Yeeeaaaah, soooo, here's the catch from the article on who gave out this award:
About Business Traveler ... Business Traveler, published by Frank Publishing, is the magazine of choice for premium business travelers.
So, we're not dealing with John Q. Public here. We're dealing with the biz traveler on flying on the company's dime. This is not the young family hauling their infant and 3-year-old across the ramp in ORD, trying not to slip on the Type I and IV, sucking down APU fumes, dodging errant baggage carts. These are the folks who sit in business and first class on United. That's what the award is about. I've ridden up there. It's awesome in United First and United Business. But, it's a far cry from the reality of coach.
I don't put much weight behind awards doled out by magazine. After all, Air Transport World named Mesa as the Regional Airline of 2005 ... in February of 2005. How can you be awarded for the year that's only 2 months old?