I find that hard to believe. I tried to take off with a level 4 thunderstorm approaching the airfield from the north. Both my instructor and the check instructor made me taxi back to the ramp and call it a day. I also taxied past a fuel truck and got my azz chewed for violating safety rules.
What were the winds and weather on the METARs and TAF for that time? If winds were out of the DCA ops specs. You were in the right. Obviously the check pilot thought it was safe. He was the actual PIC since it was not an end of course checkride.
He can't give you a no show because you're actually there. If you had a problem you should have took it up to the Group Manager, then to Pete Balesteri or Bill Leech. Bill Leech of course he's gone now, but he backed me up several times.
$1211.00 for a check flight?:rotfl: I was there when you were and I think that is a little inflated. The most I ever paid for a flight was my Inst End of Course and that was about $600 and that was for the flight and the oral. The price of the rental is wet, so fuel is already included.in the price per hour. You might want to check your monthly statement.
So you busted the VOR, keep on trucking and complete the rest of the tasks. That's just less you would have had to do on the retake. If oyu had went and completed everything else, all you would have to have done was a VOR approach. You could have handled the bust without the drama.
Did the stage check instructor make any comments about runway lighting? Their suppossed to say whether you have certain aspects of the approach lighting or runway in sight. If not you go missed at DH. If you had a solid approach, you were fine. Were you at DH when you went missed? If not it was a bust. Remeber you have to trust you instruments.
You have to be ready and set up for the approch before you do the approach. If you weren't ready, ask to be revectored.
You were in the right. Minimum fuel! What B.S. Some of those check instructors and group leaders are so full of it.
I'm in no way taking the schools side of this I'm just reading you post teeling it as I interperated it combined with my two years there. Yeah the school is a business and they're there to make money, but you have to use all the resources available to you. Don't take one instructors word as the final one. I'm sorry you had a horrible time there. There are many of us how had a great time there, albeit expensive time.
Ok, let me go through this one last time. I appreciate your view. Appearently we have differing opinions, which is fine. But since you did have some questions or contradictions, I will be happy to clear up any misconceptions or misunderstandings, so the folks that could be reading this can be well informed. Please endulge.
What's hard to believe about the question of safety? I listed the hurricane issue. I guess I could have also listed the Fatigue issue (remember the "IM SAFE" checklist?), but I figured that went hand in hand with the scheduling, but I'll be more specific next time. My apologies for the generalizations.
Surface winds were 135 (or so) at 20... it was right on the line - HOWEVER, at 3000 feet, it was from about 180 at 50+kts. That tells me that there is significant liklihood of windshear. I saw no reason to not do what I could to avoid it!
And as far as the Flight Supervisor not being able to give a no-show, that's severly misguided. In fact: from the Operations Manual, page 16-6, Issued 12/01/04... "No Show" ---- "a "no-show charge(s) will be assessed - - When one of the following occurs: If the student fails to show up for any of the scheduled events (this is the one you referred to, however, it continues) If it is determined that a student is "unprepared" for any of the scheduled events listed above by a representative of the Academy (possibly a Flight Supervisor?!). If a student arrives in advance of the scheduled training activity, but fails to be available to begin the training activity "on time"." So, there you have it, there's more than one reason you can be "no-showed" for a specific activity, and it doesn't have to be your CFI that "no-shows" you!
Nah, I didn't bother going up the chain with that one. It's a "pick your battles" type of thing. I simply put it in the bag of reasons I had decided to take the remainder of my 100 grand elsewhere when I left the academy.
As for the price I listed... there's a differance... we are talking about including a no-show fee, as well as yes, fuel was added as a surcharge. Yes, the rental was "wet", but there was still a fuel surcharge! If there wasn't, then the academy owes me roughly 400 bucks because for about 20 hours (or so) of flight time, I was charged for it!
As for the VOR, why should I have continued when the weather conditions weren't appropriate anyway? Are you suggesting I waste my money? Sorry, but I work hard for my money, and I'm not going to bust 2 or 3 other things throughout the time fighting windshear!
As for the "runway lighting" - no. The checkpilot remained silent. As for the approach. It was solid - or so I thought. It was crosshairs. However, what is wrong when you are over the middle marker on the ILS 09L, your altimeter is still at 400 feet, DH is 255, and when you have shot the approach, you know that at the MM, you are ALWAYS (for that approach in the 172s) within a couple feet of DH? Is your altimeter setting wrong? Is that instrument malfunctioning? Is the Glideslope malfunctioning? Was the sensitivity on the Beacons too sensitive? Do you want to wander around at 200 feet (or so) AGL while you figure it out? If so, remind me never to sit in an airplane with you! Get up, Get out of there. Show good judgement, and get altitude, contact tower, execute a missed approach, and relisten to ATIS, and troubleshoot. It's always better to get out of a bad situation than bum around close to the ground, in a relitively congested area, and troubleshoot it - especially when flying on instruments! As for being ready... I was ready. The approach itself was executed nearly perfectly. I wasn't a dot off in any direction - until I ANNOUNCED going missed because something wasn't adding up. It wasn't anything about a lack of preparedness. I was fully prepared, the approach was accurately briefed, everything was tuned in, and configured very well. It had to do with judgement. Because I showed enough sense and judgement to get out of a bad situation rather than push it, I was busted. I *KNOW* it is always better (unless fuel is an issue) to go missed, establish in a hold or get revectored, and troubleshoot what is in error rather than following a possible faulty glideslope or a sticking altimeter into the ground.
I just want to let people know of my experiances, and I thank you for asking for more details - as long as I don't drop names, I will be happy to provide the details. I don't deem it appropriate to post the names of individuals that were encountered negitively. I want to just stick to the facts of what happened, and use terms such as "Instructor", "Checkpilot", "Examiner", etc.