Alternative Facts: The VFR flight icing encounter...

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 27505
  • Start date Start date
In-flight structural icing happens only in visible moisture regardless of the flight rules. Right? Can we all agree on that? Or am I missing something? Sure, you can get frost on wings sitting on the ground while the sky's so clear you feel like you could pluck the stars from the sky. But we're talking about in-flight, structural icing... at least I thought we were.
We absolutely agree on that. I didn't suggest otherwise for even a second. I only said:
(1) the report did not say anything about the presence or absence of visible moisture, only that the conditions were VFR.
(2) I have picked up a trace of ice with conditions better than 4,000 and 10. Yes, there was obviously visible moisture but just as obviously it was good VFR that wasn't even marginal VFR;
(3) You added a fact that was not there (equating VFR conditions with a lack of visible moisture) in order to make a point about people who add facts that are not there (I think that actually is humorous).

Basic VFR = 3sm and 1000.
Since you seem to be fond of quibbling, "basic VFR" is not 1,000 and 3. 1,000 and 3 is the required minimum ceiling and visibility for VFR operations at an airport with controlled airspace to the surface (Class B, C, D and E airports). "Basic VFR" below 10,000 msl, is remaining 500' above or below clouds and 2,000' laterally away from them.
 
We absolutely agree on that. I didn't suggest otherwise for even a second. I only said:
(1) the report did not say anything about the presence or absence of visible moisture, only that the conditions were VFR.
(2) I have picked up a trace of ice with conditions better than 4,000 and 10. Yes, there was obviously visible moisture but just as obviously it was good VFR that wasn't even marginal VFR;
(3) You added a fact that was not there (equating VFR conditions with a lack of visible moisture) in order to make a point about people who add facts that are not there (I think that actually is humorous).


Since you seem to be fond of quibbling, "basic VFR" is not 1,000 and 3. 1,000 and 3 is the required minimum ceiling and visibility for VFR operations at an airport with controlled airspace to the surface (Class B, C, D and E airports). "Basic VFR" below 10,000 msl, is remaining 500' above or below clouds and 2,000' laterally away from them.
I was about to just quote my own OP in which I said, "...but somehow I picked up ice while not flying in visible moisture. No, really, your FAA Worshipfulness, it was clear and a million... and so icy I crashed." Then I read your second paragraph point. You conflated icing and VFR. My statements that it was VFR and that there was icing are separate statement points, albeit typically related (but not necessarily, as you and others have pointed out and I've agreed.) so I'll give you a pass on assuming that's what I meant. That said, your conflation is your own. I didn't conflate those points, only stated them. Nowhere did I state that one can't get iced in VFR, though, as I said later, those two conditions usually don't go together.
When I read your second paragraph about mins all was revealed. I realized you aren't really reading what I'm writing... to wit: "Main point of my second post-in-thread: VFR is 3 and 1000 (for typical 182 flight altitudes) or greater at higher altitudes." Yeah, that would completely comport with your astute observation in P2 of your post in which you seek to correct me for... what?... not knowing that? not having stated that?? Like I said, this isn't fun when people don't really read and process first, respond second. It's not about quibbling.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You all sound like the grumpy old men over at the Pilots of America forum. I imagine you'll start arguing over cylinder head temps and flying over square any time now.
Precisely what I meant by not much fun anymore... ;)
 
Thank you. That was my only point.
Then why, pray tell, all the other points? Pointing out that I said what I said is hardly a useful point to make, is it??? I mean, it's obvious and no one is arguing it, hmm? But it did brilliantly illustrate the problem with this whole alternative fact issue. Folks ends up talking about nonsense instead of the issues at hand. So, well done.
 
I will also vouch for picking up icing in 20 mile plus VFR conditions, the moisture only became visible once it became ice on the windshield and it accumulated surprisingly quickly.
 
Back
Top