The stuff you're hearing about Eagle is correct.
I've had the opportunity to work for both Colgan and Eagle. Both have advantages, but overall I think Eagle still comes out ahead.
The thing that made Colgan bearable was the crews- you'll work with lots of awesome people there. That, and I haven't worked there in four years. The ALPA team and pilot group have done amazing things with the QOL there since I left.
Ultimately, crunch the numbers (financially speaking) and do whatever you think will work best for you. Don't count on upgrade at any given point. The way the industry is undulating these days it's anybody's guess as to how upgrade will go. Same with the industry in general.
Get a job flying an airplane in a set of circumstances that makes you happiest and gives you a shot at having a life beyond work. Most importantly, though- don't just rely on other peoples' opinions. Google the companies.. do the research.. and decide for yourself based on the facts you uncover.