SlumTodd_Millionaire
Most Hated Member
Now thats weird. I've heard both things.....that it is an ALPA generated list, and that it isn't an ALPA generated list.
So it isn't?
It is not.
I dont know the entire history of "the list". but I believe ALPA created/maintained the first list, and then there was a lawsuit or two over it, and the judge said no more list making. Some one from within ALPA took on list making as their own project 'independent' of alpa, and thus you have the list of today. You'd probaly want to ask Todd, to some one else that has a lot more intamate knowledge of that list, but that might be the one minute version of the history of it.
Scab lists used to be maintained by ALPA International way back in the day (think Century Airlines), or by the individual MECs in later years (think CAL or EAL). The Century scab list was actually published on the front page of Air Line Pilot Magazine. That didn't last long, though, and ALPA became so big that it was better to have each individual airline keep track of their scabs.
During the EAL strike, the EAL MEC published several official lists throughout the strike. At the end of the strike, the lists were all compiled into the final official list, which was titled "The SCABS of the Eastern Strike of 1989." This was the last time that any scab list was published by an ALPA entity. There aren't too many of these old lists still floating around, but occasionally you'll run into an old timer that still has his. I knew a retired EAL striker down in Florida that had his copy hanging from a noose in his hangar.
In the '90s, the various scab lists were all compiled by a regional pilot that worked at an ALPA carrier, but he was not acting on behalf of ALPA. It was his own personal project. Most of the "Master Scab Lists" that you'll find nowadays were generated from this project. He still maintains the list, although he no longer works for an ALPA carrier.
As far as lawsuits, there was a major lawsuit filed against ALPA by an EAL pilot regarding the list, but the judge dismissed the claim, saying that it was not libel or slander to call someone a scab if they did indeed fit the definition. So, ALPA has never lost a lawsuit related to a scab list, but they still don't publish them for whatever reason.