Best Forward Speed

MikeD

Administrator
Staff member
Is there anyone who doesn't know what this request from ATC means?

Yesterday, am hightailing it back to the airfield hospital with a gunshot victim onboard, and need to come across the northern extended short final of the runway in use at about 400 AGL to get to the pad. Am still about 6 miles NNE of the field On final for the runway is a foreign 757 (can't remember the callsign, I was a tad busy) with some middle-eastern sounding crew onboard. ATC between them, myself, and the British ATC tower go like this:

ATC (to me): "....XXX, traffic 2 o'clock, 3 miles, seven-five-seven, now 8 miles final."

Me: "XXX, visual separation the 757"

ATC: "XXX, very well, pass behind the that traffic, cleared to cross northern extended centerline, call 30 seconds prior, cleared to land medevac pad"

Me: "......cleared to land at the pad, will advise 30 secs, XXX"

ATC (to 757): "XXX, your traffic 2-ship priority medevac rotary wing, 10 o'clock, 3 miles low level, will be crossing behind you, cleared to land, winds 260 at 16 knots"

757: "(unintelligible haji talk)....roger, cleared to land"

ATC (to 757): "and XXX, best forward speed please, for the priority traffic to cross behind"

757: "uhhh.....does that mean fast or slow"

ATC: "as fast as safe please"

"it means FAST, you effing moron!", Im mouthing into the ICS. I've never heard anyone not know what "best forward speed" meant.

I had to slow up some so as not to cross too close behind and/or under the 757, and contemplated requesting ATC to send his ass around for a pattern circuit if it was any closer.
 
In his defense, the 757 is rather hard to slow down. Of course, that doesn't mean to throw the gear and flaps at 10 mile final, either. :)
 
I hate 757's the FedEx one always gets vectored in front of me because I'm a small little metro, while they're a 75. What they fail to realize is I'm much faster then them within 30 miles of the airport. If you can't do 250 to the marker, get the hell out of my way. :)
 
MikeD,

In the future, if you ever find yourself thinking "I should..." when piloting a medevac - do it. Please.

Based on your account of the proximity of the 75, when instructed to "pass behind" - an "unable" would've (should've) gotten him punched out. That aircraft blows a lot of wake, and as you stated - you've got enough on your plate.

Be safe out there,
TS
 
I hate 757's the FedEx one always gets vectored in front of me because I'm a small little metro, while they're a 75. What they fail to realize is I'm much faster then them within 30 miles of the airport. If you can't do 250 to the marker, get the hell out of my way. :)

That was one thing that was nice about the ATC facility at my UPT base. They knew we could take the T-6 at almost 250 to just outside the FAF and throw out the boards. Plus, it made for a steep learning curve for a new instrument student, which my instructors absolutely loved. Idle, boards, "below 150 gear clear, check handle down, three green, flaps takeoff", power up, glideslope centering, time, turn, throttle, twist, track, talk, "Laughlin tower, Panther XX, 6 mi final ILS 13C, full stop".....or so you hoped.
 
But everyone here knows the meaning of "best forward speed" when requested by ATC? It's the first time in 28 years of flying that I've heard its meaning questioned over the radio, much less by an airline crew.
 
But everyone here knows the meaning of "best forward speed" when requested by ATC? It's the first time in 28 years of flying that I've heard its meaning questioned over the radio, much less by an airline crew.

I've heard Chinese pilots not understand "expedite descent"; had to finally tell them "descend faster". Granted expedite may be a more complicated term. Although I agree, the ability to read, speak, write, and understand English should be emphasized.
 
I've heard Chinese pilots not understand "expedite descent"; had to finally tell them "descend faster". Granted expedite may be a more complicated term. Although I agree, the ability to read, speak, write, and understand English should be emphasized.

It was even the Queen's english, being a Brit tower. Not the yank slang...."D

And too, if they just acknowledged "priority" traffic that needs to cross behind them, then why would it even be a question of fast or slow?

Granted, Im just some blond haired, light skinned Joe; but I don't understand how difficult some of this simple stuff is for some...
 
I hate 757's the FedEx one always gets vectored in front of me because I'm a small little metro, while they're a 75. What they fail to realize is I'm much faster then them within 30 miles of the airport. If you can't do 250 to the marker, get the hell out of my way. :)

Happened a lot in the 402. Ask boondr. :)
 
A) If the 757 is hard to slow, ask AAL how they manage to do a slower final than SWA in them. I've seen 206's overtake those things.

B) Cape Air 402s are the fastest airplanes on short final after fighter jets. Only weak controllers make KAP last.

C) Be glad is wasn't a South Korean in an F-15. "MAC1 (any instructions)" "Rojah! MAC! land now!"

I'm in the habit of asking pilots in that situation if I don't know, how fast they can fly till 5 out or over the fence. You'd be amazed how quickly a Baron pilot can safely do 85 knots 5 out vs 140 till the numbers. There is some magical 5 second course out there I guess. I refuse to delay a lifeguard and if need be the 757 is getting a tour. If you actually speak up and say its critical, like someone said, don't think it, say it man!
 
A) If the 757 is hard to slow, ask AAL how they manage to do a slower final than SWA in them. I've seen 206's overtake those things.

B) Cape Air 402s are the fastest airplanes on short final after fighter jets. Only weak controllers make KAP last.

C) Be glad is wasn't a South Korean in an F-15. "MAC1 (any instructions)" "Rojah! MAC! land now!"

Have worked with the ROKAF enough to know their game....but it was mostly F-5s and F-4s and F-16s then.

Am just surprised they didn't know the terminology.
 
A) If the 757 is hard to slow, ask AAL how they manage to do a slower final than SWA in them. I've seen 206's overtake those things.

Truth! Lowest Vref I've seen was at 142,000 lbs; 109 KIAS. :)

That said, getting it down to that speed from 250 in the terminal area takes a while! Much harder to slow than even a 767 (which 150,000 lbs heavier). Gotta get it slowed early.
 
Truth! Lowest Vref I've seen was at 142,000 lbs; 109 KIAS. :)

That said, getting it down to that speed from 250 in the terminal area takes a while! Much harder to slow than even a 767 (which 150,000 lbs heavier). Gotta get it slowed early.

The jet was on an 8 mile final and configured. I can't imagine it'd be too difficult to slow from there.

Still, the idea was keeping the speed up at best speed, and the crew not even knowing what it meant.

By the lack of anyone saying otherwise, I take it everyone knows what the term "best speed" means?
 
I would certainly think everyone *here* understands"best forward". It would be interesting to know if that is standard phraseology with the international community, something I am personally unfamiliar with. Maybe Doug?
 
I believe it's "Maintain maximum forward speed," but not 100% on that (sorry, not Doug!).
 
It's not just in aviation. Approaching LA harbor with a tow I was nearly mowed down by a freighter who apparently didn't know port from stbd. To avoid him I was danger close to running aground. Or in the "canal" tween Santa Barbara mainland and Channel Islands I was caught tween two steamers playing chicken. Or 75 nm off of San Francisco an LPG steamer with Chinese crew pulled within hailing distance at night to ask for directions to SF Bay. And I watched a foreign crew run over the cable of a tow and tug. I was 2 miles distant and the weather was CAVU with no lee shore.

Sometimes it is better to just turn off the comm radio.
 
I am aware of a Chinese tranlation dictionary. It only has aviation terms and is printed in Chinese/English. Even still, it barely helps and often makes communications worse.

I hope and pray the guy made it.
 
Dasleben is right. A light 757 could be doing 115 to 120K on final. Now, where I work, we are REQUIRED to be on speed at 1000AGL and encouraged to be on speed at 1500 AGL. On speed could easily be 120K. That's what our FAA approved book says. If ATC wants us to go fast we can do our best but are constrained by what our company tells us we must do and what is safe. Sorry for all the fast movers stuck behind us. I know I've pissed off a few controllers and SWA crews by flying the jet the way the company wants me to. It seems silly. At one time we didn't have to be stable until 500AGL and we weren't discouraged from using speedbrakes at flaps 20. But every time there is one incident that could have been prevented by being more conservative the company puts out a bulletin forcing pilots to fly the jet in a more conservative manner without consideration for pilots being able to decide whats safe and whats not safe. Just feel like the pilots decision making process is slowly being taken away and inhibited by some guy writing a bulletin to satisfy the lowest common denominator brought about by one crew having a bad day. Sorry for the rant.

Oh, and the 757 has wake turbulence similar to a heavy. A couple times light jets (KBIL and KSNA) have had fatal wake encounters from getting too close behind a 757. Be super careful crossing behind one Mike.
 
I was talking to a friend the other day about this. She's a controller at Anchorage TRACON.

She said "best forward speed" means exactly that--the fastest YOU think you can go. It's not a specific speed, and if a controller expects it to be, they're wrong.

The other night I ended up ticking off one of the STL approach controllers. He told me to maintain best forward speed. It was a bit turbulent and I didn't see an obvious reason to go faster, so I maintained normal cruise speed, about 150 knots. I wasn't going to give the pax a loud, rough ride for nothing. A few minutes later he came back in an irritated voice with, "Is that the fastest you can go???"

I said, "No, we can go faster, what speed do you need?" He said, "170 knots." I said, "Roger, will maintain 170 knots," and pushed the power up.

I'm not a mind reader, if a controller really wants something, they need to say it!
 
I hate 757's the FedEx one always gets vectored in front of me because I'm a small little metro, while they're a 75. What they fail to realize is I'm much faster then them within 30 miles of the airport. If you can't do 250 to the marker, get the hell out of my way. :)

I hate getting stuck behind them too! What speed are you doing inside the marker?
 
Back
Top