Diesel 182

......., since there's not a huge demand for diesel engines in the US.
No, but WHEN AvGas disappers there will be....

If I were sitting at the top of the Textron food chain, I would have sat down with the CEO of Lycoming and the CEO of Cessna YEARS ago and told them to work this out. Why would you OWN an engine company biut allow another one of your companies to buy engines from outside the Corporation.

STUPID business!!
 
:) I think most assumed you were in the USofA. Without the qualifier of "I'm in Indonesia", it seemed like a mis-stroke.
Well, I also put in the qualifier "operating cost per mile approaching a 208 [Caravan]," which is absolutely true as well. ;) From what I understand, just about everywhere outside the US, $12-15/gallon for avgas is pretty typical.
 
No, but WHEN AvGas disappers there will be....

If I were sitting at the top of the Textron food chain, I would have sat down with the CEO of Lycoming and the CEO of Cessna YEARS ago and told them to work this out. Why would you OWN an engine company biut allow another one of your companies to buy engines from outside the Corporation.

STUPID business!!
On the other hand, one thing that makes the T206H suck is that they went to Lycoming after years and years of TCM (because, as you point out, Textron owns both Cessna and Lycoming now). The 206H would be a lot more useful if it had the same TCM TSIO-520 engine as the G model.

I totally agree with you though. Supposedly Continental has been developing a diesel for years, but I don't know about Lycoming. They need to!
 
On the other hand, one thing that makes the T206H suck is that they went to Lycoming after years and years of TCM (because, as you point out, Textron owns both Cessna and Lycoming now). The 206H would be a lot more useful if it had the same TCM TSIO-520 engine as the G model.

I totally agree with you though. Supposedly Continental has been developing a diesel for years, but I don't know about Lycoming. They need to!

I will say this...the Continental building at Brookley Field in Mobile has a Jet-A tank out back. They're definitely working on something there.
 
Interesting point. However, if you're turning the prop at only 2200 RPM (and I realize that's just an arbitrary RPM you threw out), that means you're going to need a longer prop. Ground clearance could become a real issue for many planes if that's the case.

It's not arbitrary, it's the max RPM of this engine. With 90" of manifold pressure for full power. It's not oversquare, it's Overcube. (See what I did there? Invented a word!).

A longer prop will be more efficient, but it's constant speed so isn't needed. I believe it is using a 3-blade 78" Composite MT Propeller, while the T182 uses a 3-blade McCauley Prop of 78-79", which makes full power at 2400RPM and not 2700RPM as I guessed previously.
 
I will say this...the Continental building at Brookley Field in Mobile has a Jet-A tank out back. They're definitely working on something there.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Continental_TD-300
Leaked word says they are licensing the SMA SR305-230 instead of continuing to try building their own.
Yet Flying Mag said
Cessna said Lycoming has been enlisted to provide field support for the engine, which has a recommended TBO of 2,400 hours.

The aviation equivalent of
Atwt2000.jpg
 
It's not arbitrary, it's the max RPM of this engine. With 90" of manifold pressure for full power. It's not oversquare, it's Overcube. (See what I did there? Invented a word!).

A longer prop will be more efficient, but it's constant speed so isn't needed. I believe it is using a 3-blade 78" Composite MT Propeller, while the T182 uses a 3-blade McCauley Prop of 78-79", which makes full power at 2400RPM and not 2700RPM as I guessed previously.
I was referring to the mythical 300+hp (or equivalent) engine that is hopefully being developed by someone, but I see your point. A slower turning prop doesn't necessarily need to be longer, since a diesel engine prop can have a greater pitch.
 
Interesting point. However, if you're turning the prop at only 2200 RPM (and I realize that's just an arbitrary RPM you threw out), that means you're going to need a longer prop. Ground clearance could become a real issue for many planes if that's the case.
Actually it's the rpm in which they state this thing will run at, and if prop length gets too long, you shorten it and add more blades. Again, fta, 3 blades on this one.
 
On the other hand, one thing that makes the T206H suck is that they went to Lycoming after years and years of TCM (because, as you point out, Textron owns both Cessna and Lycoming now). The 206H would be a lot more useful if it had the same TCM TSIO-520 engine as the G model.

I totally agree with you though. Supposedly Continental has been developing a diesel for years, but I don't know about Lycoming. They need to!
Really? Because having flown a TSIO-520 206 and a TIO-540 206, I'd take the lycoming every day. I'd prefer the IO-550 though. IMO, the 520(and 470) are piles of crap compared the the lycoming counterpart. Also, IME, you can abuse a lycoming pretty well. Do the same thing on a continental with the ECI cylinders and you're going to be going through them every 100 hours or so.
 
Really? Because having flown a TSIO-520 206 and a TIO-540 206, I'd take the lycoming every day. I'd prefer the IO-550 though. IMO, the 520(and 470) are piles of crap compared the the lycoming counterpart. Also, IME, you can abuse a lycoming pretty well. Do the same thing on a continental with the ECI cylinders and you're going to be going through them every 100 hours or so.
Personally, I've never flown the H model 206, but the organization I work for, which has one of the largest 206 fleets in the world, has now gotten rid of all 206H's, and one of the things we didn't like was the Lycoming engine. Reduced visibility over the cowling and a turbo that is much less responsive (since the Lycoming doesn't keep the turbo spooled up the want the TCM engine does) were just two of the things they didn't like. At least for our operations, the H model 206 did not work nearly as well as the G model.

I'll give you that TCM cylinders (never worked with ECI cylinders) tend to have compression issues, especially improperly aligned valve guides. Don't have any experience with 500 series Lycoming.
 
Personally, I've never flown the H model 206, but the organization I work for, which has one of the largest 206 fleets in the world, has now gotten rid of all 206H's, and one of the things we didn't like was the Lycoming engine. Reduced visibility over the cowling and a turbo that is much less responsive (since the Lycoming doesn't keep the turbo spooled up the want the TCM engine does) were just two of the things they didn't like. At least for our operations, the H model 206 did not work nearly as well as the G model.

I'll give you that TCM cylinders (never worked with ECI cylinders) tend to have compression issues, especially improperly aligned valve guides. Don't have any experience with 500 series Lycoming.
The IO520 loses out big time to the IO540 in my type of operation (Alaska air taxi). It's just not durable enough. But we don't operate turbos other than on the Chieftain. Our cylinder problems have been cracked heads...so far exclusively on ECI cylinders. We're talking 10 cracked cylinders in 1550 hours of operation.
 
I've flown a TIO-540 in a pa31 an in a 206. We also had a O-470 206 next to it. The turbo'd 540 had less(none) cylinder cracking problems, while the NA O-470 went through them all the time. In the pa31, we did baby the engine, but in 700 hours flying the thing I never saw a cracked anything. The TSIO-520 206 had cracked a head every 100 hours or so.
I've flown enough of the two that I pretty much would never own an airplane with a continental motor in it.(save for maybe a O-200)
 
I've flown a TIO-540 in a pa31 an in a 206. We also had a O-470 206 next to it. The turbo'd 540 had less(none) cylinder cracking problems, while the NA O-470 went through them all the time. In the pa31, we did baby the engine, but in 700 hours flying the thing I never saw a cracked anything. The TSIO-520 206 had cracked a head every 100 hours or so.
I've flown enough of the two that I pretty much would never own an airplane with a continental motor in it.(save for maybe a O-200)
Just to be clear, those cracked heads I mentioned were on a 206 running an IO520.
No cylinder troubles yet in 800 or so hours on the chieftain motors.
 
Sounds like an ECI cylinder problem to me. I haven't experienced any cracked cylinders on TCM, although it has its share of problems. The usual problems we run into are burned valves, usually after about 800-1000 hours.
 
Personally, I've never flown the H model 206, but the organization I work for, which has one of the largest 206 fleets in the world, has now gotten rid of all 206H's, and one of the things we didn't like was the Lycoming engine. Reduced visibility over the cowling and a turbo that is much less responsive (since the Lycoming doesn't keep the turbo spooled up the want the TCM engine does) were just two of the things they didn't like. At least for our operations, the H model 206 did not work nearly as well as the G model.

I'll give you that TCM cylinders (never worked with ECI cylinders) tend to have compression issues, especially improperly aligned valve guides. Don't have any experience with 500 series Lycoming.

How many 206H's did your company operate and what were the major issues you ran into with the IO-540? We've had some issues with ours and wanted to see if you encountered the same problems.
 
How many 206H's did your company operate and what were the major issues you ran into with the IO-540? We've had some issues with ours and wanted to see if you encountered the same problems.
Not too many I don't think - maybe 2 or 3 - and I'm almost positive they were all TIO-540's, not normally aspirated. They were operated in a different part of the world, so I don't know all the issues, and many of the issues weren't engine related. Like I mentioned, the turbo system doesn't stay spooled up like on the TCM engines, which makes power response sluggish, and when you're going into a 400 meter airstrip, you don't want to have to wait for the turbo to spool up. Also, even tall pilots complained about the visibility over the cowling on the H model. Our CP also flew the H model some, so I'll have to ask him. All in all, I never heard anything good about the H model 206, and I know they just sold the last one this past year I believe. However, we still have a fleet of 30 or so 206G models (mostly turbo, but some NA as well), from the late 70's and 80's. The main program that was using the 206H went back to the 206G. Other issues not related to the engine I think were many STC's approved for the G model weren't for the H, and I believe the useful load was quite a bit lower. So we sold our 5 year old planes and are keeping our 30 year old planes, if that tells you something. The biggest thing we don't like about our 206G's is they burn avgas, and the fact that they're getting kind of old. In fact, many of them are in storage right now, hoping that someone will STC that mythical 300hp or equivalent diesel some day. :)
 
For you guys that had cracked ECI cylinders - maybe I'm missing something here, but if you kept having cylinders cracking, why did you continue to use ECI cylinders?
 
For you guys that had cracked ECI cylinders - maybe I'm missing something here, but if you kept having cylinders cracking, why did you continue to use ECI cylinders?
Because they were the only thing available at the time. I haven't flown a 520 in a good while now. I don't know if we can get TCM cylinders now or not.
 
For you guys that had cracked ECI cylinders - maybe I'm missing something here, but if you kept having cylinders cracking, why did you continue to use ECI cylinders?
Because the warranty on the cylinders would only replace them with ECI cylinders, and The Company didn't want to pay out of pocket for TCM cylinders. Typical aviation step over a dollar to save a nickel type stuff. I believe at one point there was also a several month wait for TCM cylinders.
 
Back
Top