Amateur hour at US Airways

Very interesting discussions the thread is generating.

I can completely see your point of view here, as esp the bolded part and the last sentence.

On the first portion, while that may generally be true of airline pax (and I agree thats what goes on most of the time), what about the first-class pax, if any? If they didn't give a rats behind about customer service, why would they buy a first or business-class ticket? Why spend the $$$, if there's not an expectation of certain level of service for their money? Yes, this is beyond where the discussion is going, but is an interesting question so far as how the customer sees the provider, and how the provider sees the customer.

Its an interesting attitude, and one that very well might be the reason why more people aren't flying - resulting in less flights and thus, the less need for so many airlines, and as a result, the less need for pilots. It's all a vicious circle and who knows what role that attitude may have in it......

Just some interesting food for thought.

Very true Mike. But I think that is more so the case on international flights. I bet 75% of first or business class seats being filled domestically are not by people who shelled out the money, it's by upgrades given to frequent fliers. Now granted those frequent fliers are shelling out all this money to fly enough to get upgrades, yea it's just a viscious circle.
 
The whole "not done with checklists" thing just doesn't add up to me. Not saying you are wrong or anything. I would be upset too I guess. But different checklists are done at different points as I am sure you know. Sometimes we have a very short taxi and if I got asked "can you accept an immediate departure?" I would say no if we had not completed the taxi checklist. Maybe something similar is the case. Can't be sure unless I was actually in that cockpit.

Also, how could you possibly know what your release time is? I have gotten up to the runway and been told to hold for 20 minutes because ATC is missing our release.

It seems to me that the fault would lay more with ATC than anything else, but again, who really knows unless you were behind that door.

Like everyone else said, the PA is the only thing that seemed rookie. I guess that is why you gotta lie! haha. Seriously, perhaps the Captain meant "we could not accept an immediate departure so they put us in the penalty box for an hour. Seems pretty crazy huh folks? At least we are here safe on the ground and not in the air wondering if we are".
Excellent post. Probably won't elicit a lot of response here as you didn't poke anyone in the eye.:laff:
 
It's kind of interesting reading all the discussions here as a non-pilot.

"Why don't you just drive?" and "Customers should suck it up and deal with it" are exactly the reasons why if the flight is less than 8 hours I'll opt to drive.

Don't you realize that it is the airlines' attitude like that which is the reason why more people aren't flying - resulting in less flights and thus, the less need for pilots? It's all a vicious circle, and that kind of thinking plays a role in that.

I've had experiences like this countless times before. Like when the captain comes on and says "Ladies and gentlemen, we have a minor maintenance issue, and it looks like we're going to be delayed by a half hour." Meanwhile, I look out the window, and I see the entire cowling removed from the engine and about a dozen guys with tools around it. It's like it'll take at least a half hour to clean up the tools and put the engine back together, not to mention the actual time to do the maintenance and verify the fix. So come on the intercom and tell me "Hey, it's going to be an hour and a half." After all, it's not like I can rebook on another airline; I'm going to have to wait. But I'd rather have a flight crew that is honest with me, because otherwise it tells me that the crew is either a) incompetent or b) untrustworthy, neither of which gives me trust in the flight crew's ability.

One thing to keep in mind is to put yourself in the passengers' shoes. You are pilots and you know what's happening behind the scenes. But I, as an average non-pilot passenger, would think, "What a line of BS? Are they covering for a real big maintenance issue or a security issue?" And a tone of surprise in their voice would just reinforce that incompetence and/or untrustworthy feeling.

You see, I expect pilots to be prepared for anything and everything; that's why I expect pilots to get paid well. As Doug once told me, you don't earn your pay every hour you spend flying; you earn your pay when the engine falls off the wing and you have seconds between life and death for all the passengers. I don't want to hear "Wow, I never expected that!"

As an illustration, imagine if Sullenberger had adopted the same attitude as MikeD's captain:

"Ladies and gentlemen, I really apologize.....if it makes you feel any better, in 15 years of being an airline captain, this has never happened and is the first time I've experienced it. We're very sorry for the delay."

A true statement, but not one that builds confidence in the flight crew.
 
"Cactus 1752, Phoenix Approach - Due to workload from IFR aircraft making practice approaches at Gateway, unable to continue providing radar services. So radar service terminated, frequency change approved. Oh and by the way, Phoenix class Bravo airspace begins at 12 o'clock and 1 mile. Good day!"
Me thinks cactus pilot finally used that Chandelle he learned in Commercial training.
 
I

I've had experiences like this countless times before. Like when the captain comes on and says "Ladies and gentlemen, we have a minor maintenance issue, and it looks like we're going to be delayed by a half hour." Meanwhile, I look out the window, and I see the entire cowling removed from the engine and about a dozen guys with tools around it. It's like it'll take at least a half hour to clean up the tools and put the engine back together, not to mention the actual time to do the maintenance and verify the fix. So come on the intercom and tell me "Hey, it's going to be an hour and a half." After all, it's not like I can rebook on another airline; I'm going to have to wait. But I'd rather have a flight crew that is honest with me, because otherwise it tells me that the crew is either a) incompetent or b) untrustworthy, neither of which gives me trust in the flight crew's ability.

One thing to keep in mind is to put yourself in the passengers' shoes. You are pilots and you know what's happening behind the scenes. But I, as an average non-pilot passenger, would think, "What a line of BS? Are they covering for a real big maintenance issue or a security issue?" And a tone of surprise in their voice would just reinforce that incompetence and/or untrustworthy feeling.

It's very difficult to estimate the time it will take for a maintenance issues to be resolved. Sometimes a seemingly major issue can be resolved by resetting a circuit breaker while a minor issue requires digging into the belly of the aircraft and changing a series of valves. There's really no way for the average pilot to know, so we try and give the best estimate. The problem with making the estimate too-long is that people will wander off. Then what happens when it's a quick fix, you're ready to go again, but someone went to the opposite end of the airport in anticipation of an hour delay? Do you leave without them or delay everyone so they can come back?

I've been cursed and called a liar by passengers before because I made a PA that said it shouldn't be more than 5 minutes to find a gate after we landed but it ended up taking 15. I don't know why people think we're doing this stuff intentionally or to be malicious. All we can do is try our best, but sometimes it doesn't work out perfectly. It almost seems like a better option to not make any PA's at all, especially with the knowledge that you can be doing a carpet dance if you don't phrase everything just perfectly.
 
Aaaaaaaaactually, some of us have customer service baked right into the decision-making process.
 
Very interesting discussions the thread is generating.

I can completely see your point of view here, as esp the bolded part and the last sentence.

On the first portion, while that may generally be true of airline pax (and I agree thats what goes on most of the time), what about the first-class pax, if any? If they didn't give a rats behind about customer service, why would they buy a first or business-class ticket? Why spend the $$$, if there's not an expectation of certain level of service for their money? Yes, this is beyond where the discussion is going, but is an interesting question so far as how the customer sees the provider, and how the provider sees the customer.

Its an interesting attitude, and one that very well might be the reason why more people aren't flying - resulting in less flights and thus, the less need for so many airlines, and as a result, the less need for pilots. It's all a vicious circle and who knows what role that attitude may have in it......

Just some interesting food for thought.
And this is why I said what I said. Like it or not, "regionals" are getting bigger airplanes, and some are equipped with business class, etc. If you keep thinking you only have sheeple behind you going to orbitz to get the lowest fare, and you have multiple classes on your airplane, then you are wrong. Trust me.

Very true Mike. But I think that is more so the case on international flights. I bet 75% of first or business class seats being filled domestically are not by people who shelled out the money, it's by upgrades given to frequent fliers.
Now, how do you think the people travelling internationally in business class or better get to JFK, or another hub city??? No, it is not just the frequent fliers, whose asses you should be kissing also due to their repeat business, but it is also the international business class...the people who are so disgusted with flying domestically that they wil charter a jet to get to JFK for their international flight. If you don't think that happens, you are crazy!! I did it many times in the US. Once again, it is job security for us in the corporate and charter world. Thank you for underestimating your pax.:beer:
Aaaaaaaaactually, some of us have customer service baked right into the decision-making process.
So, when are the airlines going to realize there are two different mindsets when it comes to customer service (regional representing the airline, and the mother ship) and take care of the customers that actually pay the bills???:insane:
 
I've been cursed and called a liar by passengers before because I made a PA that said it shouldn't be more than 5 minutes to find a gate after we landed but it ended up taking 15. I don't know why people think we're doing this stuff intentionally or to be malicious. All we can do is try our best, but sometimes it doesn't work out perfectly. It almost seems like a better option to not make any PA's at all, especially with the knowledge that you can be doing a carpet dance if you don't phrase everything just perfectly.

And I agree that a pax....any pax.....treating a flightcrew member like you describe, is as wrong as can be and are completely out of line doing that. Customer service DOES NOT give pax the right to treat an employee in that way. Thats nowhere near the intent of it.

Whats funny is, that there probably is a lot of merit for no PAs at all, both for pax as well as for the crew.
 
And I agree that a pax....any pax.....treating a flightcrew member like you describe, is as wrong as can be and are completely out of line doing that.

Whats funny is, that there probably is a lot of merit for no PAs at all, both for pax as well as for the crew.

When I was flying passengers, I told them the truth, but never gave specifics. "We're going to be delayed." "For how long?" "Never can tell, could be 5 minutes, could be an hour."
 
So, when are the airlines going to realize there are two different mindsets when it comes to customer service (regional representing the airline, and the mother ship) and take care of the customers that actually pay the bills???:insane:

That's kicked us square in the pants on all of the surveys.

They beat customer service into our heads at the mothership, but a lot of the contract carriers have different ways of doing business so the customer gets an unbalanced experience.

I flew on a paid ticket from JFK down to VA a few years ago on Mesa and quite frankly, no one on the aircraft gave a crap about jack squat. And I understand, it was a rough time, still is and moral was low, but at least look after your customers.

I don't even buy into the whole "the customer pays my paycheck!" deal because they don't. If it was up to them, 95% of them take the attitude that "Oh, find someone who just loves to fly, will do it for free and won't crumple the plane at the end of the runway in a supernova of aluminum, kerosene and fire."

But if I do my best for the passengers, maybe they'll buy another ticket on my airine, who actually pays me so I, in turn, can pay union dues to get some attack dogs to get me some more money! :)
 
That's kicked us square in the pants on all of the surveys.

They beat customer service into our heads at the mothership, but a lot of the contract carriers have different ways of doing business so the customer gets an unbalanced experience.
Trust me, I know I've been on a few of your business class overseas trips starting in JAX, and there is definitely something to be desired on my getting to JFK. I now know why the people that can afford to charter airplanes to an international hub do. Sad, but very true.

I flew on a paid ticket from JFK down to VA a few years ago on Mesa and quite frankly, no one on the aircraft gave a crap about jack squat. And I understand, it was a rough time, still is and moral was low, but at least look after your customers.

I don't even buy into the whole "the customer pays my paycheck!" deal because they don't. If it was up to them, 95% of them take the attitude that "Oh, find someone who just loves to fly, will do it for free and won't crumple the plane at the end of the runway in a supernova of aluminum, kerosene and fire."

But if I do my best for the passengers, maybe they'll buy another ticket on my airine, who actually pays me so I, in turn, can pay union dues to get some attack dogs to get me some more money! :)
Absolutely agree, and that is why I chimed in when I did. Seriously, take care of your customers. You are not just transporting the people on vacation. There are movers and shakers, even if you do not realize it, and you (general you) may be the reason they charter a flight, or drive, or any number of other things, next time.

Also, to clarify...when I said the "customers that actually pay the bills", I was referring to the business class people in general. Higher price tickets, international flight connections, etc. I was not referring to "I pay your salary since I fly your airline" types.
 
And you never know when you're going to walk back in the cabin to take a squirt during a transcon and be staring Snookie in the face when she's on GoGo Wireless tweeting away. ;)

"OMGZ!"
 
Attitude?

lol...Okay Mike.

These guys DID their job for all you know. But hey, you guys missed your wheels up time...they clearly are incompetent and need to be knocked down to being a CFI.

Once that door closes, customer service doesn't really come into my decision making process...operating the plane safely - and hopefully - on time is our goal. A safe flight is the pinnacle of customer service.

Hopefully from this little experience you've decided to stay off of a US Airways flight from here on out.
I'll echo stonecold. PLEASE keep this attitude up. Only makes jobs like mine in higher demand.

A safe flight is just the beginning. Maybe someday you'll realize that. Then again I think you just do this job for the ALPA card, that is after all one of the first things you asked about after getting hired.
What a joke... :clap:
 
...the people who are so disgusted with flying domestically that they wil charter a jet to get to JFK for their international flight. If you don't think that happens, you are crazy!! I did it many times in the US. Once again, it is job security for us in the corporate and charter world. Thank you for underestimating your pax.:beer:

I took 2 couples to TEB just this morning to catch an International flight.
 
Do one of you Corpies want to elucidate to the group why it's hard for an ex-Airline guy to land a corporate job? :)
 
Do one of you Corpies want to elucidate to the group why it's hard for an ex-Airline guy to land a corporate job? :)

It's too bad that a few guys wreck it for the rest of us. I'll be the first to admit that I'm lazy when it comes to getting a flight ready to go. I like somebody else filing my flight plan, figuring out the fuel, and loading the bags and people. That said, just because I don't do all that doesn't mean I'm not responsible for providing the best customer service I can. There are a bunch of guys that have the mentality that the slugs in the back are pretty much self loading cargo and as long as they get there in one piece the pilot's job is done. Of course it's way more than that, but good luck getting that through to some people.

During the hiring boom of 2008 I had to lecture an FO on not using abrupt control inputs and that there was a reason to be gentle with the thrust levers and not rip out the spoilers when they were needed. He flew the airplane the same way he'd flown himself around in a Cessna and he really didn't get the fact that there were people in the back who were paying for the experience. Of course once I harped on it enough he came back with the typical "well, they don't pay me enough to be smooth on the controls" argument. Thankfully he's moved on to other pastures but there are many, many guys out there like him.
 
It's too bad that a few guys wreck it for the rest of us. I'll be the first to admit that I'm lazy when it comes to getting a flight ready to go. I like somebody else filing my flight plan, figuring out the fuel, and loading the bags and people. That said, just because I don't do all that doesn't mean I'm not responsible for providing the best customer service I can. There are a bunch of guys that have the mentality that the slugs in the back are pretty much self loading cargo and as long as they get there in one piece the pilot's job is done. Of course it's way more than that, but good luck getting that through to some people.

During the hiring boom of 2008 I had to lecture an FO on not using abrupt control inputs and that there was a reason to be gentle with the thrust levers and not rip out the spoilers when they were needed. He flew the airplane the same way he'd flown himself around in a Cessna and he really didn't get the fact that there were people in the back who were paying for the experience. Of course once I harped on it enough he came back with the typical "well, they don't pay me enough to be smooth on the controls" argument. Thankfully he's moved on to other pastures but there are many, many guys out there like him.

Oh brother. Say it isn't so. Yes, I know pax can be a pain in many ways and at many times, but as you say, they are the reason you are flying the plane. The plane isn't being flown just to burn JP-4 in the Flight Levels. If theres anyone who can't understand this, then they shouldn't be in 121/135 pax ops.

That doesn't mean anyone should have to take unreasonable crap from pax, but that's part and parcel from what the mission of the airline is.
 
Do one of you Corpies want to elucidate to the group why it's hard for an ex-Airline guy to land a corporate job? :)

From what I understand, after you've had a job where you've personally loaded 4000lbs, flown a 3.5hr to 4hr leg, unloaded close to 4000lbs of cargo by yourself to complete a 14.2hr day/night at FL180 and below in some of the worse weather you could imagine.... throwing 50lbs of luggage, walking a dog on the ramp to take a pee, and serving a drink or two in the back while cruising at FL350 above all of the weather for decent pay doesn't seem like such a bad deal.:D
 
Mike,

Do you know if both engines were turning when you got to the end of the runway? Here is my best guess of what happened, they were given a specific wheels up time and they had every intention of making it. But, ATC released them five minutes early (which happens often on the east coast) and they did not yet have the other engine running. The crew then told them they needed those extra five minutes they were expecting but, ATC was unable. I always ask if the time is a hard time or if there might be an earlier one. Most folks don't though.
 
Back
Top