Copa orders 61 737's..........

There is a difference between 250-500 in my opinion. When I was hired with 1000/200 in 06 my class had folks with thousands of hours and only 250 hours. In the end, we all, but 1 (ironically with thousands of hours) made it through training. Many of the "low time" folks have moved to LCC's in the last few years. I think 750 is reasonable, with extra OE (previously required anyway) and some oversight in terms of line checks and sim events. An arbitrary 1500 doesn't make a better pilot to a 121 operator. Some will banner tow, some will instruct, others will pay, some will fly 91. In the end, it's the quality of experience and training that make the difference. No argument over 1500 being a number for the ATP, yet a rather arbitrary shot in the dark on what is "qualified". I've flown with guys with thousands of hours and a few hundred hours, in the end it came down to previous training, acquired knowledge and ATTITUDE to learn new things. Not saying a bad attitude makes them less qualified, but a 300 hour guy in the right seat that "knows it all" misses a lot along the way. Hence, experience.
 
I can agree with that. Obviously I'm God's gift to airplanes and women, so I'm the exception to the rule though. ;)
 
Personally I don't think it's unreasonable at all to have guys flying 121 with only a few hundred hours. It's completely doable especially with good training. The military has proven that much.

My argument is that the 1,500 he rule has helped the pilot side of the supply vs. demand rule. There's many factors at play obviously but the biggest thing seems to be a high cost of entry in terms of dollars. Lots of money up front (talking 6 digits here) just to slug it out for at least 5 years making less than $45k with at least 2-3 of those at less than $25k. Unless you come from a 1% family that's not really doable or attractive at all.

When you make the barrier to entry that high something has to give. Rather than eat away at the 1,500 hour rule I'd rather see the pay part of the equation change in order to attract people. Look at 9E, they couldn't hire a soul and suddenly they start trying to give away an extra $20k and they're filling classes. That's an isolated example but that's how I would like to see the system work itself out and I think it is possible. Some regionals might die in the meantime but that's really better for everyone.
 
Personally I don't think it's unreasonable at all to have guys flying 121 with only a few hundred hours. It's completely doable especially with good training. The military has proven that much.

My argument is that the 1,500 he rule has helped the pilot side of the supply vs. demand rule. There's many factors at play obviously but the biggest thing seems to be a high cost of entry in terms of dollars. Lots of money up front (talking 6 digits here) just to slug it out for at least 5 years making less than $45k with at least 2-3 of those at less than $25k. Unless you come from a 1% family that's not really doable or attractive at all.

When you make the barrier to entry that high something has to give. Rather than eat away at the 1,500 hour rule I'd rather see the pay part of the equation change in order to attract people. Look at 9E, they couldn't hire a soul and suddenly they start trying to give away an extra $20k and they're filling classes. That's an isolated example but that's how I would like to see the system work itself out and I think it is possible. Some regionals might die in the meantime but that's really better for everyone.

I'm as positive as any CURRENT employee, but unless a regional folds up (not wishing that on anyone), the supply to fill classes only exists for so long. Sure, 200 coming, maybe a couple hundred more, but then what? All the regionals are working to achieve the sim time issue for the ATP which should be good for a little while, but then what? So someone says "I want to be a pilot". They are assumed to be in HS or first years of college, we all say "great", but they do the program (assume they either get financing or have parents to foot the bill), but now they graduate with 250-400 hours and their ratings through CFI/II/MEI. Now they get to instruct or find a bridge. That's not a short term bridge to collect 1000+ hours that most want or are willing to cross.... A short time while applying to regionals? Sure. Realistically 2 years working hard in a good weather area? That's where something has to give. From 2002-2007 that worked. From 2008, those who did it either loathed flying or were already too deep to do anything else. What happened during that time? Well, those in HS or first years of college ran the numbers, saw the industry, and well, "diverted". The evidence is telling in ratings acquired and enroll,met overall in 141 Approved schools. So what can be done? Hmm... The govt won't change things until senators and congressman have their direct flights removed due to staffing, the FAA won't change things as it requires a step above in the lawmakers, the schools now show the "supply and demand" function working to being new folks in. There is still a 5-10 yer "gap" in supply by enrollment and the time it takes to get the hours. Some say the military.. Well, training has been lower with more drone pilots and those hitting the "get out" mark and deciding to make it to full retirement. So what has to give?!

My thoughts.. After the pools are all drained and the sim aspect for atp's becomes a trickle, the next step will bring the 250-500 pilot into the regional ranks on a contract timeline with enhanced training (more sims and OE) and allow airlines to hire lower time folks with the FAA sign off. Outside of that its ab-initio, throwing the 250 hour and 1500 hour rules under the bus to full seats. Of course an economic recession or act of terrorism (God forbid), could change that dynamic. It's borrowed time on the supply curve.
 
The regionals just need to pay more. Raise the bar and seats will be filled. How about 60K to start? Is it that big of a deal between keeping the planes flying and not? Pilot pay is never the real issue in the bottom line. It's penny's on the dollar per seat.
 
The regionals just need to pay more. Raise the bar and seats will be filled. How about 60K to start? Is it that big of a deal between keeping the planes flying and not? Pilot pay is never the real issue in the bottom line. It's penny's on the dollar per seat.

While I agree with you, and ALPA agrees with you that it's a pay shortage and not a pilot shortage the question still must be asked at what cost those with ATP's in other career paths would need to walk back to the pilot world. It's not just money. It's QOL and progression as well. The cost/benefit quickly dies when margins are impacted on the regional level. Don't get me wrong, if pay/QOL/progression in a clear cut and tangible method is produced it would enhance hiring. Problem is, who will do it and at what cost. Endeavor is bringing $20K a year to attract and retain, but it's wholly owned by DL making healthy profits. What regionals could do the same and not be bankrolled by their repspective major to do so? Regionals have service agreements and either block rates or cost plus arrangements, and margins are too thin to throw a 10-30% increased cost on payroll.

Open to other ideas with the cards on the table.
 
That's not a short term bridge to collect 1000+ hours that most want or are willing to cross.... A short time while applying to regionals? Sure. Realistically 2 years working hard in a good weather area? That's where something has to give. From 2002-2007 that worked. From 2008, those who did it either loathed flying or were already too deep to do anything else. What happened during that time? Well, those in HS or first years of college ran the numbers, saw the industry, and well, "diverted". The evidence is telling in ratings acquired and enroll,met overall in 141 Approved schools.

I don't know, I think the CFI supply line has been working for quite a while.

My prediction: as pay increases, the number of new hires will increase.
 
Solid. So, a Copa thread (d)evolved into a pilot shortage thread...I shoulda known.

Did you even read OP's post?

Predictions on the next 10 years? Its so hard to buy into the idea that we've finally turned the corner after so many years of disappointment in this industry. My thoughts are with Asia and the ME3 expanding so much, it will keep the demand for pilots high, allowing for the supply to remain low in the US.
 
The regionals just need to pay more. Raise the bar and seats will be filled. How about 60K to start? Is it that big of a deal between keeping the planes flying and not? Pilot pay is never the real issue in the bottom line. It's penny's on the dollar per seat.
Unfortunately regional airlines made a deal with the devil years ago when they signed up for FFD. Initially the majors tried to keep the regionals down to a few to control branding- ContExp, American Eagle, ASA/Comair/Skywest... etc. After the Comair strike all the majors went the opposite route to the point that if a regional DID go on strike today it would be difficult to sort out the "struck work".
Regionals are now left in a dilemma. Treat their pilot group well and they have higher costs and lose flying to the bottom feeders. Once they lose flying the upgrade time slows down. New pilots don't care about contracts, they care about upgrade times so these regionals then have a problem attracting new pilots. Just look at the posts on this board. Very rarely do I hear a discussion about the quality of the pilot contract at a regional. It is always "What is the upgrade time?" No one cares about top end captain pay, 8 year FO pay, 401(k), duty rig, etc.
The next ten years will be interesting for the regional airlines as some fall by the waist or absorbed. Heck, even today I can't figure out the new callsigns.
 
Yes. Mine tops out for FOs at 8 years. I know. No pilot, regional or major, should expect to sit right seat for more than a year or two. What are they thinking??? Any FO pay past three years is a waste.
 
By 2030, airliners will be flown by one pilot and a dog. The pilot's job is to feed the dog. The dog's job will be to bite the pilot if he touches anything.
 
Back
Top