College degree requirement

One is not a "child" at 18, in any meaningful sense. Be serious.
I mean, I am being serious; the science is not on your side here.

The fact that our society insists, more or less, on cutting you loose at 18 does not match the developmental psychology. Moreover, the quote-college pipeline frequently starts at an even younger age—PSAT, if memory serves, is a sophomore year event—so in terms of large decisions (and it is, indeed, a big decision) it’s even earlier. So no, I don’t think the pressure placed on teenagers as regards college is even nearly appropriate.

Just because X sucked then or for you does not mean that X needs to continue to suck. That may be the way that it is, but it does not mean it has to be that way, or that I have to like how it is.

By your own admission:
[…]I was an utter crap high school student. Like kinda-almost-nearly flunked and got held back from Senior year, due to adolescent got-it-all-figured-out-don't-care-damn-the-man, etc.
So, again, I’m not really sure why it is you would support the system as it is, because as you said:

But boy, howdy, the system is BROKEN.
I’ll also freely admit that much of this rot comes from the universities themselves who, in many cases, do not have an obligation to serve graduating seniors or transfers in their local areas, depending upon how they’re chartered, funded and governed. (Getting a university to look at itself in a mirror is a nearly impossible exercise and don’t even ask an admissions officer to start.)

As for me, I qualified for local service area admission on the basis of either grades or SATs, whichever metric you wanted to use; I never really had any strong interest in going anywhere though I did consider Riddle for undergrad—nope, no dinero—so the local CSU it was, and honestly, it was far more fun, far cheaper, and a far better student experience than I think anywhere else could have been. Mildly bruised ego in a sea of people going to Berkeley, Stanford, UCLA, USC? Sure, but wtf-ever.
 
My advice to a new pilot would be this: You can do almost any education online these days, go to Endeavor (or whatever regional De Jure) and then take classes towards a BS in some thing you’re interested in online.

Highly recommend this approach. Works good, last long time.
 
So are you just willfully ignoring the science that shows brain development is still in full swing until 25, or are you claiming the science is all wrong?

The science is a bit of a mess, or at least attempts to apply it to public policy. Much of the research has focused on impulsiveness and rationality in decision-making. It gets messy when environmental factors are shown to determine the category and trajectory of impulsive action. So, toss out the science and we are looking at the same social factors we always examined.

It seems like a bunch of social scientists are grabbing the hard science and attempting to advance their agendas.
 
So are you just willfully ignoring the science that shows brain development is still in full swing until 25, or are you claiming the science is all wrong?

cognitive Science and philosophy is the principle reason why I don’t support prison sentences in excess of around 10 years ish.

the jury is decidedly out as to whether you’re the “same” person you were 10 years ago. What makes you a person, the brain or the pattern of the mind? It’s some serious ship of Theseus stuff. We could be punishing people who don’t even exist yet… that troubles me greatly.

even if you’re not as radical about it as me, why we allow people at 18 to make decisions that could change the course of their life without guidance (sign up to kill people with rifles, and take out massive loans, etc) is astounding to me. as for crime, people tend to age out of crime - not a lot of 35 year old dudes knocking over 7-11s.

regardless I wish we lived in a world where we had more compassion about the mistakes of our youths, or at least tried to support them a bit better
 
cognitive Science and philosophy is the principle reason why I don’t support prison sentences in excess of around 10 years ish.

the jury is decidedly out as to whether you’re the “same” person you were 10 years ago. What makes you a person, the brain or the pattern of the mind? It’s some serious ship of Theseus stuff. We could be punishing people who don’t even exist yet… that troubles me greatly.

even if you’re not as radical about it as me, why we allow people at 18 to make decisions that could change the course of their life without guidance (sign up to kill people with rifles, and take out massive loans, etc) is astounding to me. as for crime, people tend to age out of crime - not a lot of 35 year old dudes knocking over 7-11s.

regardless I wish we lived in a world where we had more compassion about the mistakes of our youths, or at least tried to support them a bit better

Just when I think you're irredeemable, you bring up a Ship of Theseus reference and now I just want to hang out and talk philosophy. :bounce:
 
Just when I think you're irredeemable, you bring up a Ship of Theseus reference and now I just want to hang out and talk philosophy. :bounce:

I mean, I didn’t come to these conclusions by a lack of exploring them lol. Took me about 10 years to reach this (admittedly addled) state.

but I absolutely am irredeemable compost in training

but yah let’s hang out
 
So are you just willfully ignoring the science that shows brain development is still in full swing until 25, or are you claiming the science is all wrong?

Well of course, my Todd, ignoring it and thinking it's "all wrong" aren't my only two options. Is this some weird artifact of your snake-handling past? Man is not perfectible, and there's no discreet, absolute point at which one becomes an adult (or anything else, for that matter). Many of your systems are breaking down from long before adulthood. Your arteries, for example, are clogging in utero. So, of course, any designation of "adulthood" is to some degree arbitrary. Being ethically responsible for one's own behavior is certainly not rationally contingent upon one's brain not changing (because of course it never stops changing, links are being created and destroyed every second of every day). I don't know what your experience was, but I was unequivocally capable of taking responsibility for myself uhm a long time before I was 25. Alexander the Great had conquered all of Asia Minor and was juuuuust about to put the finishing touches on the Persian Empire when he was 25.
 
Well of course, my Todd, ignoring it and thinking it's "all wrong" aren't my only two options. Is this some weird artifact of your snake-handling past? Man is not perfectible, and there's no discreet, absolute point at which one becomes an adult (or anything else, for that matter). Many of your systems are breaking down from long before adulthood. Your arteries, for example, are clogging in utero. So, of course, any designation of "adulthood" is to some degree arbitrary. Being ethically responsible for one's own behavior is certainly not rationally contingent upon one's brain not changing (because of course it never stops changing, links are being created and destroyed every second of every day). I don't know what your experience was, but I was unequivocally capable of taking responsibility for myself uhm a long time before I was 25. Alexander the Great had conquered all of Asia Minor and was juuuuust about to put the finishing touches on the Persian Empire when he was 25.

You would be very hard pressed to find any psychologist or neuroscientist who would agree with your opinion here. The parts of the brain that are still developing until 25 are specifically the parts that are responsible for judgment and decision making.
 
If I ever do the lawyer thing, my passion project is likely to be eviction defense, just to piss off Todd.

The appellate district for my state is walking distance.

I operate in states where eviction defense basically isn't a thing. The judges are pretty simple with it:

Judge: "Did you pay your rent?"

Tenant: "No, but..."

Judge: "Judgment in favor of the plaintiff, be out in 7 days. Next!"

As it f'n should be.
 
This far have I gone, but no farther. I will hold the line.

"We are trained for espionage. We would be legends, but the records are sealed.
Glory in battle is not our way.
Think of our heroes: The Silent Step, who defeated an entire nation with a single shot.
Or the Ever Alert, who kept armies at bay with hidden facts.
These giants do not seem to give us solace here, but they are not all that we are.
Before the network, there was the fleet.
Before diplomacy, there were soldiers.
Our influence stopped the Rachni, but before that, we held the line.
Our influence stopped the Krogan, but before that, we held the line.
Our influence will stop Saren. In the battle today, we will hold the line!"
-Captain Kirrahe, Salarian STG 3rd IR

Post things like this and you'll be the goddess of my idolatry.

Well played.
 
You would be very hard pressed to find any psychologist or neuroscientist who would agree with your opinion here. The parts of the brain that are still developing until 25 are specifically the parts that are responsible for judgment and decision making.

I was always told typically age 22, but that it can be up to age 25. As in not all cases is the frontal lobe done maturing at age. 25.

Spend a day or two at the county courthouse.

Thats the real world, not the MySpaceBookVerse.

Or work a year in juvenile dentention. Or an adolescent psych unit.
 
Boris’s way is why people used to start working horrible jobs that they hated at a young age and could never escape, while meanwhile marrying the first girl they held hands with at age 17 and spending the rest of their life miserable and angry. But hey, they were “adults.”

Just like for full color, here, my grandfather died in the late 90s, after his wife (who, yes, was the first girl he set his eyes to) slowly expired, after having had horrifying dementia for about a decade. She'd scream, throw things, say unspeakably unpleasant things to him (and to a lesser extent, everyone else). Wasn't her fault, her brain was deteriorating from the inside out. He shuffled out to her bed and brought her whatever she asked for, every time. She threw a plate or a fork? He picked it up. She pissed the bed? He cleaned it. Again, never a word of complaint.

Has the possibility occurred to you that *WE* are the ones who have lost something? They were never angry with each other, that I saw (pre-mind-loss). They held hands in *ahem* any socially-appropriate circumstance. Even when they were 70+. There was none of this constant seeking for some imaginary thing they didn't have. They had it. They loved each other tremendously, as far as I understand the what the term means. Certainly, he'd have jumped in front of a speeding truck or bullet for her, and I think that when she was in her right mind, she would have done the same for him. Are we the lucky ones, do you think? Are you sure? In any case, they were explicitly NOT "miserable and angry" people. That, I'm 100% sure of. They seemed pretty happy, to me, insofar as that's a meaningful term. "Miserable and angry" sounds more like a phrase I would use to describe...I dunno, US? Certainly, you, Mr. Grinch! Merry Christmas, btw.
 
Back
Top