MidlifeFlyer
Well-Known Member
We absolutely agree on that. I didn't suggest otherwise for even a second. I only said:In-flight structural icing happens only in visible moisture regardless of the flight rules. Right? Can we all agree on that? Or am I missing something? Sure, you can get frost on wings sitting on the ground while the sky's so clear you feel like you could pluck the stars from the sky. But we're talking about in-flight, structural icing... at least I thought we were.
(1) the report did not say anything about the presence or absence of visible moisture, only that the conditions were VFR.
(2) I have picked up a trace of ice with conditions better than 4,000 and 10. Yes, there was obviously visible moisture but just as obviously it was good VFR that wasn't even marginal VFR;
(3) You added a fact that was not there (equating VFR conditions with a lack of visible moisture) in order to make a point about people who add facts that are not there (I think that actually is humorous).
Since you seem to be fond of quibbling, "basic VFR" is not 1,000 and 3. 1,000 and 3 is the required minimum ceiling and visibility for VFR operations at an airport with controlled airspace to the surface (Class B, C, D and E airports). "Basic VFR" below 10,000 msl, is remaining 500' above or below clouds and 2,000' laterally away from them.Basic VFR = 3sm and 1000.