Boeing/Airbus hybrid engines!?

abrutus

Well-Known Member
Well.. with all this non-sense high fuel prices rising, and the end of this not anywhere close (aparently), Airlines going out of bussines, and those who are not barely braking even, I just wonder how posible would it be for GE or some big engine manufacturer to come up with a fuel efficient plane (engine).
I know they have been working on that for years, and they are coming up with more and more fuel efficient planes (787,etc). But still, their main source of enery its Fuel! therefore their small profit margin will be ruled by fuel prices.
I wonder if it would be possible for them to come up with big engines (not talking about small GA ones, or for UL´s, thats ¨¨easy¨¨, Im talking about engines for Airliners, wich would work based on a Fuel/Energy Basis (hybrid), or perhaps just electrical power. Is it possible? Would the switch to hybrid engine compromise the engine´s performance drastically?.
Note that there are hybrid cars on the market with really good aceptable performance. So thats why I think. If you can come up with Fuel saving cars and busses, why not airplanes?.
I know if that could happen, the convertion to ¨¨hybrid¨¨ per say, would not be afordable probably to some airlines, But just thinking in the long run, how posible, affordable, and Cost saving would be?
 
You could only do it with piston aircraft. Jets work much different from car engines and also propel themselves differently. A hybrid Jet engine just wouldn't work. Take a look at how a jet engine works and you will see why.

Currently the best way to help a jet aircraft be more fuel efficient is to use better designs to reduce drag.
 
Well, the engines on the 787 have massive IDG/electric starter things (no bleed starts) ... just like a hybrid ground vehicle,

It seems like it would be possible to supplement at least the normal accessory load on the engines with something like fuel cells or solar power. For a 777, the nominal accessory load is around 160hp per engine (120 kW), and 85hp per engine for a 737NG (63 kW). I would imagine the loads are even higher for the 787 since the pressurization is done electrically (maybe 3x?).

A quick look at the Wikipedia tells me a rule of thumb for fuel cells is $1000 per kilowatt. That means a 777-sized installation cost would be ~$250,000 (really, multiply that by 4 because its an airplane). Not terrible, but that doesn't consider the added cost of schlepping around and maintaining another complex system on the aircraft.

For the time being, aircraft are particularly dependent on the unique energy density and portability that fossil fuel provides.
 
What about the alternative or bio-diesel some are working on? If we can get airlines off fossil fuels it would make them more economical. I am not sure if older engines could run on the new fuel or if they would need to be retrofitted but if it gets airlines off oil it will eliminate one of their largest expenses.
 
You can not eliminate energy costs at any level.

A 747 in cruise is going through about 60K hp. 60,000. How much of a dent do you think 85 hp will save? (Besides the weight penalty).

Sooner or later, the world will run out of attainable oil, that is a given. Iran's leader says it is way to cheap now. At some point folks, aviation in the commercial sector will not be serviceable. May be 10 years from now, might be 30, or 100. But the day is coming.

But when you have to come up with 60,000 hp and get it in the air, you are going to burn fuel, lots of it. There may be some efficiency's to be had in airframe design, and weight control, but design in aircraft is reaching the apex in what is to be gained. Bio fuel may be answer, but it will be expensive. Takes a lot of land to grow (something) to get enough fuel to fill a jet. Let alone a fleet of jets.

High speed railroads powered by Nuclear, Wind, Solar.
 
What about the alternative or bio-diesel some are working on? If we can get airlines off fossil fuels it would make them more economical. I am not sure if older engines could run on the new fuel or if they would need to be retrofitted but if it gets airlines off oil it will eliminate one of their largest expenses.

Using bio-fuels wont work in the overall economy. As fuel prices go down, food prices will rise as we cause our own food shortage. Using food for fuel is not worth it. If there was a different alternative fuel that could provide the same characteristics as Jet-a then use it. As long as it doesn't hurt something else like bio-fuels.


Yes we could use and electric motor to start the jet engines, but we can't use the electric to actually run the engine in flight. It just wont work with a jet engine.
 
Using bio-fuels wont work in the overall economy. As fuel prices go down, food prices will rise as we cause our own food shortage. Using food for fuel is not worth it. If there was a different alternative fuel that could provide the same characteristics as Jet-a then use it. As long as it doesn't hurt something else like bio-fuels.

Current bio-fuels are created from food sources but they are close to getting it from grass and other non essential products. Once that happens I think we can find a sustainable happy medium.

I know it is incapable of supporting the entire enconomy. But many users of fossil fuels have other alternatives. Cars can run on electric, hydrogen and use hybrids to drastically decrease their usage. Electric production can be done by wind, solar, methane, nuclear, hydroelectric and thermal.

We can't depend on one product to save us, we need to use all available avenues to decrease our dependence.
 
Current bio-fuels are created from food sources but they are close to getting it from grass and other non essential products. Once that happens I think we can find a sustainable happy medium.

I know it is incapable of supporting the entire enconomy. But many users of fossil fuels have other alternatives. Cars can run on electric, hydrogen and use hybrids to drastically decrease their usage. Electric production can be done by wind, solar, methane, nuclear, hydroelectric and thermal.

We can't depend on one product to save us, we need to use all available avenues to decrease our dependence.

This is true, but I don't see bio-fuels ever not hurting our food supply. Farmers will grow what gives them money. Even if it is not food related they would most likely replace their crop (that is for food) with the non-food items. The problem isn't that we use plants for a bio-fuel, but farmers will grow what gives them the most money. Right now it is corn cause of the rise in bio-fuel production. If we get something that is not food that we can make into a bio-fuel great, but where will we grow it exactly? On the farms.

I have no problems with finding alternative fuels as we need to become much more self sufficient, I just think bio-fuels are heading in the wrong direction.

Also funding for other projects aren't helping us find a better fuel. Cut funding to global warming projects and put it into finding a new fuel. Instead of studying a possible problem, why not prevent/fix it instead? Find something relatively inexpensive and people will embrace it with no problems.

Now if we use bio-fuels for only jet fuel, then maybe we could get away with bio-fuel not hurting the food economy so much. So far I have yet to see any other alternative to jet fuel.
 
This is true, but I don't see bio-fuels ever not hurting our food supply. Farmers will grow what gives them money. Even if it is not food related they would most likely replace their crop (that is for food) with the non-food items. The problem isn't that we use plants for a bio-fuel, but farmers will grow what gives them the most money. Right now it is corn cause of the rise in bio-fuel production. If we get something that is not food that we can make into a bio-fuel great, but where will we grow it exactly? On the farms.

I have no problems with finding alternative fuels as we need to become much more self sufficient, I just think bio-fuels are heading in the wrong direction.

Also funding for other projects aren't helping us find a better fuel. Cut funding to global warming projects and put it into finding a new fuel. Instead of studying a possible problem, why not prevent/fix it instead? Find something relatively inexpensive and people will embrace it with no problems.

Now if we use bio-fuels for only jet fuel, then maybe we could get away with bio-fuel not hurting the food economy so much. So far I have yet to see any other alternative to jet fuel.

Bio Fuels can be made from Algae but that is still something that is being worked on, and if achieved it would not hurt food supply. The main reason bio fuels probably won't work is because they gel at about 15-20 degrees F, and it gets much colder than that at FL350. If there was a way to keep it at a certain temp then I think we'd have a real solution. Jet engines could be powered by compressed natural gas, like in some cars but the main problem is infrastructure and engine conversion. We can make JET A out of liquefying coal and natural gas.
 
This is true, but I don't see bio-fuels ever not hurting our food supply. Farmers will grow what gives them money. Even if it is not food related they would most likely replace their crop (that is for food) with the non-food items. The problem isn't that we use plants for a bio-fuel, but farmers will grow what gives them the most money. Right now it is corn cause of the rise in bio-fuel production. If we get something that is not food that we can make into a bio-fuel great, but where will we grow it exactly? On the farms.

I have no problems with finding alternative fuels as we need to become much more self sufficient, I just think bio-fuels are heading in the wrong direction.

Also funding for other projects aren't helping us find a better fuel. Cut funding to global warming projects and put it into finding a new fuel. Instead of studying a possible problem, why not prevent/fix it instead? Find something relatively inexpensive and people will embrace it with no problems.

Now if we use bio-fuels for only jet fuel, then maybe we could get away with bio-fuel not hurting the food economy so much. So far I have yet to see any other alternative to jet fuel.

Ah yes, good old opportunity costs.

One option is dual use fields. The middle of the country is perfect for wind farms. It is also perfect for growing large fields of switch grass. It is the best of both worlds and could potentially keep the opportunity costs low enough to keep farmers growing other food related crops.

Who knows though. It seems many people are willing to give up and just accept the status quo anymore. When ever I have this conversation and mention hydrogen or switch grass I am met with the same resistance. Hydrogen is too costly to produce and is to far off. Switch grass is not viable yet. Both are true but neither is insurmountable by any means. We as a nation have overcome much more daunting challenges. I mean what if the Wright brothers just gave up on flight, I am sure that a majority of people were saying they were crazy.
 
Yup, opportunity costs is what is going to cause a food shortage if we continue to move that way using food supplies and fields for bio-fuel. I have no problem with other means of fuels, the biggest problem is funding for the new technology to use them.

Move all this global warming research money from them and put it into something useful for alternative fuels. Just putting more and more research into global warming wont fix anything. Putting the money to good use with alternative fuels will. Find a cheap clean fuel and everyone will be happy.
 
The world is just getting closer to its population saturation point. Think about it. The world can only support so many living things. Eventually the human population will be such that it cannot be supported by the Earth.
 
I don't think we will have shortage of food like everyone says we will.

For the last 10 years on our ranch we have just burned the field because it was more money from the subsidy of destroying the crop then sending it to be food. I say for the short term we should go with bio-fuels and then develop hydrogen powerplants
 
Yeah I'll believe that once the government stops paying for the destruction of the crops to artificially raise the price of the goods. :rolleyes: You should see the stock pile of grain, dent corn, and certain fruits that are just waiting for prices to go higher before the farmers sell it.

What I would really like to see though is a company that collects all used food oil. There is so much wasted energy in that region that could be easily used to power many vehicles.
 
We are already getting reports of food shortages caused by increases in biofuels.

Here is a report by The New York Times of all places.

I did not read the article but is not hard to see why it is happening.

In a way though it is a good thing. We, America, have been propping up impoverished nations with free grain and water which actually keeps them from being self sustaining.

Many of these places are in very arid areas of the word where life is hard to sustain. Water is scarce and land for growing food is just as hard to come by. By keeping these people teetering on the brink all we are ensuring is their continued dependence on our helping hand.

In other areas we provide the end product but not the means to produce that product. "Give a man a fish and he can eat for a day, teach a man to fish and he can eat for a lifetime". We give the fish. This also undermines any local farmers ability to sell their goods because of the influx of cheap/free goods to market.

Maybe if we stop giving they will be able to begin to develop an agricultural economy. If not, then maybe they will do what people have done through out the history of mankind, migrate.
 
If not, then maybe they will do what people have done through out the history of mankind, migrate.

And who's going to let them in?

You see what we do with people who come here ready to work at jobs Americans don't want to do.

What are we going to do with people who come here with no means to support themselves and who will need a lot of social services in order to exist?

I hate to say it, but we need to sandblast the phrase on the Statue of Liberty. We no longer want the huddled masses longing to be free.
 
Back
Top