[ QUOTE ]
The point is that there is never a time to do a single engine go around. A plane pulls out in front of you, land to the side, in the grass. Weather below mins? Emergency superceeds that. The reason it is not in the PTS anymore is because people were killing themselves.
[/ QUOTE ]
The bigger point is that you need to have the SA to know what to do and when. Emergency and land, or go around. YOU as the PIC must make the decision, must know if you can accomplish it or not. There's no absolute right or wrong answer, it's situation dependant:
1. Situation #1: You are recovering single-engine to El Centro, California in the middle of winter (airport elevation, minus 15), temp very cold, after a s hour flight (low on fuel). Proverbial car pulls out on runway, do you land on the taxiway or in the grass, or do you take it around. YOU should know the performance potential of your aircraft at all times. In this case, if you were able to execute the go around, performance-wise, and elected to put it in the grass (assuming simple engine failure, no other problems) and ended up collapsing the gear or other major damage, who then is at fault? You as the PIC, since your decision wasn't prudent.
2. Same situation as above, but lets assume Flagstaff, Arizona in the summer, high temp and density altitude of 9000'. Car pulls onto runway and you elect to take it around, only to end up 1 mile off the runway impacting someone's house and killing the whole family, you happen to survive with minor injuries. Who'd at fault? What would've been the more prudent thing to do? Likely putting it in the infield grass/dirt or taxiway, and any damage sustained then can be justified as the more prudent decision.
It all comes down to maintain SA on your aircraft and making sound judgements as PIC. One answer does not fit all situations. And as PIC, not only are you responsible for you, you aircraft, and your pax, but YOU are also responsible for people on the ground that your plane flies over, whether on or off airport. If they get killed or injured due to your unsound judgement, lack of SA, or not knowing your job; then you've got the responsibliity there.