CAPT AND ASA!!! EVERYONE DOUBTING TAKE A LOOK!!!

Re: CAPT AND ASA!!! EVERYONE DOUBTING TAKE A LOOK

[ QUOTE ]
Do hours make a great pilot, is that what you are insinuating, or blatantly saying?

[/ QUOTE ]

Yeah, pretty much. That and experience in many different types of aircraft, flying environments, and a variety of mentors from different areas of aviation.

Just by playing the odds, how many actual emergencies or just plain tight spots will a pilot get into in 300 hours? Probably one or none. Can you count on a 1500 hour pilot to have at least a few good stories? You bet.

I was told at some point that instructors and especially DEs usually have to make the ultimate decision of "would I let this person take my loved ones for a flight?". For me, in regards to a very low-time pilot in an RJ, the answer would be no. Personal opinion of course.

Look dude, you obviously have a very different point of view than I do, and I can respect that. So lets not escalate discussion into arguement (mostly talking about another thread). These discussions are always interesting and I usually learn something in the process, and thats always a good thing.
 
Re: CAPT AND ASA!!! EVERYONE DOUBTING TAKE A LOOK

I find this thread interesting, not because of the arguments (they are getting old), but because of some of the people involved:

Tyrael has 8 total post and of these 5 can be summarized as, 'CAPT is the Greatest Thing Ever!'

GoAround has 15 total post, all having to do with CAPT.

Firefly has only one post, the one in this thread.

I would have to suspect that all are either employees of Riddle, or mindless CAPT groupies. I woulod guess they are employees.

[ QUOTE ]
Do hours make a great pilot, is that what you are insinuating, or blatantly saying? I hope not! There is no substantial evidence to support such insidious words. The pinnacle situation was not due to low time pilots. Accident history disfavorably slaps your argument to the turf. Human error is most often attributed to attitude, not time logged, although perhaps the latter is adversely affecting the former, do you feel yourself failing, as the hours build?

[/ QUOTE ] As for you Francais, this is the second post where you have attacked and insulted a poster (who probably has more experience than you) who has questioned the wisdom of putting very low time pilots in the pointy end of a jet. All I can say is that you have a lot to learn, and not only about flying. You will not win any friends or influence any people if you insult everyone who disagrees with you.

As for your post, I am not sure what you are trying to 'insinuate'. It is true that accidents spike at certain times as pilot's build time, and some of this is caused by attitude. It is also caused by pilots 'leaving the nest' and flying in more challenging situations and more complex equipment.

Later on in your career you may learn that there are 4 stages to learning.

1. Rote - I memorized it but do not know what it means.
2. Understanding - I understand.
3. Application - I can use what I know.
4. Correlation - I can apply what I have learned to unfamiliar situations.

Most low time pilots are at the application level. They know how to fly and they know the regulations, but it takes effort. For example, they may use little acronyms to help them remember how to set up for an approach. This is not what you want crewing a jet. You want someone who can fly IFR and operate the aircraft with out thinking about it, the same way you drive your car. You also want someone who has the experience and judgment to deal with any unforeseen difficulties that arise during the flight.

For some reason there are always people here who discount experience. It is possible to have a low time pilot who is very good. But they are still probably lacking in some areas. The biggest is probably situational awareness and the ability to deal with new, unexpected situations.

Insurance is often the big bugaboo of aviation. We all like to moan about how much it cost and how much time we have to have to do certain things, but there is a very real reason behind it. The insurance industry could easily make money insuring 300 hour pilots in their new single pilot jets. So, why is it that they will not even consider insuring a pilot at this level of experience? Is it because the insurance companies are stupid? Or is it because they know that there is a high probability that the low time pilot will make a smoking hole in the ground, which will cost them a lot of money? The same goes for FSI, why does one of the largest and most well known training providers have a policy against type rating pilots with less than 1,000 hours. They could possibly make some more money if they did. Are they stupid, or is there a very real reason?

Think about it.
 
Re: CAPT AND ASA!!! EVERYONE DOUBTING TAKE A LOOK

[ QUOTE ]
Later on in your career you may learn that there are 4 stages to learning.

1. Rote - I memorized it but do not know what it means.
2. Understanding - I understand.
3. Application - I can use what I know.
4. Correlation - I can apply what I have learned to unfamiliar situations.


[/ QUOTE ]

Nah, remember what CAPT is doing is new, exciting and it works. Soon there will be no more CFIs, so we won't have to worry about this FOI stuff.....
sarcasm.gif
 
Re: CAPT AND ASA!!! EVERYONE DOUBTING TAKE A LOOK

[ QUOTE ]
Do hours make a great pilot, is that what you are insinuating, or blatantly saying? I hope not! There is no substantial evidence to support such insidious words. The pinnacle situation was not due to low time pilots. Accident history disfavorably slaps your argument to the turf. Human error is most often attributed to attitude, not time logged, although perhaps the latter is adversely affecting the former, do you feel yourself failing, as the hours build?

[/ QUOTE ]

Ah, young Padawan......so much to learn in the field of aviation.....the reality versus the book theory.

rolleyes.gif


BTW, where did Seth the CAPT answer man go? He's MIA.
 
Re: CAPT AND ASA!!! EVERYONE DOUBTING TAKE A LOOK

"Do hours make a great pilot, is that what you are insinuating, or blatantly saying? I hope not! There is no substantial evidence to support such insidious words."

Experience is what makes a great pilot. Experience in our business is partly defined by hours and partly defined by the way you got those hours. A person who does most of their training in a sim and gets a jet type rating with 300 hours has a very specific and narrow type of experience, and not even very much of that. That person will do better than most in regional airline sim training and maybe even ground school, because it's such a ground intensive program. Where it all falls apart is when you hit the real world outside the training enviornment. The 300 hour, jet type rated, new hire doesn't know enough about the real world to be a proper asset in the cockpit. They need to be babysat. Sure, after a while, they catch up and it's no big deal, other than it will take them a LONG time before they have the hours to upgrade.

When you look at the cost/benefit ratio of a CAPT or FSA direct entry program, you gotta look at whether it's worth it to spend all that money to get hired at 300 hours. For some, it's worth it, but I don't think it's the best way to go. The amount of hours and experience to get on with a regional can be attained the "traditional" way with maybe a year of extra flying if you instruct for a while. Not everyone wants to instruct, for those, I'd say the CAPT scheme might be worth it. For the older career changer who is in a hurry, perhaps a year or two makes a big difference. But for your average young joe looking to get into the profession, in my mind you'll be a much more well rounded pilot and a better stick by doing it the "traditional" way.

Why do I really hate the CAPT program? The marketing statements that make it seem easy to be an airline pilot if you just do their program. I recently got a CAPT brochure in the mail that implied that in one year you'll be flying for Delta. That's irresponsible. If their marketing is BS, then maybe so is the rest of their program.....
 
Re: CAPT AND ASA!!! EVERYONE DOUBTING TAKE A LOOK

"BTW, where did Seth the CAPT answer man go? He's MIA."

I was wondering the same thing. I've got the impression from his posts that he tries to gloss over the real issue kinda like what you'd expect from a company PR guy. Not that there is anything really wrong with that, if you're paid to be a company PR guy, but as far as any getting any critial answers for the jetcareers membership towards the CAPT program, I've been sadly dissapointed.

For example: Seth, do you agree with the CAPT marketing brochure saying "fly the big jets in one year" and have a pic of a Delta MD88 next to it? Does the CAPT program target their grads as new hires on MD88's at Delta airlines?
 
Re: CAPT AND ASA!!! EVERYONE DOUBTING TAKE A LOOK

[ QUOTE ]
"BTW, where did Seth the CAPT answer man go? He's MIA."

I was wondering the same thing. I've got the impression from his posts that he tries to gloss over the real issue kinda like what you'd expect from a company PR guy. Not that there is anything really wrong with that, if you're paid to be a company PR guy, but as far as any getting any critial answers for the jetcareers membership towards the CAPT program, I've been sadly dissapointed.

For example: Seth, do you agree with the CAPT marketing brochure saying "fly the big jets in one year" and have a pic of a Delta MD88 next to it? Does the CAPT program target their grads as new hires on MD88's at Delta airlines?

[/ QUOTE ]

No, he's not MIA, but he hasn't been checking the board as of late because he has been task saturated.
grin.gif


I will be answering the specific questions a little later on today. Also, I am asking everyone to please redirect their questions to the CAPT Q&A thread.

Thanks and regards,

Seth
 
Re: CAPT AND ASA!!! EVERYONE DOUBTING TAKE A LOOK

[ QUOTE ]
There is no substantial evidence to support such insidious words. The pinnacle situation was not due to low time pilots.

[/ QUOTE ]
Both were Gulfstream (academy) pilots.
The FO was a newhire with less than 4 months in th RJ.
The Captain had been with Pinnacle for 20 months, but only 9 months as a Capt. They had 2 pilots new to their respective positions, and one of them a low time newhire. Neither could have had very much high altitude experience. Before anyone states it, yes, the Capt had over 6000 hours. However, the majority of his "professional" flight time was in the B1900 (Below FL300). Therefore, it is likely that his only high altitude flight time, came in his brief (approx) 11 months as an RJ FO.

[ QUOTE ]
Human error is most often attributed to attitude, not time logged...

[/ QUOTE ]
...and the attitude that you can do it all at 300 hours is a bad attitude.
 
Re: CAPT AND ASA!!! EVERYONE DOUBTING TAKE A LOOK

[ QUOTE ]
...and the attitude that you can do it all at 300 hours is a bad attitude.

[/ QUOTE ]

I wouldn't say it's necessarily a "bad" attitude as long as you take into account some other factors. Number one, you won't know near enough as far as real world ops go. With the exception of speed and altitude, there's a lot of similarities b/w flying an RJ and a 172. The challenge is, you have fewer options in the 172. You can't outclimb weather, you don't know where the t-storms are if you're IMC (unless you're lucky and flying a weather radar equipped bug smasher) and you're aircraft is a tad bit more sensitive to turbulence. ALL of those factors if experienced in a 172 will help when you get to the airlines. You can look back on that long cross country where you had to make the divert or punch through call in the 172 and realize that you can actually climb above that stuff now. Flight planning as far as winds aloft are also a concern. You want to get there quicker, so the altitude you planned for might not have as favorable winds or a smooth ride. That's when you have to make the judgement call to ask for another altitude. A 300 hour pilot trained in sims isn't gonna learn ANY of that in ground school. They're too busy dealing with engine fires and other emergencies. This is all stuff you SHOULD know going into ground school. How do you learn it? Experience. Get out and DO it.

Now, back to the attitude thing. If a 300 hour pilot thinks he's gonna be on par with everyone else, that might be true in ground school if they've gotten type specific training. Once out on the line, that learning curve is gonna get REAL steep, though. I once thought that a 300 hour pilot would be just as good as a 600-1200 hour pilot if they got type specific training. Actually getting out and flying a couple of multi-state cross countries along with training for my CFI ratings more or less slapped me into my senses, and I'm at 260 hours right now. I'd scare the crap out of myself if I wound up in the right seat of an RJ in 40 hours. Now, if I went to ATP and took an RJ course for those 40 hours, I could fly the plane. However, the ADM that goes along with it wouldn't be near enough to handle the speed at which things happen. Any 300 hour pilot that comes in to airline training with the attitude that they're gonna be equal to everyone in that class is setting themselves up for a big fall. I know of couple of guys that went through MAPD and did exactly that, and they washed out of CRJ ground school at Mesa. Couple more guys washed out in the sims later. Having the attitude that you can do it in 300 hours CAN work, but you have to realize that you're gonna be behind the curve a LOT and you'll more than likely be putting some extra mental stress on your captains.
 
Re: CAPT AND ASA!!! EVERYONE DOUBTING TAKE A LOOK

Why everyone in such a hurry to get out of college/flight school and run to the airlines. You're getting payed the same amount of money, as a new hire at some of these airlines, as you would be making as a CFI. Heck, in some places, you can make more as a CFI than you would as a new hire FO at some of these low time pick-up airlines. But no, everybody trying to hurry up and hop in something "big and fast" and get paid next to nothing for it.

What is it to you to do a good year or two of some tough CFI'ing so when you get to the airlines to have just a tad more experience? So you can get some real IMC in something a little more your speed before throwing yourself into something that you would probably kill yourself in if the captain went down for the count....

No thanks. I would rather be a good FO than a seat warmer. So I will take my time and do it the right way.
 
Re: CAPT AND ASA!!! EVERYONE DOUBTING TAKE A LOOK

[ QUOTE ]
Why everyone in such a hurry to get out of college/flight school and run to the airlines. You're getting payed the same amount of money, as a new hire at some of these airlines, as you would be making as a CFI. Heck, in some places, you can make more as a CFI than you would as a new hire FO at some of these low time pick-up airlines. But no, everybody trying to hurry up and hop in something "big and fast" and get paid next to nothing for it.

What is it to you to do a good year or two of some tough CFI'ing so when you get to the airlines to have just a tad more experience? So you can get some real IMC in something a little more your speed before throwing yourself into something that you would probably kill yourself in if the captain went down for the count....

No thanks. I would rather be a good FO than a seat warmer. So I will take my time and do it the right way.


[/ QUOTE ]

Next time I'm in Dallas, beers are on me.
rawk.gif
 
Re: CAPT AND ASA!!! EVERYONE DOUBTING TAKE A LOOK

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
yeahthat.gif
Let me know. We have a pretty nice size group of JCers in the DFW. Maybe we can get something together.

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]


Now, back to the attitude thing. If a 300 hour pilot thinks he's gonna be on par with everyone else, that might be true in ground school if they've gotten type specific training. Once out on the line, that learning curve is gonna get REAL steep, though. I once thought that a 300 hour pilot would be just as good as a 600-1200 hour pilot if they got type specific training. Actually getting out and flying a couple of multi-state cross countries along with training for my CFI ratings more or less slapped me into my senses, and I'm at 260 hours right now. I'd scare the crap out of myself if I wound up in the right seat of an RJ in 40 hours. Now, if I went to ATP and took an RJ course for those 40 hours, I could fly the plane. However, the ADM that goes along with it wouldn't be near enough to handle the speed at which things happen. Any 300 hour pilot that comes in to airline training with the attitude that they're gonna be equal to everyone in that class is setting themselves up for a big fall. I know of couple of guys that went through MAPD and did exactly that, and they washed out of CRJ ground school at Mesa. Couple more guys washed out in the sims later. Having the attitude that you can do it in 300 hours CAN work, but you have to realize that you're gonna be behind the curve a LOT and you'll more than likely be putting some extra mental stress on your captains.

[/ QUOTE ]

Thats exactly why I am so interested in the SimuFlite Right Seat Program. It is a cheap and forgiving way of practicing how to be a good FO while I am CFI'ing it for the next two years.
 
Re: CAPT AND ASA!!! EVERYONE DOUBTING TAKE A LOOK

Not sure how I feel about the SimuFlite thing. I think we talked about this over Sonic burgers, though. I still think I'd rather get paid SOMETHING, even if I'm just a gear monkey for someone else getting the type rating......
 
Re: CAPT AND ASA!!! EVERYONE DOUBTING TAKE A LOOK

[ QUOTE ]


[/ QUOTE ]
I would never argue that experience couldn't be helpful, but one can't argue that it always is. Reason being, experience doesn't ensure your having to deal with major issues. How many pilots fly the same route for thousands of hours and ne'er experience anything notable. How many hours are spent becoming more and more complacent? I would never disagree that thousands of quality hours with someone with the proper attitude isn't an advantage over the low time pilot. Yet to generalize that experience is always an advantage is probably just as irresponsible as saying a 300 hour is as capable as a 5000 hour pilot
 
Re: CAPT AND ASA!!! EVERYONE DOUBTING TAKE A LOOK

[ QUOTE ]
How many pilots fly the same route for thousands of hours and ne'er experience anything notable. How many hours are spent becoming more and more complacent?

[/ QUOTE ]

That's the key. If you're not learning something nearly every flight, anything, then you're screwing up. No two flights are exactly the same, differing conditions, differing things to experience, etc. All that adds up as one gains hours.
 
Re: CAPT AND ASA!!! EVERYONE DOUBTING TAKE A LOOK

[ QUOTE ]
Not sure how I feel about the SimuFlite thing. I think we talked about this over Sonic burgers, though. I still think I'd rather get paid SOMETHING, even if I'm just a gear monkey for someone else getting the type rating......

[/ QUOTE ]

I thought there had to be more to it when I saw it on the SimuFlite website also. It just looked to good to be true. But after talking to Jason and some other people PMing me information, it is actually not a bad deal. You get free training, a free SIC checkride, and you get a free type rating ride after committing a certain amount of time to the program. Thats thousands and thousands of dollars worth of free stuff. You might even get a job out of it if you save the right persons butt. And you only have volunteer when you feel like.
 
Re: CAPT AND ASA!!! EVERYONE DOUBTING TAKE A LOOK

[ QUOTE ]
I thought there had to be more to it when I saw it on the SimuFlite website also. It just looked to good to be true. But after talking to Jason and some other people PMing me information, it is actually not a bad deal. You get free training, a free SIC checkride, and you get a free type rating ride after committing a certain amount of time to the program. Thats thousands and thousands of dollars worth of free stuff. You might even get a job out of it if you save the right persons butt. And you only have volunteer when you feel like.


[/ QUOTE ]

How does it work as far as locations? I checked out their website and didn't find anything. Is it all over the country or just in a certain area?
 
Re: CAPT AND ASA!!! EVERYONE DOUBTING TAKE A LOOK

[ QUOTE ]

How does it work as far as locations? I checked out their website and didn't find anything. Is it all over the country or just in a certain area?

[/ QUOTE ]

Heres information about the program http://www.simuflite.com/career/rightseat.html

I don't know if it is anywhere else except in the DFW. Maybe someone else can help you with that.
 
Back
Top