In 2002 I was hired at Comair after having been furloughed by US Airways in March of that year.
Up until this point I had always been the baby of the class at most of the airlines I had worked for. Not anymore. My class was filled with kids, some with extraordinarily low time. They were all friendly and we got along fine. I have to admit that it bothered me -- not that they were low time, but that all of the experience I had gained up until that point was apparently wasted. I was no more valuable than the person sitting next to me who had never flown anything larger than a Seminole.
Once I was online it didn't bother me so much. You sort of fall into a groove. I had been a copilot long enough to know what my role was and you just seem to forget that the person sitting to your left is young and may have much less time than you do. Truthfully at the airlines people don't go around asking, "how many hours do you have?". I never volunteered my background so those conversations rarely happened.
Besides, this was post 9/11, so I wasn't an anomaly. In addition to myself there were 2 other USAirways furloughees, a couple of ex-Emery pilots, and more in my class alone.
I did have ONE out of the ordinary experience there that i'll share. After having been on the line a month or two as a "new" CRJ FO I showed up at the airplane one morning to find the Captain standing at the gate kibitzing with some of the other crewmembers. I didn't want to interrupt so I just nodded at him and walked outside to preflight the airplane. When I sat down in my seat the Captain came up and introduced himself, looked at his trip sheet and said, "New guy huh?"
"Yep", I responded, "Been here a month or two."
Captain said, "Well -- don't worry you'll have stories to tell soon enough too."
Seriously? Did this guy just set the land-speed record for zero to ass-hat?
So we finish setting up the cockpit and Captain ass-hat looks at me and says, "Listen, since you're a new guy i'll fly the first couple of legs. We'll see how it's going and if things are going well then you can fly, ok?"
Well shoot -- I get paid the same whether I fly the airplane or not so I just agreed.
He flew three legs the first day and then, obviously satisfied with my performance in the right seat, he said, "Well you think you're ready to fly a leg?"
I looked out the window for a second (my pride was bruised and was trying to think of how to respond) and then turned to him and said, "No... I think you better show me one more leg."
So he flew the last leg of the day. The next morning in the van (in front of the FA) he says, "Well newbie, you want to fly the first leg this morning?"
By now my ego was really beginning to shatter. I pondered my reply:
"You know Cap'n ... I forgot most of what I learned yesterday. Would you mind flying a couple legs today so I can watch?"
And he did. He flew all 3 legs on day 2.
On the morning of day 3 he flew the first leg. We hadn't talked much in cruise up until that point. Honestly we just didn't have much in common. I was feeling very old and un-cool. I didn't have, after all, any spiky hair, or cool sunglasses, or surfer bag stickers.
But finally he looks at me in cruise and said, "So how long did you instruct before you came here?"
"I wasn't a flight instructor before I came here."
The Captain looked incredulous. "So what did you do to build time?"
"I was a 737 FO for US Airways"
He stared at me for a minute or two. "So why am I flying all of the legs???!!"
I shrugged and said, "I don't know, it seemed like you had something you wanted to teach me."
If you thought it was quiet BEFORE that point. We didn't say much of anything other than checklists for the rest of the trip. I felt like a jerk for screwing with him.
He didn't deserve me being a jerk. My pride was sore about being back at the commuters with low-time Captains in the left seat. I shouldn't have taken it out on him. It is hard though to go back to being a newhire copilot at the regionals after you've had that brass ring for a few years. It's not that the JOB is hard. It's not the low pay or the small airplane. It's the recognition that everything you've worked for has been wasted. That all of that time and effort you spent getting to a major was worthless. It's the understanding that pilots are interchangeable cogs and that (at least in the 121 world) an 8,000 hour former major-airline pilot was worth no more than a 300 hour former flight instructor. It made me feel old, and made me feel like a failure.
That wasn't the fault of the guys I was flying with. It was timing. It wasn't Comair's fault -- they gave me a shot when I needed a job. It was just something I had to deal with. After a while those feelings started to go away. I even turned down a recall to a Captain's seat at the ill-fated MidAtlantic Airways (US Airways light) because I would have rather stayed at the commuters than go back into the USAir quagmire.
Had I still been at Comair when USAir mainline finally called I'm sure I would have gone back. Fortunately I had moved into the corporate world by then.
121 is an interesting beast. It took several furloughs for me to realize how little I was really worth. Imagine all of the Eastern or Pan-Am pilots with years and years of flying heavy aircraft under their belt trying to find a job as a brand-new copilot on a Bac 1-11 twenty five years ago. Think of the Midway pilots, the ATA pilots, the Emery pilots and the TWA pilots just a few years ago with gobs of transport category jet time all standing around at AirInc job-fairs looking for jobs flying commuters -- many of them had been Captains for twenty years.
Think of this: If some of the heroes of this very website were to be victims of fate, and their airlines sink into the abyss -- then they to would start over as first officers, very likely at carriers with far worse pay and/or working conditions than those who they work for today. Doug... Polar... MTSU aviator. Doesn't matter who you are.
Hopefully that gives you some understanding as to how a relatively experienced person feels sitting to the right of someone less experienced. I'm just one data point, everyone deals with things in their own way. For what it's worth I was an FO for 3 years at the flight department where I work now. It didn't bother me nearly as much here because the other pilots here didn't treat you like an FO. When it was my leg I sat in the left seat and with few exceptions ran the show. The only thing I didn't do was sign the logbook. Nowadays we operate Co-Captain. <shrug> It's a different world than 121 and one that seems to respect experience a little bit more. It's not unheard of for corporate pilots whose departments shut down to walk into the left seat of a similar airplane at another department.
This has been my experience... i'm sure i'm not the only one though. What was yours?</shrug>