Boeing/Airbus hybrid engines!?

You could only do it with piston aircraft. Jets work much different from car engines and also propel themselves differently. A hybrid Jet engine just wouldn't work. Take a look at how a jet engine works and you will see why.

Currently the best way to help a jet aircraft be more fuel efficient is to use better designs to reduce drag.

Actually, jet engines and pistons engines though different, operate on pretty similar principles.
 
Getting back to the original question here.... the key reason why a hybrid power plant will not work on an aircraft is simple: constant load. In a road vehicle, tremendous energy is wasted both in producing power (a gasoline engine is, at best 35% efficient. A diesel, at best, is 55%. The rest is wasted heat out the exhaust and out the radiator) and in converting energy to heat in the form of braking- energy that is lost. Gasoline engines, in particular, are only remotely efficient at high load (i.e. wide open throttle). This is why those teams that build "weird" cars and test them in the desert can achieve over 100MPG by using "coast and burn," where the car operates full throttle, accelerates to a calculated maximum speed, then shuts off the engine, costs down to a calculated minimum speed, and does it again. In a street car, 95% of driving is part throttle, where the gasoline engine is least efficient. This is why diesels are much better as they are efficient at lower load. A hybrid uses regenerative braking to convert rotational energy into electrical energy and store it for use once the car needs to accelerate again.

The real gains in a hybrid car come from using the electrical system for low load and to recapture wasted energy from braking. Airplanes simply don't do these things. They accelerate, take off, climb, and then level off at a constant power setting (which is still relatively high, say 65% power). There are no low load conditions and obviously no "stop and go" flight. There simply is not gain to be had by a hybrid power plant here.

I agree, somewhere in the future, hydrogen is likely to become the fuel of choice, especially if/when we can make nuclear fusion viable and use excess electrical energy during low demand periods to split hydrogen off of water to be used for fuel.
 
Actually, jet engines and pistons engines though different, operate on pretty similar principles.

To an extent, the only thing is that a piston engine will produce power and the prop takes the power and turns it to thrust. A jet engine just produces thrust. Hence the difference in drag (power) curves for each aircraft type. This is also the reason we rate jet engines in pounds of thrust and piston aircraft in Horsepower.

We could implement a energy driven engine to help sustain level flight and then when needing the extra power to climb or accelerate the piston engine would kick in more power. This would be very similar as with hybrid cars.

The problem with the jet engine is that the electric motor wouldn't help other than with starting the engine. Two totally different engine types.

Patrick gives other good points as to why it wouldn't work with aircraft in general.

Patrick, I would think the static in flight could help charge the battery, but then again it most likely wouldn't be enough to make it anywhere near worth while.

Also don't forget that these fuel cells/batteries, whatever they are are very heavy and would reduce the useful load tremendously. Especially in our little piston aircraft.
 
Well.. with all this non-sense high fuel prices rising, and the end of this not anywhere close (aparently), Airlines going out of bussines, and those who are not barely braking even, I just wonder how posible would it be for GE or some big engine manufacturer to come up with a fuel efficient plane (engine).
I know they have been working on that for years, and they are coming up with more and more fuel efficient planes (787,etc). But still, their main source of enery its Fuel! therefore their small profit margin will be ruled by fuel prices.
I wonder if it would be possible for them to come up with big engines (not talking about small GA ones, or for UL´s, thats ¨¨easy¨¨, Im talking about engines for Airliners, wich would work based on a Fuel/Energy Basis (hybrid), or perhaps just electrical power. Is it possible? Would the switch to hybrid engine compromise the engine´s performance drastically?.
Note that there are hybrid cars on the market with really good aceptable performance. So thats why I think. If you can come up with Fuel saving cars and busses, why not airplanes?.
I know if that could happen, the convertion to ¨¨hybrid¨¨ per say, would not be afordable probably to some airlines, But just thinking in the long run, how posible, affordable, and Cost saving would be?

To the original poster.

Everytime I see your avatar why do I think you're about to bust out in a verse of Chocolate Rain!

:D :laff:
 
Sure, you could use some static discharge to charge the battery, but to what extent? Lets just say we're talking a 160HP piston Warrior. In level flight, at 55% power, thats 88 HP needed to maintain. An 88 HP hybrid motor, drive system, likely a planetary gearbox to feed the prop, and now, for the big problem- BATTERIES. You're looking at several hundred pounds of equipment, even with the uber exotic lithium batteries.

The real "problem" with off of the discussions related to alternative fuels is the simple fact that oil is just too damn convenient. You pump it out of the ground, refine it, and burn it. Its liquid, and easy to contain. It has a relatively high specific energy. Internal combustion is also a very proven science at this point, hence its low cost. Really, the problem with internal combustion is its lack of efficiency due to tremendous wasted heat, at least on a car. Jets are quite a bit better, as that heat is what creates thrust and so there is much less wasted. The giant diesels in locomotives and ships are very efficient when you factor in the total use of the energy, as sure, they still have the heat losses in terms of fuel used vs energy created for propulsion, however, they use almost all of that excess heat aboard the vessel for heating and other uses. Being large, heavy vehicles, they can also benefit from recapture technologies for the lost heat which simply don't make sense on a car, or let alone a plane, due to weight concerns.
 
To an extent, the only thing is that a piston engine will produce power and the prop takes the power and turns it to thrust. A jet engine just produces thrust. Hence the difference in drag (power) curves for each aircraft type. This is also the reason we rate jet engines in pounds of thrust and piston aircraft in Horsepower.

We could implement a energy driven engine to help sustain level flight and then when needing the extra power to climb or accelerate the piston engine would kick in more power. This would be very similar as with hybrid cars.

The problem with the jet engine is that the electric motor wouldn't help other than with starting the engine. Two totally different engine types.

Patrick gives other good points as to why it wouldn't work with aircraft in general.

Patrick, I would think the static in flight could help charge the battery, but then again it most likely wouldn't be enough to make it anywhere near worth while.

Also don't forget that these fuel cells/batteries, whatever they are are very heavy and would reduce the useful load tremendously. Especially in our little piston aircraft.

Maurus, at least in theory you could create a hybrid or an all electric engine for an aircraft that would operate like a turbofan or a turboprop (although not like a pure turbojet). Both turboprops and turbojets (and pistons, for that matter) produce most of their thrust by accelerating a large air mass a very small amount. They do this by spinning a propeller or by spinning a fan. There's no reason that a sufficiently powerful electric motor couldn't spin either a propeller (and replace the engines on the small commuter's and GA aircraft) or a ducted fan (and replace the engines on a large commercial airliner).

There are, however, some DIFFICULTIES. Among the biggest are the weights and sizes of the electric motors that would be required to produce that much power, and an even bigger problem than that is the weights of the batteries that would be required to power such large engines. I don't know that either of these problems is insurmountable, however, but the answers are certainly difficult, and probably some ways off. Electric engines are at least theoretically possible on large aircraft, though.

Biodiesel or biodiesel blends are probably do-able in the very near future, however. Also, the Air Force has tested synthetic fuel recently, and that is another quick answer...quick being a relative term, of course.
 
Sure, you could use some static discharge to charge the battery, but to what extent? Lets just say we're talking a 160HP piston Warrior. In level flight, at 55% power, thats 88 HP needed to maintain. An 88 HP hybrid motor, drive system, likely a planetary gearbox to feed the prop, and now, for the big problem- BATTERIES. You're looking at several hundred pounds of equipment, even with the uber exotic lithium batteries.

The real "problem" with off of the discussions related to alternative fuels is the simple fact that oil is just too damn convenient. You pump it out of the ground, refine it, and burn it. Its liquid, and easy to contain. It has a relatively high specific energy. Internal combustion is also a very proven science at this point, hence its low cost. Really, the problem with internal combustion is its lack of efficiency due to tremendous wasted heat, at least on a car. Jets are quite a bit better, as that heat is what creates thrust and so there is much less wasted. The giant diesels in locomotives and ships are very efficient when you factor in the total use of the energy, as sure, they still have the heat losses in terms of fuel used vs energy created for propulsion, however, they use almost all of that excess heat aboard the vessel for heating and other uses. Being large, heavy vehicles, they can also benefit from recapture technologies for the lost heat which simply don't make sense on a car, or let alone a plane, due to weight concerns.


You're right, Patrick. There are some real difficulties (particularly in battery weight). Now, you could line the skin of the aircraft in solar panels, and if you were talking about propellers, you could use a variable pitch prop as an energy recovery device (on the descent) and that would help. Electric motors typically run in the 85-95% efficiency range anyway, so there's probably not much more advancement in terms of motor design that would help, except to make them weigh a little less. The real secret to the electric airplane (or electric-hybrid airplane) is the storage or production of electrical power (IMHO).
 
An electric 727, flies nicely:

[yt]Y7JjWEJH2vw[/yt]

The problem is, you have no payload :). Our future depends on a cheap, energy dense fuel.
 
Back
Top