American Eagle Vs Colgan

aviator04

Well-Known Member
I am in the fortunate position of being offered two class dates; any advice on which company to work for?
AE has the size and support with AA, but Colgan seems to be moving up the ladder with consolidation and support from Mesaba and Pinnacle?
 
I am in the fortunate position of being offered two class dates; any advice on which company to work for?
AE has the size and support with AA, but Colgan seems to be moving up the ladder with consolidation and support from Mesaba and Pinnacle?

There will be no more Colgan name in just a little while. Eagle's hard money is still higher than ours (for now) at Mesaba's, although our soft money is fairly strong. Plus raises will come every year on dec 1 which will jump us above Eagle. Six days into this month, for instance I'm already getting about 100 more dollars off soft pay for doing hardly anything (no open time pick up, no trip trading, no jr man, really just dealing with normal ops during T-storms). Mesaba has always enjoyed fairly high QOL, but so has Eagle. We had a number of Eagle guys come over here as street captains and the majority of them regretted coming here after returning to FO.

Eagle is a good company, probably as bright a future as ours, and the upgrade is comparable. I'd say Beagle as well. If you've got some basing preference I'd say choose more off that. Two three years from now, if things continue going well over here at Mesaba, we'll probably eclipse them in pay.
 
Any word on the relationship between AA and Beagle? Does it seem like they'll be together for awhile, or is AA looking to drop Beagle?




Argh, I just realized my post resembles high school dating drama. oh well
 
I believe they are destined to be high school sweethearts that get hitched... of course, we all know what happens when they hit forty!
AE is saying in their interviews that half (50%) of their pilots will be joining AA within the next two years?
My buddy CFI who has been in training with AE for 6 weeks now has seen his seniority number drop 200?
 
Yeah my seniority started just below 2900 now it's in the very low 2500's. Comining up on a year in another week. Eagles a great place to work from
What I've seen in the short time being here. For the last 4 months I've only been flying in the 60 hr range but always get paid for over 100hrs. Our contract concerning pay protection is pretty good. Upgrades have been going down to so that's always cool. I have a buddy at colgan who is upgrading and I think he's been there about 3 years. He seems to like it there. Good luck in your choice. And congrats on getting two offers, that's awesome.
 
The stuff you're hearing about Eagle is correct.

I've had the opportunity to work for both Colgan and Eagle. Both have advantages, but overall I think Eagle still comes out ahead.
The thing that made Colgan bearable was the crews- you'll work with lots of awesome people there. That, and I haven't worked there in four years. The ALPA team and pilot group have done amazing things with the QOL there since I left.

Ultimately, crunch the numbers (financially speaking) and do whatever you think will work best for you. Don't count on upgrade at any given point. The way the industry is undulating these days it's anybody's guess as to how upgrade will go. Same with the industry in general.

Get a job flying an airplane in a set of circumstances that makes you happiest and gives you a shot at having a life beyond work. Most importantly, though- don't just rely on other peoples' opinions. Google the companies.. do the research.. and decide for yourself based on the facts you uncover.
 
I would go to CJC without any hesitation over Eagle. The BEagle is a great company, don't get me wrong, but I'd go to CJC now.
 
Now that we have a decent contract, comparing the 2 and finding pros and cons that don't match, is pretty hard. Isn't the pilot group even the same size?

Eagle's pilot group is almost 3000 large. I assume you mean the combined Pinnacle/Colgan/Mesaba count? (Good for you guys on THAT one. Death to the whipsaw!)

One advantage the Pinnacle Holdings set definitely has over Eagle is that you guys just came *out* of contract talks (successfully, at that) and Eagle is just about to go IN to contract talks. Hilarity will ensue, I'm certain.

As an Eagle pilot, though, I'd be sorely pressed to turn anybody applying away- our turnover rate is accelerating, and our staffing is stretched horribly thin. We need every new body we can get. Self interest dictates that I scream often and loud that the water is just fine here. And we have rivers of beer. And stuff.
 
Back
Top