DOT axes 27 subsidised routes over poor load factor

av8tr1

"Never tell me the odds!"
https://www.ch-aviation.com/portal/news/60137-dot-axes-27-subsidised-routes-over-poor-load-factor

The United States Department of Transportation (DOT) has found that 27 communities have not met the criteria for eligibility for subsidised Essential Air Service (EAS) in fiscal year 2016. The requirements relate to the numbers of passengers transported or to the subsidised cost per passenger. Accordingly, the DOT has tentatively removed 19 of those communities from eligibility.

The communities which failed to meet the DOT requirements are:

- Alabama: Muscle Shoals
- Arizona: Prescott
- California: El Centro Imperial Country
- Colorado: Alamosa, Pueblo
- Georgia: Macon
- Iowa: Fort Dodge, Mason City
- Kansas: Salina
- Kentucky: Owensboro
- Maryland: Hagerstown
- Mississippi: Tupelo
- Nebraska: Kearney, Scottsbluff
- New York: Jamestown, NY
- Oregon: Pendleton
- Pennsylvania: Altoona, Bradford, Du Bois, Franklin/Oil City, Johnstown, Lancaster, PA
- Tennessee: Jackson, TN
- Texas: Victoria, TX
- Utah: Vernal
- West Virginia: Clarksburg/Fairmont, Parkersburg.

Under the terms of the DOT's EAS program, communities need to enplane an average of ten or more passengers per day at a required subsidy per passenger of USD200 or less. The communities now have twenty days to file objections or petitions for waivers before the DOT's decision becomes final.

Of the cities listed, the DOT recognises that eight experienced hardship during the year as they suffered an abrupt disruption of service. SeaPort Airlines (K5, Portland Int'l, OR) ceased operating at Muscle Shoals, El Centro, Salina, Tupelo and Pendleton; SkyWest Airlines (USA) (OO, Salt Lake City) ceased at Pueblo and Vernal; and Macon had no service at all. For this reason, the DOT has granted a waiver to the subsidy cap requirement for these communities.

The amount by which each community exceeded its subsidy cap varies greatly. For example, at Kearney, the subsidy came in just over the limit at USD213 per passenger. However, at Jamestown that figure is USD656 per passenger, and at Altoona a whopping USD734 per passenger.

Carriers operating at the affected airports are: Boutique Air, Great Lakes Airlines, Mokulele Airlines, Contour Airlines, Air Choice One, Allegiant Air, Cape Air, Southern Airways Express, PublicChartersand ViaAir.
 
Well that will probably be the end of Southern Airways Express, fairly certain that is all of their business. CKB is an FAA tower/radar too.
 
Well that will probably be the end of Southern Airways Express, fairly certain that is all of their business. CKB is an FAA tower/radar too.

Yeah pretty much. Met a couple of those guys at my last flight safety summer camp. All were training to go to these cities.

I think Boutique is going to take it in the shorts as well. But it sounds like they have one foot out the door anyway.
 
Yeah pretty much. Met a couple of those guys at my last flight safety summer camp. All were training to go to these cities.

I think Boutique is going to take it in the shorts as well. But it sounds like they have one foot out the door anyway.

Boutique may be on the way out, but I think they're only losing Alamosa today. I actually rode that route, back when it was Great Mistakes.
 
I don't think this happens immediately. I think these cities get to finish out thier contracts and then are unable to reapply unless they get a waiver.
 
I've always had mixed feelings on EAS, and this is with a lot of research.

In the case of Owensboro, that is an example of EAS money probably wasted. You have Evansville less than an hour away by car in a largely non-congested area far outside of any metropolitan that would pose issues to driving. Evansville has air service from the 3 legacy carriers to 5 major hubs plus Allegiant to SFB. Owensboro is connected to STL by Cape Air as an EAS route but also has Alleigiantserving SFB despite being within an hour of EVV. Seeing as SFB is a non-hub(as far as connecting onto other airlines) and Allegiant doesn't deal with connecting tickets, I doubt the Cape Air EAS Cessna route is much of a threat to that service. If Owensboro loses Cape Air and the limited destinations from STL, oh well. Drive 50 minutes and connect thru ORD, DFW, DTW, ATL, or CLT. And if Allegiant leaves, they fly to SFB up the road. Local commerce should not be affected as a drive within an hour to visit a place like Owensboro for business is not unacceptable. No real argument there.

But for every place like Owensboro, there is a place like Imperial/El Centro. Those people(unless the cross the border to travel within Mexico) are about an hour and 15 minutes with no traffic from Yuma. Yuma is, itself, highly isolated with just a few daily CRJ flights to PHX. When ATC delays impact PHX, flights places like YUM are among the first to cancel. These people are isolated. Yes, many of them choose to live there. But there is a big military presence and enough going on in the Imperial Valley to justify the area having some kind of reliable air link, in my opinion. Giving these people the option of LAX and flying right out of Imperial in a Caravan so that any very time sensitive transportation issue at least has a chance is what EAS was really created for.

I understand the people who are against EAS, and I am as well in many markets. But I personally am not against EAS funding for outlying but moderately populated areas over 1.5 hours away from any commercial airport with decent service, so long as they maintain the boarding numbers required to justify air service vs. driving.
 
Several of those places are within an hour's easy drive to other service. Macon is just down the interstate from ATL fer crying out loud.

Are there legit reasons for EAS, sure, just like the Tennessee Valley Authority and the rural electrification project. Some places are just off the beaten path, and I personally don't see any issue throwing some sheckles their way to keep the place connected.

But throwing the gimmes in with that dilutes the program and drags the whole thing down.
 
Back
Top