Angry Vet and USAirways

I'm sorry, but that's kind of BS. Ok, throw the guy off the plane because he's having a meltdown. But seriously, no service dogs? Why do we let women bring toy dogs on the airplane? You don't think those ladies would be scrambling to save that little abomination of nature in an emergency?

If the dog is in the window seat, not blocking anyone from egress, then I don't see a problem. We strap bags to the window seat to make weight and balance magic. I have to say I disagree with this policy.
 
The problem was he wouldnt put the dog on the floor between his legs.

Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 4
 
The problem was he wouldnt put the dog on the floor between his legs.

Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 4

Okay, that wasn't made clear from the article and I wasn't about to sit through a 10 minute video of angry confrontation.

The article said "remain on the ground". "Floor" would have been a more apt term. And uh, wouldn't the dog being on the floor between his legs constitute an obstruction to the emergency exit???
 
I'm sorry, but that's kind of BS. Ok, throw the guy off the plane because he's having a meltdown. But seriously, no service dogs? Why do we let women bring toy dogs on the airplane? You don't think those ladies would be scrambling to save that little abomination of nature in an emergency?

If the dog is in the window seat, not blocking anyone from egress, then I don't see a problem. We strap bags to the window seat to make weight and balance magic. I have to say I disagree with this policy.

Service dogs have to go under the seat.

Either you comply with the regulations which you agreed to when you registered your dog (usually, in all honesty, just a pet) or we've got a schedule to maintain.

An aircraft with 200 people, no matter what we think, has to be thought of as 200 passengers, not 200 individuals with varying levels of compliance.

We all can't be special. Because if we were, the world would be filled with Ballerinas and F-14 pilots and ain't nobody got time fo dat.
 
Service dogs have to go under the seat.

Either you comply with the regulations which you agreed to when you registered your dog (usually, in all honesty, just a pet) or we've got a schedule to maintain.

An aircraft with 200 people, no matter what we think, has to be thought of as 200 passengers, not 200 individuals with varying levels of compliance.

We all can't be special. Because if we were, the world would be filled with Ballerinas and F-14 pilots and ain't nobody got time fo dat.
...or fifty...but anyway.
 
Service dogs have to go under the seat.

Either you comply with the regulations which you agreed to when you registered your dog (usually, in all honesty, just a pet) or we've got a schedule to maintain.

An aircraft with 200 people, no matter what we think, has to be thought of as 200 passengers, not 200 individuals with varying levels of compliance.

We all can't be special. Because if we were, the world would be filled with Ballerinas and F-14 pilots and ain't nobody got time fo dat.

I understand the reg, I just don't agree with it as a logical safeguard in any way. We let morbidly obese people and frail elderly people on the edge of death occupy seats, but A SERVICE DOG MUST GO UNDER THE SEAT. Nope. Sorry, that just doesn't sound like consistent logic to me.

Also, I must say a take a bit of exception to the notion that service dogs are mostly just pets. But then, my sister has been wheelchair bound her entire life, so I have a slightly different bias. Now say what you will about vets, PTSD, and the effectivenenss of service animals in this scenario; but my initial reaction would not be one of skepticism.

But hell, if the guy has a meltdown, get him and his dog off the airplane.
 
Service dogs have to go under the seat.

Either you comply with the regulations which you agreed to when you registered your dog (usually, in all honesty, just a pet) or we've got a schedule to maintain.

An aircraft with 200 people, no matter what we think, has to be thought of as 200 passengers, not 200 individuals with varying levels of compliance.

We all can't be special. Because if we were, the world would be filled with Ballerinas and F-14 pilots and ain't nobody got time fo dat.

Exactly.

On the ATR we tried very hard to put pax with service animals in 11 C/D. That way the service animal could hang out behind & under that seat, where there was typically about 12" + of room behind the seat row. (Just the way that airplane's layout was.) Some of the older former Command ATRs had an even bigger gap there, was the perfect space for a service animal to hang out, have TONS of room, and not be in a pax seat. Fully complying with all requirements, and lots of room for the dog.
 
I definitely think that US Air isn't in the wrong for this one. They were just trying to stick to their policies, and their request wasn't unreasonable. If the passengers wanted to get all disgruntled then they had all the justification in the world to remove him off of the flight. The worst part about this whole thing is that I imagine the mainstream media will find this story in about a week, and blow it hugely out of proportion to make US Air seem like some massive, evil airline that hates disabled veterans and other people with service animals. Hopefully the media onslaught will not happen, but I would not be surprised at all.
 
I understand the reg, I just don't agree with it as a logical safeguard in any way. We let morbidly obese people and frail elderly people on the edge of death occupy seats, but A SERVICE DOG MUST GO UNDER THE SEAT. Nope. Sorry, that just doesn't sound like consistent logic to me.

Also, I must say a take a bit of exception to the notion that service dogs are mostly just pets. But then, my sister has been wheelchair bound her entire life, so I have a slightly different bias. Now say what you will about vets, PTSD, and the effectivenenss of service animals in this scenario; but my initial reaction would not be one of skepticism.

But hell, if the guy has a meltdown, get him and his dog off the airplane.

Here's the trick. The "service dog" thing is about the biggest scam on earth. Get a dog, don't want to spend the $$$ to get your dog onboard, spend about $10 on eBay and now it's a registered "service dog".

If flying is that stressful that you need an ancillary animal, there's always a bus, your own car or a train, but flyng isn't a guaranteed privilege.

The beef shouldn't be with the airline business. It should be whollly with the people who absolutely abuse the "service animal" waiver.

I've seen very few blind or obviously disabled people with a "service animal". However, I have seen lots of disaffected (wanna be) upper crust people who read a blog about saving money traveling with animals with them though.

I'm not trying to be an ass and I'm fully aware that I sound like one, but blaming the airline business about the situation as about as insipid as blaming a cop for enforcing a traffic law.
 
"Hey what with the service K9?"
"He detects seizures"

Thats the most popular one Ive seen. In fact, thats really the only type Ive seen. Like Derg said, Ive maybe seen one lady who was blind with a dog. Most blind folks usually have a human with them and not a dog.
 
Blind people normally don't even fly with animals as they largely want to be treated like everyone else. For the most part, you don't even know you have a blind passenger until you see them walk by on he way out of the jet (or prop for @Autothrust Blue)

Now, the "social anxiety", "food allergy", "Whaever" crowd travel with loads of animals and want full special privileges.

Sadly, it's largely a scam these days.
 
Blind people normally don't even fly with animals as they largely want to be treated like everyone else. For the most part, you don't even know you have a blind passenger until you see them walk by on he way out of the jet (or prop for @Autothrust Blue)

Now, the "social anxiety", "food allergy", "Whaever" crowd travel with loads of animals and want full special privileges.

Sadly, it's largely a scam these days.
"Please stay forward of the wing. Sir! Please stay forward of the wing! SIR! Stay FORWARD of the WING!"

I'm with US Airways on this one.
The recording on the website, like most other recordings, is insufficient, in that it only started after the yelling started.
 
Back
Top