Dial an Altitude - Potential Money Saver

kiloalpha

Well-Known Member
Transponder: Garmin 320

Encoder: Ameri King 350
I thought I would post this for others flying small airplanes. I spent a week this month chasing a frustrating problem in my PA-12. It all started about two weeks ago as I was approaching Bowman field (LOU). As I approached the pattern the tower asked me to "say altitude". I told them 1500 feet. The tower replied that I was showing 1900 feet. A moment later they showed 1200 feet. Basically on every radar sweep they showed a different altitude. After flying around a bit it was clear that my Transponder or encoder was all over the place. Ironically my biannual transponder check was due and I had my radio man coming to the hanger the next day. I called him to inform him that I now also had a squawk with the system. After explaining the problem he suggested I re-rack the encoder as well as the transponder. He figured there was a good chance something was loose. So I climbed under the dash and re-racked both instruments. For good measure I blew compressed air over all the connections. I then took the airplane around the pattern and asked the tower to tell me what they saw. There was no change, my altitude was all over the place.

I called my radio man back and told him the results. He suggested that I should replace the encoder. So I grabbed the Aircraft Spruce book and spent some money. I waited 3 days for the new encoder and when it arrived I swapped out the old unit for the new. My flight around the pattern revealed that the problem still existed. Basically the altitude being transmitted from my airplane was hopping up and down as much as 700 feet.

I called my radio man again and told him the news. It was clear the encoder was not the issue. He suggested swapping out the transponder with a similar unit. I was able to locate an airplane with a Garmin 320 like mine. To get the replacement transponder I flew to a grass strip just west of Lexington, KY. The gentleman who owned the replacement transponder was very generous. I landed by his hanger and within ten minutes was back in the air with the replacement transponder. I climbed up to 3000 feet, called Louisville Approach and asked them what they saw. Unfortunately they saw me all over the sky. I descended back to the grass runway, swapped out the transponders and headed back to Bowman. It was clearly not a transponder problem.

I called my radio man and he decided the next thing to check would be the wire harness running from the encoder to the transponder. I contorted myself back under the dash and removed the harness. We tested each of the 9 wires and could not find a problem, but just to be safe we replaced the harness with a new one. At that point I had to leave for work and my radio man stayed behind. His plan was to hook the encoder up to the transponder and power everything up on the work bench to see if it worked. With his test equipment he pumped up the system to watch it climb. The encoder seemed to be working just fine, and then while it was climbing his cell phone rang. When it rang the encoder altitude jumped a few hundred feet. After he took the call he continued to watch the encoder. Each time he spoke the encoder jumped.

You probably know where this is going. I have an I-phone and yes I always have it with me in the airplane. I usually do not use it but I stow it in a map pocket and it stays on.

We put the airplane back together. I flew around in the pattern for fifteen minutes (Iphone off) while the tower watched my altitude. It was rock solid right on the money. I landed and then turned on my Iphone. I took off again and immediately the tower saw my altitude jumping all over the place. While talking with the tower I turned the phone off and immediately things returned to normal.

My radio man has never encountered this anomaly but is convinced the phone is the culprit. I am as well. By the way the encoder is made by Ameri King. I have an old Ack unit that we put in after discovering this problem and the Iphone does not effect the Ack unit.

Hopefully this information will prevent someone else from chasing their tale.
Thought this might be a good reason to turn off your phone in flight!
 
Interesting read! I figured with the way today's technology is, there was no need to turn it off.. I guess I'll be making anyone with an iPhone confirm their phone is off before taking them up in the future!

I turn mine off before every flight because if I don't, I'll land and find I only have 1 bar of battery left, even when it was full on takeoff.
 
I turn mine off before every flight because if I don't, I'll land and find I only have 1 bar of battery left, even when it was full on takeoff.

Same reason I fly with the cell off. No need to deplete the battery for no reason.
 
Very interesting! I've got an iPhone and fly an airplane with an older transponder.

I'll have to make sure it's off. I do recall having an issue with ATC and our encoded altitude atleast once.
 
I usually keep my phone on, but never have a problem with my x-pndr. always a problem with batter life though. I keep my phone off IFR only for the reason that i might have to call my boss if i have to divert.

I have noticed though, that GSM phones usually cause more interference over the headset than CDMA phones. Dont know if its just anecdotal, but seems to be my experience.
 
This is an interesting post. I will definitely keep this in mind if I ever have that problem.
 
I've also had cell phones MIJI GPS and flying near the Mexican border I've been charged for international calls/messages and international roaming while on the US side.
 
I have a blackberry, never have noticed any issue with it. I do had an instructor that had an iPhone, and anytime it rang, we an heard it in the headset as static. Maybe the iPhone's tolerances aren't very high?
 
I have a blackberry, never have noticed any issue with it. I do had an instructor that had an iPhone, and anytime it rang, we an heard it in the headset as static. Maybe the iPhone's tolerances aren't very high?

What network are you on? I've found that GSM phones cause significantly more interference. My CDMA phone has never been able to cause any static. My buddy uses an iPhone, on GSM, which I hear interference from every flight.
 
Many years ago, I was in a small Piper Cherokee with one of those early model cellphones. Flying at 7000 feet, the phone rang. (back when the cell phones were more powerful).

I answered the phone and spoke a bit. Hung up and didn't think anything of it.

I ended up going into CLT airspace with the transponder indicating the altitude all over the place just like the original poster.

I tracked the problem down to that cell phone.

From that day on, I have always kept the cell phones turned off because I know first hand that cell phones do interfere with the aircraft navigation equipment.

Joe
 
I'm very surprised "Airplane Mode" is not even mentioned here. What exactly does "turned off" mean these days? Is it completely off or just airplane mode? I had a Treo that didn't shut off, you could only turn the cell signal off or take the battery out.
 
Any GSM phone will cause interference in your headset....

and the phone drains battery more in the air when it's not off or in airplane mode because its constantly searching for a signal that usually doesn't exist....very draining on the battery
 
Same reason I fly with the cell off. No need to deplete the battery for no reason.

Yeah, constantly searching for cell towers is hard on the battery. Also, I hate hearing the feedback in my headset when I get a call or txt.
 
Story from another board...

"I always was a skeptic on how a cell phone can affect aircraft instruments but I am now a believer. On Oct 27 we were on vectors to 35L for the ILS with the weather at minimums. Very poor turn on vector and we overshot the loc and had to turn back to capture the loc. Finally established, configured and on course when we switched to HGS and attempted to fly the approach. We switched to AIII and continued the approach but I could not get the aircraft to settle on a stable localizer course with the fly cues continuing to wander left and right across the course. About 800 feet or so we got an Approach Warning and the F.O. commanded go around which we did. At this point I was P.Od at my ability to track the localizer but the FO pointed out that the localizer was "wandering" during the approach from left to right and back. On the downwind I remembered a conversation I had with a DAL Captain that went missed twice in DAL with a wandering localizer. This Captain told me that whenever they placed the gear down the localizer would start to wander. The F.A.s stated that whenever the gear would come down a customer would fire up his cell and call his wife to come and get him at the airport as they were about to land. The customer would then phone his wife back when they went missed and update her. After the second time the F.A.s caught him and he turned the cell off which resulted in a successful approach. Much the same situation in Denver and I went on the PA and made a forceful PA that if you had a Cell Phone turn it OFF, if you had a computer, turn it OFF. We had a Lynx jumpseater who told me that after I made the PA he saw at least six glowing cell phones in use in the cabin. The F.A.s were a senior group from DAL and immediately walked the aisle and found many cell phones on. On downwind I asked the approach controller if any of the snow removal equipment could have been in the ILS critical area and received a negative reply and they had no issues with the loc from other aircraft. We were vectored to 34R as the snow removal equipment was cleared onto 34L and made an uneventful landing. Our airplane was 683 a 300. The point of this story. I believe this anomaly is a 300 issue but maybe not. If you are making an approach and the localizer seems to "wander" consider a PA to have the customers ensure their celll phones are turned OFF. Have the F.A.s get involved in policing the issue. We discussed the issue in depth and both the F.O. and I agreed that the localizer was wandering and after the cell phones were turned off the localizer stabilized. Food for thought Y'all, but that's what I experienced. Kudos to the F.O. and the F.A.s for being part of the team and being proactive. "
 
I have an iPhone and have flown 2 172's, a 152, and a G1000 Diamond... no problems.

Come to think of it, we had 4 iphones in most of those planes.
 
Pretty much any GSM phone will do this, while CDMA won't. The iPhone is, of course, a GSM device.
 
Back
Top