Client Supplied Aircraft

ComplexHiAv8r

Well-Known Member
I want to make sure that this is all on the up, so here it goes.

I have a client that told me today that if I got qualified for their single engine aircraft, that I could start using it for travel when on their business. To this point they have been reimbursing me for commercial tickets. The plane is not local, so they would still fly me commercial to it, then I would use it to travel to multiple sites, return home commercial.

It will add some time to my travel as I usual head home from the last facility, now I will have to fly back to the original location to return the plane.

My questions (please correct if wrong):
1. I know that as I need to do the travel I don’t need my commercial. I need to work on it soon!
2. From time to time other Engineers will be traveling with me also.
a. If I need to make the trip all is good.
b. If I didn’t need to make the trip, I need my commercial, or become an employee to remain Part 91.
3. They indicated me paying to get qualified, told 10-15 hours in type
4. I need to make sure I am placed (by name) on the insurance

I normally charge $35/hr for travel time, but figure they are going to want a discount since they are providing the plane. Recommendations on what I should charge, as it is for my time, not as a pilot, but in transit to location. (I would really like to keep the $35, but don’t think they will go for it).

We meet next week to discuss it further.

Thanks in advance.
 
[ QUOTE ]
1. I know that as I need to do the travel I don’t need my commercial. I need to work on it soon!

[/ QUOTE ]You. Right. All you need is a private certificate to travel on personal business.
[ QUOTE ]
2. From time to time other Engineers will be traveling with me also.
a. If I need to make the trip all is good.

[/ QUOTE ]Essentially correct. Even though you're being compensated for the flight, because it's incidental to your business as an engineer (the job doesn't require flying) you're safely in 61.113(b)(1) territory.
[ QUOTE ]

b. If I didn’t need to make the trip, I need my commercial, or become an employee to remain Part 91.

[/ QUOTE ]Pretty much. Actually you'd need your commercial whether or not you were an employee. Once your job becomes flying other employees around, you are out of the protection of 61.113(b)

[ QUOTE ]
4. I need to make sure I am placed (by name) on the insurance

[/ QUOTE ]Yep. And not as a "named pilot." That doesn't give you any protection. You need to be placed on it as an "additional insured" (sometimes called "additional named insured."

[ QUOTE ]
I normally charge $35/hr for travel time, but figure they are going to want a discount since they are providing the plane.

[/ QUOTE ] Maybe not. It's till you time it's being paid for and there were paying traveling expenses otherwise, weren't they? I wouldn't change my hourly rate just because they think its more convenient for you to have access to an airplane.
 
[ QUOTE ]

[ QUOTE ]

b. If I didn’t need to make the trip, I need my commercial, or become an employee to remain Part 91.

[/ QUOTE ]Pretty much. Actually you'd need your commercial whether or not you were an employee. Once your job becomes flying other employees around, you are out of the protection of 61.113(b)

[/ QUOTE ]

Depends whether said flying is his primary duty, or incidental to his employment. If the only reason he's on the payroll is to fly engineers around, yeah, he'd need a commercial ticket. If he does something else for the company a majority of the time and only flies for them occasionally, all he needs is a private ticket.
 
[ QUOTE ]
Depends whether said flying is his primary duty, or incidental to his employment. If the only reason he's on the payroll is to fly engineers around, yeah, he'd need a commercial ticket. If he does something else for the company a majority of the time and only flies for them occasionally, all he needs is a private ticket.

[/ QUOTE ]I don't think that's right. The first time that he flies the engineers to a meeting the he's not attending, I don't think it's incidental. As I look at the way the FAA has enforced this, "incidental" doesn't mean "part time." It means that your flying is related to you non-flying job duties. Once even part of the job becomes flying, it's no longer "incidental."
 
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Depends whether said flying is his primary duty, or incidental to his employment. If the only reason he's on the payroll is to fly engineers around, yeah, he'd need a commercial ticket. If he does something else for the company a majority of the time and only flies for them occasionally, all he needs is a private ticket.

[/ QUOTE ]I don't think that's right. The first time that he flies the engineers to a meeting the he's not attending, I don't think it's incidental. As I look at the way the FAA has enforced this, "incidental" doesn't mean "part time." It means that your flying is related to you non-flying job duties. Once even part of the job becomes flying, it's no longer "incidental."

[/ QUOTE ]
yeahthat.gif



Don't consider it as "incidental," instead think of it as the "purpose for flight." If you are considered to be the only reason for the "purpose for flight" then a PPL will do fine. But, the FAA has violated others in the past for a "secondary reason for flight." That being considered, anytime there is something that is not "primary for the flight" being taken into consideration for the flight, it becomes out of the realm of a PPL and must be accomplished by a commercial pilot.

Example.... Person "A" has a PPL and has a job which requires him to fly from one point to another every week on Tuesday. He takes along some other coworkers (person B) to help him along the way. Then one Monday, he finds out he is not needed to be there on Tuesday, but person "b" will be needed. Person 'B" is not a pilot, and cannot fly for himself. Person "A" cannot fly Person "B" to the meeting on Tuesday because he (a) is not the Primary purpose of flight. If he had a commercial pilots license he would be fine to do it, but he does not have the license to be paid as a pilot and therefore is limited to that.

It is a regulation that is very vague but is very clear cut once research is done. This protects a lot of parties. The commercial pilot is protected, so that he will have a job, the company is protected - so their employees will arrive in the safest manner, and the private pilot is protected - he will not be allowed to do something in which his/her skill level is not up to.

Thats all it comes down to.... Skill level. It is a very low level layer of protection the government has set in place to keep low time pilots from loading up a plane with coworkers, and having an accident. Instead a Commercial pilot (usually with more experience) will fly the plane... and in theory do it safer.
 
Thanks for the answers.

For the comments above, if person B is a pilot, but asks A to tag along because he wants another pilot with him, then what would it be?
 
[ QUOTE ]
Thanks for the answers.

For the comments above, if person B is a pilot, but asks A to tag along because he wants another pilot with him, then what would it be?

[/ QUOTE ]Not a problem. As shinysideup said (great post, BTW), in your scenario, so long as the flight is =your= need to travel, it doesn't matter =from a regulation standpoint= whether a friend, pilot or non-pilot, comes along.

Insurance for a non-related party who comes along on a business flight, may or may not be an issue. I don't know. Someone familiar with the specific policy (and knows how to read insurance policies) would be able to answer that one.

BTW, notice that I said "in your scenario." As shinyside said, 61.113 is a regulation that attempts to balance a number of policies. The result is some simple wording that has bee interpreted extensively through the years, mostly as a result of folks who search for loopholes (that usually close around them). It's very fact-specific. Change one small fact, and the answer can change completely.
 
[ QUOTE ]
Thanks for the answers.

For the comments above, if person B is a pilot, but asks A to tag along because he wants another pilot with him, then what would it be?

[/ QUOTE ]

Then in that case... all is good. I used to ride along with someone who was a pilot flying in a rental aircraft for business purposes just as a safety pilot. This is not only legal, but in my eyes, I would encourage it. Two pilots are always better then one.
 
Back
Top