American Airlines hit with record fine

The baggage fees are here to stay and will only increase. The airlines are making money on them and people are still paying. It's a good business model for the airlines. It's bringing in a bunch of cash.

On the $50 charge for stand by, I like that as well. If you want to change your ticket and fly earlier, then pay the $50 and welcome aboard.

This charge separates those that really need to go from those that simply want to go. You will have a better chance of getting the standby flight because most people do not want to pay the $50 fee.

If you don't want to pay the $50, then hang out in the terminal, enjoy your time there, have an airport meal for $20 and save a net $30.

Joe
 
The baggage fees are here to stay and will only increase. The airlines are making money on them and people are still paying. It's a good business model for the airlines. It's bringing in a bunch of cash.

On the $50 charge for stand by, I like that as well. If you want to change your ticket and fly earlier, then pay the $50 and welcome aboard.

This charge separates those that really need to go from those that simply want to go. You will have a better chance of getting the standby flight because most people do not want to pay the $50 fee.

If you don't want to pay the $50, then hang out in the terminal, enjoy your time there, have an airport meal for $20 and save a net $30.

Joe


Or you could just wear a pilot shirt. When I go to LAS/HND, we usually airline home. I always ask the ticket agent if there is an earlier flight, and have never been charged. And you get the golden treatment while on the airplane.
 
I would rather they just charge the fare up-front with no bullcrap, rather than advertise a low fare, but with a ton of fees added to it.

But isnt that how the model was run since this 'extra fee' thing started? It didnt work for most of the carriers. It had to change.
 
AMR really ticked me off this week, trying to charge me $50 to standby on a delayed flight...

Thank your fellow business travelers. Flights departing at less ideal times of the day typically run cheaper. Business travelers were repeatedly booking cheaper flights then showing up at preferred times to standby for the flights they REALLY wanted. It makes load planning a nightmare. So rather than have the company lose revenue because passengers were gaming the system, AA just fell in line with the rest of the industry.
Not to mention, it totally fouled the boarding process and shot the schedule to pieces. Trying to deal with 30 or 40 would-be standby pax that all want to stuff their 22" roll-aboard in the overhead and then wind up gate-checking them just doesn't work. Then they wonder why nothing's ever on time.

I know what you're thinking- it's just a few here and there. Not even close.

On a personal note, when I was forced to commute to Chicago, I planned my commutes based on loads, not time. Guess who repeatedly got hosed by people working the system? Folks like me.

It's a simple concept- you show up for the flight you bought a ticket for.
When I go to the movies, I don't buy a cheaper ticket for the matinee and then ask if I can show up prime time "if there's room for me".
 
On a personal note, when I was forced to commute to Chicago, I planned my commutes based on loads, not time. Guess who repeatedly got hosed by people working the system? Folks like me.

Well I wasn't really going to bring that up, but it is a royal PIA to try to NR when the standbys are gaming the system.

Joe
 
Guess who repeatedly got hosed by people working the system? Folks like me.

I agree with all your points but this one. How can a NR get hosed by a paying passenger? NR is a benefit, not a right. It's still a customer service industry, isn't it?
 
I agree with all your points but this one. How can a NR get hosed by a paying passenger? NR is a benefit, not a right. It's still a customer service industry, isn't it?

Very easily. When you check the loads 12, 10, 8, 6 and 3 hours before take off there are 40 open seats with 19 employees trying to get either to work or home from work. Everything looks good. All of a sudden there are 50 stand-bys showing up for the flight as they try to game the system. Makes it real difficult to get to work or get home after a 4 day trip.

Joe
 
I agree with all your points but this one. How can a NR get hosed by a paying passenger? NR is a benefit, not a right. It's still a customer service industry, isn't it?

Like Joe Friday said above, you play the game and aim for the flight with the open seats and stay out of everybody's way.

No, I'm not suggesting that a paying customer should give way to a nonrev- that doesn't make sense. I didn't commute by choice, however, and when I planned my rides to and from work based on loads I got hosed and got hosed often. There comes a point where a customer is robbing you blind and inconveniencing everybody around them and potentially gumming up the works in other, less obvious ways as well.
 
Like Joe Friday said above, you play the game and aim for the flight with the open seats and stay out of everybody's way.

No, I'm not suggesting that a paying customer should give way to a nonrev- that doesn't make sense. I didn't commute by choice, however, and when I planned my rides to and from work based on loads I got hosed and got hosed often. There comes a point where a customer is robbing you blind and inconveniencing everybody around them and potentially gumming up the works in other, less obvious ways as well.

Now should we be blaming the customer who's attempting to get a standby, or the gate agent or ticket agent that approves said standby?
 
Yeah, I agree. If your original flight gets delayed over an hour and there is an earlier flight now, or if you misconnect or something and can't be re-booked on the next flight, United will still let you stand by for free. I agree with it totally. You have no idea how many people buy a ticket on the wide open 757 to SNA at 8pm then show up to the airport for the 4pm CRJ flight trying to go out early. The ticket difference is usually significant between the two flights and the businessmen figured out they could "cheat the system". Funny how as soon as the $50 charge came about, I would get maybe 2-3 revenue standbys on an SNA flight instead of 25-30.

True, but they were simply winning at the game. There are still empty seats, regardless of who pays what and when. Instead of bringing in somewhat less than the big price the airline wanted for those seats, they chose to not adjust the fare program and now may bring in a couple hundred, tops. If that plane is not filling up, the prices are too high for those last seats.
 
Now should we be blaming the customer who's attempting to get a standby, or the gate agent or ticket agent that approves said standby?

Well the company policy told the gate agents to put those stand bys on the plane and that same company policy said those stand bys trumped all NR because they were revenue passengers.

That is the way that is WAS. Now the company policy is to put the stand bys on the plane but make sure you get $50 AR out of them. AR is now measured and gate agents are on their toes.

Joe
 
True, but they were simply winning at the game. There are still empty seats, regardless of who pays what and when. Instead of bringing in somewhat less than the big price the airline wanted for those seats, they chose to not adjust the fare program and now may bring in a couple hundred, tops. If that plane is not filling up, the prices are too high for those last seats.

I dunno, they are flying pretty close to capacity on many routes these days. If there are seats available they seem to put them on priceline the night before and pull the revenue in that way.

Joe
 
Like Joe Friday said above, you play the game and aim for the flight with the open seats and stay out of everybody's way.

.

Not really me being the bad guy this time though, it was my connecting flight I was trying to standby for. It was AMR's delay that made me want to standby. I had a seat request on a overbooked flight, and was trying to get on one with 8 open. My point is, you should refund restricted tickets on cancelled flights, and not charge for standby on delayed ones.

I end up fighting for those refunds quite a bit (in a perfect world, the airline should just send the ticket off to another carrier, but it is like pulling teeth to make that happen. I usually just buy a ticket on the other carrier because it isn't worth the aggravation)

As for the frequent fliers gaming the system, still largely the case. I'm platinum medallion on Delta, so I can already same-day standby for free. And that can be dicey too, since you need to use the ticket by midnight that day. I would be surprised if American didn't still do the same for Executive Platinums (but I don't fly American vey often these days)
 
Now should we be blaming the customer who's attempting to get a standby, or the gate agent or ticket agent that approves said standby?

The customer makes the decision based on their options provided by the company. If the ticket agent approves it, it's because the company said "that's what we do." So it's a combination of management policy and the customer exploiting that policy.

Granted, I'm no expert on gate agent policy. I just know what I've seen.

Once saw a 777 turn away 90+ standbys. Were it not for the jumpseat, I might still be stuck in Chicago.
 
Not really me being the bad guy this time though, it was my connecting flight I was trying to standby for. It was AMR's delay that made me want to standby. I had a seat request on a overbooked flight, and was trying to get on one with 8 open. My point is, you should refund restricted tickets on cancelled flights, and not charge for standby on delayed ones.

I end up fighting for those refunds quite a bit (in a perfect world, the airline should just send the ticket off to another carrier, but it is like pulling teeth to make that happen. I usually just buy a ticket on the other carrier because it isn't worth the aggravation)

As for the frequent fliers gaming the system, still largely the case. I'm platinum medallion on Delta, so I can already same-day standby for free. And that can be dicey too, since you need to use the ticket by midnight that day. I would be surprised if American didn't still do the same for Executive Platinums (but I don't fly American vey often these days)

I follow you, but the same concept still applies. I understand why you might want to standby, though, when the schedule isn't met. Maybe somebody could get an exception made in that case. I don't really make policy as it were. I just drive. :)

There is a great deal that could be better in the airline business as far as customer service goes, but the customer base seems to think that the airlines owe them something for nothing. The market has become commodity based, yes, but that doesn't mean customers can just have their run of things. Money still needs to change hands. The companies get to determine when and how.
 
Wanna know the problem? For a trip tomorrow from DC to BOS:

Greyhound: 66 bucks
Jetblue: 100 bucks.

It seems to me an hour and a half trip deserves more than a 30 dollar premium over a 11 hour trip on a damn bus.
 
The customer makes the decision based on their options provided by the company. If the ticket agent approves it, it's because the company said "that's what we do." So it's a combination of management policy and the customer exploiting that policy.

Granted, I'm no expert on gate agent policy. I just know what I've seen.

Once saw a 777 turn away 90+ standbys. Were it not for the jumpseat, I might still be stuck in Chicago.

Hold on there just a sec. If a policy is in place that the company allows, then the customer isn't necessarily exploiting the policy (implying that the customer is doing something nefarious), the customer is simply using that policy which is allowed.

If its allowed, then theres no exploitation going on that I can see.....
 
Hold on there just a sec. If a policy is in place that the company allows, then the customer isn't necessarily exploiting the policy (implying that the customer is doing something nefarious), the customer is simply using that policy which is allowed.

If its allowed, then theres no exploitation going on that I can see.....

And now the policy has been changed. It now costs $50 to standby for a flight. That seems to have taken care of the issue.

Joe
 
Back
Top