DOT axes 27 subsidised routes over poor load factor

That's about the same as the cost to add electrification to existing railways. Which would have a better and more immediate effect on improving roadways, increasing travel speed and reducing pollution.

Existing railways in the US are privately owned. It's up to those companies to upgrade them. The highways, or at least most of them, are public.
 
Well I disagree except for reducing congestion. Not very many use rail because it’s a PITA and has limited destinations, and also is expensive even subsidized. Your bang for your buck would be much higher with electrifying highways.

Not passenger rail, freight. Expanding freight rail capacity, means moving trucks off the roads, achieving all the above.
 
Existing railways in the US are privately owned. It's up to those companies to upgrade them. The highways, or at least most of them, are public.
I wish it was that simple. Amtrak is a quasi-public corporation (sort of like the Post Office) that exists on their own revenues and very sizable subsidies, primarily Federal (they also operate some regional lines under contract from states & other regional bodies). The private railroads you speak of are all long-haul freight (think FedEx Air and UPS Air, running on terrestrial steel bands). Most of the right of ways are owned by private RR companies. They are maintained by the private companies, from the fees Amtrak and the regional lines pay to use them, and from those RR companies' freight revenue.

A few examples: MARC (Maryland Area Regional Commuter) is owned by a division of the Maryland Department of Transportation (a State agency), and operates on right of way owned by the Baltimore & Ohio RR and Amtrak. They have contracted with Bombardier Transportation to run it (Yup, that Bombardier).

New Jersey Transit is a NJ state agency, formed to operate rail, light rail and bus services. In some cases, they provide buses to private bus companies operating commuter services (which sounds like a subsidy to me). PATH (Port Authority Trans Hudson - which should properly be PASH, since it runs in a tunnel under ['Sub'] the Hudson River), is owned by the Port Authority of NY and NJ, the same folks who own & operate EWR, LGA and JFK. It runs from Newark to the Wall Street area of New York City - most of the other rail service goes into mid-town Manhattan, because that's where those tunnels end.

SEPTA (Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority, even though its acronym sounds like a disease) is a regional public transportation authority, chartered by the Commonwealth of PA but run by the multi-city & county Philadelphia area region that it serves. It operates all the terrestrial mass transit modalities: rail, light rail, rapid transit, subway and bus. It is built largely around the commuter operations originally established by the Pennsylvania Railroad and the Reading Railroad, both of whom went bust. (Many of the stations are located on Reading Avenue in towns it serves. Or on a Monopoly game board.) It is a classic hub-and-spoke system, built to bring commuters from the suburbs to the jobs in center city. Now that most of the jobs are located in surrounding municipalities, you have to take the train from your town into downtown, then transfer to another train (spoke) to your destination, Or to a bus from that station to your job destination. The roadways, being newer, reflect this shift and take you much more directly to/from home, job, etc. The only truly new rail route they've built runs from center city to the Philadelphia airport. I'm ashamed to say, in ten years of living around there, I never took it to PHL. Hub & spoke meant it had two separate trains, and took twice as long as driving. But for some people, it worked.

There are more examples, but until you get down to some bus-only lines, they are basically not private. There's even a good case to be made that those bus lines are in part subsidized by governments who build the roads they run on.

The case for subsidies for any form of mass transit is based upon the fact they they benefit society as a whole, They reduce the number of individual cars on the roads, they enable business development, they pollute less than other means of transportation, etc. If you charged the fare necessary for them to truly turn a profit, the ridership would go w-a-a-y down and they could not exist. But we need them.

Air transportation shares many of the same issues: The air traffic control system (including Mr. Echo's salary) is subsidized by the government, so planes don't run into each other, as they did before the mid-1950s. Ditto TSA, dammit. Airports and runways are built largely with tax money. Sure, some fees come from end users for all of these, but far less than the real cost (both capital investment and operating cost) of the entire system. Could some parts be more efficiently run? Of course. But replace it? Like it or not, our system of a capitalist society has some socialistic aspects. Passed by both Democrats and Republicans over our country's history.

Some things we, as a society, demand are simply impractical to operate entirely in the private sector. Public schools and public libraries are good for their towns, and even though I'm childless by choice, I won't move into a town without good ones. They make the whole town better for all. Ditto the military, public universities & hospitals, etc.

Might as well have the police department funded by the proceeds of burglaries.
 
Not passenger rail, freight. Expanding freight rail capacity, means moving trucks off the roads, achieving all the above.
That sounds great but the places freight goes is a pretty long list. Would be a huge undertaking and where do you put the stops? It would take weeks to go across the US.

What freight that can gets sent on rail from coast to coast but just like it’s impractical to run pax rail to all corners of the US same thing goes for freight...
 
That sounds great but the places freight goes is a pretty long list. Would be a huge undertaking and where do you put the stops? It would take weeks to go across the US.

What freight that can gets sent on rail from coast to coast but just like it’s impractical to run pax rail to all corners of the US same thing goes for freight...

The US already has the best railway freight distribution system in the world! Sure, it can't move everything everywhere, but it's how the majority of freight already moves. Shifting the rest of the long distance freight on to rails is certainly achievable, and more than that, it's necessary to make the road network usable for next generation vehicles. Your 100 mph autonomous cars are useless when stuck in a line of freight vehicles. The benefits of electrification to improve cost and capacity, are a worthwhile investment for the taxpayer via public-private partnerships or subsidies.
 
railway freight distribution system

This reported one year ago, and in Oct 2017, I'd opinion not much has changed.

Rail's advantage is clearly moving bulk/weight great distances, like unit trains, also called a block train for the movement of coal or oil. As to intermodal traffic, (box containers sea, hwy, rail) rails big hope of the future was -4.2% in 2016.

Prior to 2016, 'As oil and coal shipments were collapsing, intermodal was growing, and the hope was that it would be able to compensate for the decline in coal and oil shipments. Diesel prices have fallen over the past two years. Spot rates that trucking companies charge have dropped too. And shippers have come to see a price advantage in shipping their merchandise by truck rather than by rail.'

' .... even trucking companies are cutting costs and slashing investments as the transportation recession exacts its pound of flesh. Read… Heavy Truck Orders Plunge, Worst September since 2009.'




Rail Freight Gets Clocked from all Sides in this Economy
by Wolf Richter • Oct 12, 2016


This hasn’t happened since the Financial Crisis.

Total US freight rail traffic, as measured in carloads and intermodal units, fell 6.1% in the week ended October 8, from the same week last year, the Association of American Railroads reported today. It was down 10% from the same week two years ago!

Both of its components were down: Carloads – transporting oil, coal, grains, chemicals, and the like – fell 5.9% in the week, to 264,165 loads. Intermodal (containers and trailers), which accounts for about 46% of total traffic, fell 6.4% from a year ago, and 6.5% from two years ago.

This comes after an already dreary September, when total freight traffic was down 4.8% from September last year, with carloads down 5.4% , and intermodal down 4.2%.

“Rail traffic in September was more of what we have come to expect this year: big declines in energy related products, continued weakness in intermodal and most other export markets, but with some strength in grain,” the AAR report said. “The fact is, in many of their markets, railroads are facing significant market uncertainties.”

These “significant market uncertainties” – actually “certainties” would be a better word – come in several packages:

The decline in car loads is mostly due to two big factors:

  1. The ongoing collapse of coal shipments. Power generators have been switching to natural gas and renewables, at the expense of coal. This trend started years ago when the price of natural gas collapsed and when power generators began building large utility-scale renewables facilities, particularly wind, in Texas, California, and other states.
  2. The total collapse of crude oil shipments. This started two years ago, when the oil bust began to bite. In the latest week, shipments of petroleum and petroleum products were down nearly 70% from the same week two years ago!
A more recent addition to the freight rail problem is the decline in intermodal traffic.

Intermodal had been the big hope for railroads. As oil and coal shipments were collapsing, intermodal was growing, and the hope was that it would be able to compensate for the decline in coal and oil shipments. But that hope fell apart in Q4 2015, when intermodal booked its first year-over-year decline (-9%) since the Financial Crisis.

This was followed by an uptick (+1%) in Q1 and by two back-to-back year-over-year declines in Q2 and Q3 (about 5% each).

It’s not just a blip. Year-to-date, US railroads reported a total volume decline of 6.9% from the same period last year, with car loads down 10.4% and intermodal units down 3.3%. Coal shipments, by far the largest category, accounting for about 30% of total carloads, plunged 25%. Petroleum and petroleum products shipments fell 22%, forest products 7.8%….

The only bright spots in terms of carloads, year-to-date: grains (+5.6%), motor vehicles (+2.7%), chemicals (+1.7%), and “other,” the smallest category (+16.7%).

But one of these bright spots, motor vehicles, which accounts for over 7% of total carloads, is turning into the next brake shoe to drop.

Auto sales hit a record in 2015, after cheap-debt-fueled increases year after year. But in September, unit sales fell from a year ago. Year-to-date, sales are up merely 0.5%, on strength earlier this year. Inventories at dealer lots are growing. Manufacturers are piling on incentives to move the iron. Ford will close its Mustang plant for a week to deal with oversupply. The industry has been talking about a looming “car recession” for months. And unless a miracle happens, auto shipments are going to follow auto sales.

So the decline in intermodal traffic is very unwelcome. Intermodal faces a combination of different challenges: Shippers seeing less than stellar demand in the US and overseas; and fierce competition from the trucking industry.

Diesel prices have fallen over the past two years. Spot rates that trucking companies charge have dropped too. And shippers have come to see a price advantage in shipping their merchandise by truck rather than by rail. In that vein, the AAR estimates that truck freight has increased 3.5% this year through August.

To deal with these “significant market uncertainties,” as the AAR put it, railroads have been cutting costs. They’re laying off people. They’re slashing investments. They’re working on efficiencies, such as increasing train speeds, given the reduced traffic (particularly of slower-moving oil trains).

And they’re idling engines on various tracks around the country. Sightings of these long lines of hundreds of engines have become more common. In May, I reported on the majestic sight of 292 Union Pacific engines parked in the Arizona desert [Freight Rail Traffic Plunges: Haunting Pictures of Transportation Recession].

Investors, however, have piled into railroad stocks since the February low – along with just about everything else out there – hoping the glory days are back, or hoping that QE4 will commence soon, or hoping at least for a nudge from the Fed, or whatever. For example, Union Pacific shares have jumped 42% since February, but they’re still down nearly 20% from the February 2015 high.

As an industry, North American Class 1 railroads – which the AAR defines as line haul freight railroads with revenues of over $476 million – are much smaller than trucking. According to the AAR, these railroads employed about 169,000 well-paid people in 2015, compared to about 1.8 million long-haul truckers (not counting other employees at trucking companies). And for those who want to know, there are over 26,000 locomotives in service at Class 1 railroads, including a couple of thousand or so parked on sidings around the US.

https://wolfstreet.com/2016/10/12/freight-railroad-shipment-decline-coal-oil-intermodal-soon-autos/
 
Back
Top