Well, let's do some math, numbers taken from airlinepilotcentral.com. By these figures there are nearly 60,000 major/legacy/LCC airline pilots in the USA. I lumped small jet providers in with regionals despite several having the offical status of “majors”. I also put any significant cargo feeders in with the regionals, and threw UPS, FedEx, ABX, Atlas etc in with the Majors. For the regionals I come up with about 22,000 pilots. There’s almost a 3:1 ratio of majors to regionals.
Majors
ABX: 750
AirTran: 1200
Alaska: 1490
ATA: 800
Aloha: 350
American: 9265
Atlas: 630
CAT: 110
Continental: 4600
Delta: 6470
Evergreen: 220
FedEx: 4650
Frontier: 550
Hawaiian: 283
JetBlue: 1400
Kitty Hawk: 140
Midwest: 375
Northwest: 5400
Polar: 363
Spirit: 420
Southwest: 4900
Sun Country: 130
United: 6400
USAirways: 5100
USA 3000: 168
UPS: 2730
Total: 58,894
Regionals:
Air Wisconsin: 820
Airnet: 230
Ameriflight: 200
ASA: 1700
Chautauqua/Republic: 1350
Colgan: 350
Comair: 1900
Commutair: 150
Eagle: 3000
Expressjet: 2650
GoJet: 200?
Gulfstream: 500
Horizon: 715
Island Air: 100
Mesa: 1700
Mesaba: 950
Mountain Air: 300
Piedmont: 490
Pinnacle: 1200
PSA: 560
Skyway: 315
Skywest: 2150
TransStates: 700
Total: 22,230
Caveat: The cargo airlines probably skew the scale in favor of the majors. I think this is still a fair comparsion because cargo jobs flying heavy equipment are some of the most coveted jobs available today. I can see how someone like Doug, working for an airline with about 6500 mainline pilots and nearly 6000 pilots for regional affiliates would begin to think that regional pilots are outnumbering major airline pilots, but I don't think that's the case.