ATP XC req. clarification

Johnny Beau Bekkestad

Well-Known Member
Going over my logbook to try to figure out my XC hour for my ATP.
Since you do not need to land in order to meet ATP req. i am now trying to calculate those hours separately.

I have a few questions on how you guys have done this.
1. Should i have 2 separate columns in log book (XC and ATP XC) or should i just write 14 CFR 61.1(b)(3)(vi) in the remarks.
2. Since i do not need to land i presume that i am allowed to log XC for route of flight A -> A, how do you explain the 50nm then? By writing waypoints in the remarks?
3. Can i fly from A to a waypoint (not a airport) > 50nm and then turn back and log as XC?

Anything else i need to think about?
 
For what it's worth, I've been using flightlogg.in as a backup to my paper logbook, and it actually calculates ATP XC for you. It's free.

EDIT : fixed the URL
 
Last edited:
I just have always written "A->B->A in the from and to blocks, squeezing the B, (or b and c) in between, insuring that at least one identifier is beyond 50nm.
 
in case anyone clicks on the link and thinks the site is down, you have to drop the www from the flightlogg.in url in order to access the page. http://flightlogg.in

Thanks for posting that @killbilly this is just what I am looking for.

I just noticed that it's tracking both "61 XC" and "ATP XC" in separate columns.

I tried loading a test flight and not logging it as XC (thinking it would track in the ATP section and not in the 61 section) but it's doing both still.

I need to figure out why - I suspect this is more user error than anything else.
 
I just noticed that it's tracking both "61 XC" and "ATP XC" in separate columns.

I tried loading a test flight and not logging it as XC (thinking it would track in the ATP section and not in the 61 section) but it's doing both still.

I need to figure out why - I suspect this is more user error than anything else.

How is it tracking ATP XC when departure and destination are the same.
 
How is it tracking ATP XC when departure and destination are the same.

Yeah, I'm trying to sort that out. Because it's not doing it that way. Although it should.

For example, if I put in there "JYO W29 JYO" it will track it as XC, even if I didn't land there. So I'm still trying to figure out how to invoke it.
 
Yeah, I'm trying to sort that out. Because it's not doing it that way. Although it should.

For example, if I put in there "JYO W29 JYO" it will track it as XC, even if I didn't land there. So I'm still trying to figure out how to invoke it.
That's fine, cause now you've got waypoints and if you were asked by FAA about that hour you can look it up.
I have a ton of hours where i only have
FPR -> FPR but the flight was anywhere from 2-4 hours long
 
I just have always written "A->B->A in the from and to blocks, squeezing the B, (or b and c) in between, insuring that at least one identifier is beyond 50nm.
I've always reserved the route box for airports where I've actually landed and use the comments box for the non-landing waypoints. Of course if one has a substantial amount of these, the bigger issue is the totaling one and nothing beats a separate column for that (paper or plastic).
 
How is it tracking ATP XC when departure and destination are the same.
I haven't used flightlogg.in for a few years so I don't recall but perhaps there's just a checkbox to identify them.

Edit. Just took a look. I don't see any way for it to produce separate totals for ATP as opposed to non-ATP cross countries.
 
Last edited:
I haven't used flightlogg.in for a few years so I don't recall but perhaps there's just a checkbox to identify them.

Edit. Just took a look. I don't see any way for it to produce separate totals for ATP as opposed to non-ATP cross countries.

There is an alteration you can make it in the preferences section. I believe it makes the distinction based on the number of landings.

Not sure about that though. Probably worth an email to the developer to see what he says.
 
By looking at your records, how can you tell which ones they are?

thats is why i created this thread...
I have no way of doing this today. I could just say F' it and do it right from now on or try to go back to all my flights that have the same departure and destination and look at the total time together with cruise speed of aircraft and try to estimate wether or not each flight was an ATP XC or not.
F_or the future i an thinking of doing separate rows for each approach f.ex
NR DEPARTURE DESTINATION #TO #LA APP TIME
1. FPR PBI 1 0 ILS 1.2
2. PBI FPR 0 1 GPS 1.2

instead of
NR DEPARTURE DESTINATION #TO #LA APP TIME
1. FPR FPR 1 1 ILS, GPS 2.4

Unfortunately i have a bunch of the second one. But i know that i did many flights like the first one
 
thats is why i created this thread...
I have no way of doing this today.
That's your real issue. I knew a pilot once who was doing his commercial checkride and had neglected to identify his solo flights; DPE terminated the checkride before even the oral started and refused to accept the pilot's memory or reckoning of what flights were solo. While the basic FAA theory on meeting requirements is, "if it ain't logged it didn't happen" it does seem to me to be a bit overboard but it does illustrate the problem and some of the issues involved in going back, trying to reconstruct flights and entering information after the fact.

While I don't think "triggered my memory" would be enough - IMO a logbook needs to stand alone - I agree with @subpilot's observation that the rest of the entries might show that it was more than 50 NM away from departure. For example, I have a flight in my logbook in which the Route box says "APA LOCAL" ("local" only meaning no landings at another airport). The comments read "Charlotte and Amanda - Royal Gorge Bridge." I'd have no problem years later identifying it as a qualifying cross country for ATP requirement purposes.

instead of
NR DEPARTURE DESTINATION #TO #LA APP TIME
1. FPR FPR 1 1 ILS, GPS 2.4

FAR 61.51(g)(3) requires logging "The location and type of each instrument approach accomplished" (my emphasis) if you are counting them toward currency.So your one-line item for FPR-FPR should be (additions underlined, the ## being the number in the approach name; maybe or maybe not technically required but what not add the full name of the approach?)
FPR FPR 1 1 PBI ILS ##, FPR GPS ## 2.4
which very clearly tells us you went from FPR to PBI.

In terms of methodology, you've seen a couple of options. The key is that that it's easy to use and makes it easy to identify and retrieve for other purposes.
 
Well as for currency i am ok right now, just did my BFR and IPC. The only thing i am missing is the ATP XC. I meet the RATP requirements of more than 200 at the moment, but i am aiming for a full ATP.
Going to make sure that i log it better in the future.
 
I wasn't worrying about your instrument currency - just pointing out that if your >50 NM without landing cross countries were mostly while doing instrument approaches, correct logging of the approach also provides confirmation of the ATP cross country.
 
I wasn't worrying about your instrument currency - just pointing out that if your >50 NM without landing cross countries were mostly while doing instrument approaches, correct logging of the approach also provides confirmation of the ATP cross country.

Thanks for that info.
Need to be better at logging approaches to. The jepessen book is not really good at specifying how to do it correctly
 
Back
Top