How many times have you guys seen gate agents go on board to verify if a pax boarded?
Someone going to MFR and I guess paying no attention what-so-ever to any of her surroundings(despite being Star Alliance Gold) slipped by me once and got on a plane going to YYC, the scanner was down and I was just madly typing in the seat numbers to board the full flight. It was a full CRJ-700, you'd figure if someone had the wrong pass, there would be a headcount or seat issue. About an hour later, someone in that same seat shows up and says they've missed their flight to YYC. "Wait....". It happens.
Also, though it seems to be changing with the Real ID rule, you don't NEED ID to get through TSA. They tell you that, and some smurf's don't know the deal, but it's not true. The procedure is without it, you're quad S. And you may get extra screening at the gate. But you'll get through with a valid boarding pass. People lose their IDs abroad all the time.