV and a civilian aircraft get close then you are being extremely naive to put it bluntly.



Ok, then explain this...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran–U.S._RQ-170_incident



I understand that, but there are going to be a multiple of problems with UAVs intermingled in the National Airspace System. Do I think UAVs play a useful role in the future of this country? Absolutely. However, we must be SUPER careful and hesitant to the application of them for various reasons mentioned in this thread.


I am not. The work @esa17 does saves American lives. No argument from me about the necessity of UAVs in war zones or their usefulness. @esa17 did a very interesting write up and perspective.



You should be.



How so domestically? Or are you talking about the use of UAVs in military applications? Because like you said, you can't compare the two.



That is nice, but Palmdale isn't this whole country. Say the NYPD amasses a fleet of UAVs for various operations. If you can't see multiple scenarios where there is a high probability of a UAV and a civilian aircraft get close then you are being extremely naive to put it bluntly.



Ok, then explain this...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran–U.S._RQ-170_incident



I understand that, but there are going to be a multiple of problems with UAVs intermingled in the National Airspace System. Do I think UAVs play a useful role in the future of this country? Absolutely. However, we must be SUPER careful and hesitant to the application of them for various reasons mentioned in this thread.


This is going to be difficult from a phone, so near with me. I've dealt with the acceptance and testing flights done out of Palmdale and El Mirage for years. They don't use restricted airspace for it. They fly in and under the Lynx arrival into Van Nuys and Burbank. So depending on what equipment I was flying depended.on how I chose to handle them.

If you think a police agency is going to "amass a fleet" of UAV's, I say you are the one who is being naive. The cost would outweigh the benefit, lets be realistic here. A fleet?

Iran is of no.concern to me. I'm not. Using that that landed a UAV with "little to no damage." Remember the video of their stealth fighter? Bow come the bottom of the UAV in those pictures is covered. Accidents happen as well. Hijackings happens. If theybdid, it's nondifferent, and if you think we are immune as pilots up front, you are sorely mistaken.

I do agree with your last point. We must be careful with how we integrate them into this country's NAS. But that's not my job to worry about, hence, why I'm not worried about it. I don't have the time nor the man power to effect the change I'd like to see, and what has been talked about with how that will happen thus far, I can deal with. When a plan comes out that's worth me getting my panties about, then I'll be upset about it. Until then, getting upset or angry about it is wasting my time and energy.
 
Last edited:
This is going to be difficult from a phone, so near with me. I've dealt with the acceptance and testing flights done out of Palmdale and El Mirage for years. They don't use restricted airspace for it. They fly in and under the Lynx arrival into Van Nuys and Burbank. So depending on what equipment I was flying depended.on how I chose to handle them.

Which means nothing as acceptance and testing flights are done under ideal, highly controlled conditions.

If you think a police agency is going to "amass a fleet" of UAV's, I say you are the one who is being naive. The cost would outweigh the benefit, lets be realistic here. A fleet?

If I told you that on September 10, 2001 the NYPD, in three years, would have field offices in places like Tel Aviv, London, Frankfurt, and Dubai (the NYPD has eleven international field offices open since 9/11) and that they would aquire SAMs (which they most likely have) you would be telling me I was 'naive' and I needed to be 'realistic'.

Iran is of no.concern to me.

So what happened with that drone?

I do agree with your last point. We must be careful with how we integrate them into this country's NAS. But that's not my job to worry about, hence, why I'm not worried about it. I don't have the time nor the man power to effect the change I'd like to see, and what has been talked about with how that will happen thus far, I can deal with. When a plan comes out that's worth me getting my panties about, then I'll be upset about it. Until then, getting upset or angry about it is wasting my time and energy.

Ok.
 
Last edited:
Which means nothing as acceptance and testing flights are done under ideal, highly controlled conditions.



If I told you that on September 10, 2001 the NYPD would have field offices in places like Tel Aviv, London, Frankfurt, and Dubai (the NYPD has eleven international field offices open since 9/11) and that they would aquire SAMs (which they most likely have) you would be telling me I was 'naive' and I needed to be 'realistic'.



So what happened with that drone?



Ok.

Acceptance and testing were done in just about all weather conditions save for stuff that was dangerous. Just like the way they currently operate most 91 GA Liston stuff. Still a non event. And never a conic. See and avoid. You are lookingnoutside the aircraft right?

The field offices in foreign countries that the HYPE put up are a joke. Are they even manned? I would reason that the field offices are a feel good measure. Do they even have any police authority there? Are they carrying weapons there?

I really don't know what happened, and neither do you. Same as we don't know what happened in a few crashes that happen here stateside with small aircraft of dollar size. Some things are just a mystery. Parts fail. When was the last time you flew without an MEL?
 
Acceptance and testing were done in just about all weather conditions save for stuff that was dangerous. Just like the way they currently operate most 91 GA Liston stuff. Still a non event. And never a conic. See and avoid. You are lookingnoutside the aircraft right?

It is a lot easier to see and avoid when you are actually in the aircraft.

The field offices in foreign countries that the HYPE put up are a joke. Are they even manned? I would reason that the field offices are a feel good measure. Do they even have any police authority there? Are they carrying weapons there?

You don't know what you are talking about here. Shortly after the WTC was attacked, the NYPD was extremely frustrated with our National Intelligent Agencies so they took matters in their own hands, opening these stations. The vast material with a simple google search spells all this out nicely, but here is one for you to look at....

http://www.esquire.com/features/world-trade-center-safe-0913?click=main_sr


I really don't know what happened, and neither do you. Same as we don't know what happened in a few crashes that happen here stateside with small aircraft of dollar size. Some things are just a mystery. Parts fail. When was the last time you flew without an MEL?

A mystery? Wow, that is reassuring with the advancement of UAVs in the NAS. Also, when parts fail, they should not bring down an aircraft. That is why you have redundant systems like you claim these UAVs have.
 
Back
Top