Delta Request to End Pilot Pentions!

ROFCIBC said:
Doug, oh Swarthy one...

Goes back to much more basic stuff than organized labor and what administration does or does not support it.

Goes back to that day in the DFW pilots lounge. Who has the agenda? Who's interest are the "principles" looking out for?

gerry and joe are of the same cloth...perfumed princes looking out for themselves. joe never was a pilot, or a captain (I use the small "c" by design). He sold us out...period! he came to Delta never intending to be a pilot.

I remember a call from him back in December 2000 when his paranoia got the best of him and he wanted to know why I was looking at his schedule. From that day on he joined the ranks of the back stabbing management wannabees...richard "dick cheese" colby, and that moron bushey who bailed out and went to another airline...joe is no different...he's out for himself and you, me, and the rest of the Delta pilots be damned.

Only difference is I can stand in front of a mirror each day and not see some white fluid coming out of my mouth!

FWIW some of the so called “labor leaders” fall into the same category…how long before we see small “j” johnny boy as the ALPA President?

You heard it here first!

Two things:

1) Don't like the Union stewards? VOTE THEM THE • OUT. A union is onlyas good as those who participate in it (just like this pesky government of ours).

2). Even if you have a sucky leadership the vote still comes down to the pilots ...
 
pilot602 said:
Two things:

1) Don't like the Union stewards? VOTE THEM THE • OUT. A union is onlyas good as those who participate in it (just like this pesky government of ours).

2). Even if you have a sucky leadership the vote still comes down to the pilots ...

The union leadership hated ROFIBC because he's got one of those rolodex memories where at the drop of a hat, he'd either remember specifically what someone said, or had access to archived information where he could hold their feet to the millstone.

Not to kiss Jon's ass, but the guy was legendary. I thought he was going to make the secretary-treasurer cry one day! :)

Recalling is difficult. We tried to mount a recall in SLC last year but things get political very quickly and they pull all sorts of interesting tricks out of the magic hat.
 
ROFCIBC said:
FWIW some of the so called “labor leaders” fall into the same category…how long before we see small “j” johnny boy as the ALPA President?

You heard it here first!

Malone? Ya think?
 
Callous said:
Can someone point me to a good article or information regarding pilot pensions. I'm hoping to be a career pilot, and I work in the finance industry currently, but I dont know anything about pensions. Working for any given carrier cant you just have a 401(k)? Or does the airline not provide that? I have seen some info on airlinepilotcentral.com, but that's about it.

In a nutshell the traditonal "defined benefit" type pensions are going away, not only for the airline industry but just about all business.

The "DB" was one where after "X" years of service you get "Y" amount for the rest of your life after retirement. Companies had to put money aside to cover the cost of such a plan.

The current trend is the "defined contribution" where you as the employee put some money aside, often matched to some degree by the company you work for. That money then pays your retirement.

Companies wanted to get rid of DB plans because they are an expense that cuts into profits. Problem was what do you do with all those folks who have retired? The easy answer was dump them on the PBGC which "insures" the plans. Problem is the PBGC is broke (more or less) too because of all the companies that dumped their DB plans. Once the PBGC takes over a DB plan the amount each individual retiree may be decreased radically, even to total elimination.

The defined contribution plans have on advantage, they employee can take their contributions money with them if they change employers, and the matching funds too after a certain time. Works really well if you change jobs. Airline pilots however tend not to do that...you are more or less "married" to one airline for your entire career.

The sticky wicket comes when a company transitions from the DB to a DC (defined contribution) plan. For a brand new employee, it's easy...but for an older one not so. It would be impossible for an employee with just a few years left to put aside enough money to insure they have a retirement. Just not enough time.

In the case of Delta they just flat said they could not afford to keep putting money in the pilots DB plan and were going to stop. Eventually the money they had put in there runs out and the retiree's checks stop. Kind of tough if you are in your 70s and suddenly all income stops. Sure there is social security...ha ha ha! But you get the point.

In my case I was able to take 1/2 of my retirement in a "lump sum" which then cut my monthly check in half. So instead of $4800 a month I got $2400. (I won't go into how the exact amount is computed as it's a complicated formula based on years of service and average monthly income). At any rate, I put that lump sum (actually a rolled over IRA) into CDs that are in my IRA at the local credit union. As it turns out the interest I earn each month on that IRA is just about equal to the $2400 I get from Delta. So if push comes to shove and the Delta check (or the PBGC) goes away I can just start drawing that interest out each month and pretty much have the same amoung. Yes the interest will be taxed as it's an IRA, but then my Delta retirement check was taxed too.

The only downside is the principle of my lump sum will no longer grow as it does now due to my not drawing out the monthly interest. But on the other side the IRS makes you take that money out when you turn 70 1/2 anyhow! Heaven forbid you die and have a bunch of money on which no taxes have been paid! Gahhh....

One last point…I also have an Air Force retirement, and both Mz B and I draw social security, plus she has a small Delta retirement. (that will probably eventually go away too as the non pilot DB is actually a bigger fund than the pilot DB due to a lot more folks in it)

At any rate...that's the long winded story about Delta, DBs, DCs and IRAs!

Now for some simple advice, a lot of which came from my Dad, God Bless him.

Start thinking about retirement now! The key is to OWN everything when you retire. And I mean EVERYTHING! The house, the car, the boat, the RV…any “toys” you plan to have. THIS CANNOT BE OVER EMPHASIZED…OWN EVERYTHING!

In this way all you really have to do is pay for recurring things like taxes, food, utilities and transportation. Anything left after those necessities you can spend on whatever you want.

The other thing is to always be looking at what you can really do without if for whatever reason your income decreases. Because as we have seen, that can happen.

See? Pretty simple…just two things to worry about!

For me, I plan on enjoying retirement. If I have to cut back on this or that, well that’s just a part of life. I can still enjoy things I want to, just maybe not as much of them. But then, with time and age, you tend to cut back anyhow, so it’s not the end of the world. In the end it’s all about what lifestyle you can (a) afford and (b) tolerate!
 
pilot602 said:
Two things:

1) Don't like the Union stewards? VOTE THEM THE • OUT. A union is onlyas good as those who participate in it (just like this pesky government of ours).

2). Even if you have a sucky leadership the vote still comes down to the pilots ...

Not exactly that simple...

First of all not ALL the folks who do union business are "voted in", at least not by the rank and file. For example the good folks up at national ALPA are not voted "in" or "out" by the rank and file. Nor even at the local level. Each base votes on their two reps. Those two reps from each base vote on such things as the head of the ALPA unit at that airline and such important folks as the negotiating team. Then those folks go up and vote on who runs national ALPA. FWIW most unions are set up that way…by design! The old “golden rule”…those who have the gold, make the rules. The corollary to “power corrupts, and absolute power, absolutely corrupts!”

Yes they can eventually be voted "out" but that may be (as was the case back in the 90s at Delta) long after they have royally screwed over the rank and file, and taken their money and run away!

As for the pilot "vote". The only real thing they vote on directly (at least at Delta) is the contract and then only if those local reps decide to let them. (kind of a simplification of a complicated process)

But unfortunately by the time it comes to a rank and file contract vote, the deal is pretty much over and done with. In the history of Delta Air Lines a contract has NEVER been voted down....NEVER, NEVER, NEVER. Goes back to the old thing "half a loaf is better than none", "we'll get them the next time" and all that clap trap. Plus a whole lot (the vast majority) of the pilots (at least at Delta) just flat aren't prepared (psychologically or financially) to go on strike! PERIOD! (FWIW I was!)

So while the "vote the bastards out" and "turn down the contract...STRIKE" ideas seem like a good idea, in reality they're just not in the cards.

Trust me...been there, done that, got the tee shirt!
 
Kristie said:
that would not be good right now... how did the change over from Allen to Mullen do? not good.. how bout Mullen to Grinstein?? not good... changing over the team now isn't going to help...it's only going to make it flounder more!

The old rearranging of the deck chairs as the Titanic sinks!
 
So while the "vote the bastards out" and "turn down the contract...STRIKE" ideas seem like a good idea,

Or a bad idea, depending on your perspective. I know a few guys who thought it was a "good" idea and wish they could have that vote back.
 
flyover said:
Or a bad idea, depending on your perspective. I know a few guys who thought it was a "good" idea and wish they could have that vote back.

It depends on ONE thing...are you prepared to strike?

Back when that might have been a possibility at Delta there was some nifty stuff put out. One was "strikes begin at the kitchen table". True words.

If you and your FAMILY (whomever and how many that may include) are NOT ready to strike and you vote to you are (a) screwed (b) STUPID!

So me and Mz B, my blushing bride sat down at that very kitchen table and figured out just how much we could live on. Just the big 3...a roof over your head, food on the table and reliable transportation. That is the survival mode. No 700 channels on DirectTV, no 26 magazine subscriptions, no six cars all insured, fueled up, ready to go, no NY strip steaks or lobster every night, no going out, no NASCAR races, none of that crap! Basic survival…

We came up with $1100 a month...(I still had a mortgage then). Based on what we had in the bank...could have "survived a strike" for six years! That is assuming neither of us went to work.

For me the strike vote was then based on the issues...not SURVIVAL! Sadly I was probably in a 10% category who could vote on issues....

So the bottom line is...you get what you are prepared to stand up an fight for! If you are not prepared you get the bovine feces management offers and the union accepts!
 
ROFCIBC said:
Uh, what exactly are "Pentions"?

Enquiring minds and all that!

Pretty soon, it won't matter how you spell it.

Companies are killing them left and right.
 
ROFCIBC said:
We came up with $1100 a month...(I still had a mortgage then). Based on what we had in the bank...could have "survived a strike" for six years!

I have friends who "survived a strike" for lots longer than 6 years. The real question is: is a strike a smart move at this point? ALPA and others (PATCO for one) have had their share of ill conceived strikes.

So the bottom line is...you get what you are prepared to stand up an fight for!
Just way over simplified. The idea that the current pay and benefits situation for legacy pilots is wholly a result of a lack of unity or willingness to strike is very debatable. There have been plenty who "stood up" and got zip.
 
flyover said:
I have friends who "survived a strike" for lots longer than 6 years. The real question is: is a strike a smart move at this point? ALPA and others (PATCO for one) have had their share of ill conceived strikes.

How long one "survives a strike" after it iscalled is not an issue when the "crunch time" comes to vote on it or not. It is an unknown then. My six year number was without any income whatsoever. Trust me, had we gone on strike I would have generated income.

As far as PATCO...that was by any definition an illegal strike. The President did what he had to do. Period! The PATCO leadership led the rank and file over the cliff.


flyover said:
Just way over simplified. The idea that the current pay and benefits situation for legacy pilots is wholly a result of a lack of unity or willingness to strike is very debatable. There have been plenty who "stood up" and got zip.

"over simplified" NOT! I made no reference to any current situation...just a general observation. If you are not willing to go to the mat, to use EVERY weapon in your arsenal, then you deserve what you get. I am not a current Delta Air Lines pilot...so I had not vote...nor am I about to second guess the decisions of those who did. But the point is the same...and it is valid...you either are willing to go to distance or you are not. And by "willing" the issue of "being prepared" is a part of that. If a pilot is living from paycheck to paycheck, even at $250,000 per year...then I will venture they are not "prepared" as they simply cannot afford a loss of even one cent of income in a given month...let alone six years or more.

Which was my point...if you aren't prepared then in essence you don't have a choice...you vote not to strike. In that case then, you deserve what you get. Period!

This may sound cruel but that is a fact when it comes to going all the way.

20/20 hindsight is not relevant in that decision...especially considering you don't have it at the time of the vote!

The “end game” is the Delta Pilots made a decision based on what they wanted. The loss of retirees pensions is something we retirees had no vote on, and will live with, or actually without, for the rest of our remaining lives. Not a union issue…we have NO union.
 
tonyw said:
Pretty soon, it won't matter how you spell it.

Companies are killing them left and right.

Tony

As people begin to live longer, pensions are getting more & more expensive for companies. The best way to go are 401k's & have the employers offer matching 401k contributions to the employees account.

This does not excuse what Delta is proposing to do, but, the Unions needs to start balancing protecting the employees against what the company can afford.
 
most employers aren't even matching anymore.. now a days, it's all about ESOP and to me, that's not necessarily a benefit....If i want to put stock in something, give me the $$ and let me be the judge of what stock i put it into...
 
mpenguin1 said:
This does not excuse what Delta is proposing to do, but, the Unions needs to start balancing protecting the employees against what the company can afford.

The only problem is that pensions have often been a source of profits. Sure they are underfunded now, but when the stock market was booming, they tapped into the excess funding in pensions and call those profits.

Companies want it both ways. Screw that.
 
tonyw said:
The only problem is that pensions have often been a source of profits. Sure they are underfunded now, but when the stock market was booming, they tapped into the excess funding in pensions and call those profits.

Companies want it both ways. Screw that.

Actually they just used the "profits" the Defined Benefit trust funds made to cover their contributions...which is essence what you say as they took that money as "profit" or in many cases executive bonuses.

Then when times are bad they piss and moan about all that money they have to use to fund pension trusts which are not making money due to investments, all while gleefully ignoring what they did when "times were good"!
 
ROFCIBC said:
Then when times are bad they piss and moan about all that money they have to use to fund pension trusts which are not making money due to investments, all while gleefully ignoring what they did when "times were good"!

Yep. And us minions get shafted again -- uh, hello, guys, when the pensions were overfunded, what did you do with that money?
 
tonyw said:
The only problem is that pensions have often been a source of profits. Sure they are underfunded now, but when the stock market was booming, they tapped into the excess funding in pensions and call those profits.

Companies want it both ways. Screw that.

Tony

Of that, I will not argue.

The thing that I like about 401k type accounts is that the company has a small amount of time to transfer that money to the account, so, that is protected money for the employee. Yes, there have been problems with some 401k accounts, but, those are isolated.

A Pension is not safe, you can work for a company for 40 years, retire at the ago of 60, be retired for 10 years, & *bam*, there goes your retirement fund.
 
Kristie said:
most employers aren't even matching anymore.. now a days, it's all about ESOP and to me, that's not necessarily a benefit....If i want to put stock in something, give me the $$ and let me be the judge of what stock i put it into...

Most, competitive companies offer some sort of 401k matching account.
 
Back
Top