Alternative Facts: The VFR flight icing encounter...

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 27505
  • Start date Start date
D

Deleted member 27505

Guest
NTSB Identification: CEN17LA076

On January 11, 2017, about 0913 central standard time (all times cst), a Cessna 182T bearing Canadian registration C-GTBI, was substantially damaged during landing following an in-flight structural icing encounter. The pilot, who was the sole occupant, was not injured. The airplane incurred structural damage to the forward fuselage and firewall. The aircraft was registered to Falconair Ltd., and operated by the pilot under the provisions of 14 Code of Federal Regulations Part 91 as a business flight. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed for the flight, which was not on a flight plan. The flight originated from Sawyer International Airport, Marquette, Michigan about 0505.

"Well, see, er, VFR conditions prevailed and I was flying VFR without a flight plan, but somehow I picked up ice while not flying in visible moisture. No, really, your FAA Worshipfulness, it was clear and a million... and so icy I crashed."
 
An excellent use of alternative facts! Keep 'em coming!

But, seriously, you can pick up ice from ice fog in conditions that are VFR: 1000' and 1 is all you need to be VFR, and ice fog can exist with that visibility. I know a guy who loaded up with so much ice in VFR ice fog that he couldn't make it to the runway.
 
An excellent use of alternative facts! Keep 'em coming!

But, seriously, you can pick up ice from ice fog in conditions that are VFR: 1000' and 1 is all you need to be VFR, and ice fog can exist with that visibility. I know a guy who loaded up with so much ice in VFR ice fog that he couldn't make it to the runway.
VFR mins...1000 and 1??? Forgive me, but is that another alternative fact? :) I've never seen ice fog with 3sm viz; 3sm viz is not fog... mist at best. If you're having to S-VFR it to make it to the airport, I can't imagine it's better viz enroute. I mean, really. "I picked up the ice a mile from the airport as I broke out of the clear." ??
 
Last edited by a moderator:
1000 and 1??? Forgive me, but is that another alternative fact? :) I've never seen ice fog with 3sm viz. If you're having to S-VFR it to make it to the airport, I can't imagine it's better viz enroute.
I have picked up ice while in FZDZ with 10+ SM vis that hung on the airplane all the way back to the home drome, 30 miles or so.
 
I have picked up ice while in FZDZ with 10+ SM vis that hung on the airplane all the way back to the home drome, 30 miles or so.
Sheesh. You just trying to be contrary? ;) Yeah, I get it: There are times one not need be in clouds/fog when it is still possible for ice to adhere and accrue to an airframe. Still, freezing rain/freezing drizzle is visible moisture. And still... that wasn't really my point in the OP, nor the post you quoted me on.
Wx in the upper Midwest lately has been low clg clouds, fog, clouds, and more clouds. There has been some freezing rain, mixed precip, and probably some ice fog (I wouldn't know, it's in contravention of our opspecs), but all that stuff has come from low clg clouds, fog, clouds and more fog.
Just so we're clear. Main point of OP: Dumbassery is bad, m'kay. Main point of my second post-in-thread: VFR is 3 and 1000 (for typical 182 flight altitudes) or greater at higher altitudes.
This isn't fun anymore...:(
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Sheesh. You just trying to be contrary? ;) Yeah, I get it: There are times one not need be in clouds/fog when it is still possible for ice to adhere and accrue to an airframe. Still, freezing rain/freezing drizzle is visible moisture. And still... that wasn't really my point in the OP, nor the post you quoted me on.
Wx in the upper Midwest lately has been low clg clouds, fog, clouds, and more clouds. There has been some freezing rain, mixed precip, and probably some ice fog (I wouldn't know, it's in contravention of our opspecs), but all that stuff has come from low clg clouds, fog, clouds and more fog.
Just so we're clear. Main point of OP: Dumbassery is bad, m'kay. Main point of my second post-in-thread: VFR is 3 and 1000 (for typical 182 flight altitudes) or greater at higher altitudes.
This isn't fun anymore...:(
Well, what do you expect him to say? "Yup Mr. CAA man, you got me, I was bandit IFR!"?
 
Sheesh. You just trying to be contrary? ;) Yeah, I get it: There are times one not need be in clouds/fog when it is still possible for ice to adhere and accrue to an airframe. Still, freezing rain/freezing drizzle is visible moisture. And still... that wasn't really my point in the OP, nor the post you quoted me on.
Wx in the upper Midwest lately has been low clg clouds, fog, clouds, and more clouds. There has been some freezing rain, mixed precip, and probably some ice fog (I wouldn't know, it's in contravention of our opspecs), but all that stuff has come from low clg clouds, fog, clouds and more fog.
Just so we're clear. Main point of OP: Dumbassery is bad, m'kay. Main point of my second post-in-thread: VFR is 3 and 1000 (for typical 182 flight altitudes) or greater at higher altitudes.
This isn't fun anymore...:(
That's the problem. Once someone disagrees and makes a valid point in the process, it's no longer fun.

I got the point of your original post and appreciated it. Sounds like dumbassery to me too. But, having very recently picked up a small coating of ice in a bit of light freezing drizzle with 4,000' ceilings and >10 visibility, I had a similar reaction to some others. if you look at it, there is nothing in the report that says the pilot claimed he was not in "visible moisture" defined as any liquid you could see. Just that he was VFR. "No visible moisture" was your, um, alternative fact add-on. It's not a monopoly, you know.
 
Last edited:
VFR mins...1000 and 1??? Forgive me, but is that another alternative fact? :) I've never seen ice fog with 3sm viz; 3sm viz is not fog... mist at best. If you're having to S-VFR it to make it to the airport, I can't imagine it's better viz enroute. I mean, really. "I picked up the ice a mile from the airport as I broke out of the clear." ??

I've picked up ice in good VFR... that is to say, 500' and 1sm. I don't know where this "3sm" comes from...

-Fox
 
I was flying that morning and heard this guy talking to ATC. The actual events may not be as cut and dry as the NTSB report makes it sound.

From what I heard, he was VFR and got caught off guard by rapidly deteriorating weather, which was not in the forecast. Shortly after I took off, ATC offered Rhinelander to him as a VFR airport and within minutes had to change plans, as the field had gone IFR. I told ATC the conditions I took off in 45 miles south of there, which was MVFR, and thought he might head that way. I changed frequencies before I heard the outcome.

This guy may be a dumbass, but if so, it's probably more for believing the forecasts. And no one here has ever done that before, right?
 
That's the problem. Once someone disagrees and makes a valid point in the process, it's no longer fun.

I got the point of your original post and appreciated it. Sounds like dumbassery to me too. But, having very recently picked up a small coating of ice in a bit of light freezing drizzle with 4,000' ceilings and >10 visibility, I had a similar reaction to some others. if you look at it, there is nothing in the report that says the pilot claimed he was not in "visible moisture" defined as any liquid you could see. Just that he was VFR. "No visible moisture" was your, um, alternative fact add-on. It's not a monopoly, you know.
In-flight structural icing happens only in visible moisture regardless of the flight rules. Right? Can we all agree on that? Or am I missing something? Sure, you can get frost on wings sitting on the ground while the sky's so clear you feel like you could pluck the stars from the sky. But we're talking about in-flight, structural icing... at least I thought we were.
You're flying in clear air with rain coming out of an overcast... You're in visible moisture.
You're flying in mist with clear above... You're in visible moisture.
You're flying in freezing drizzle, rain, ice fog (we'll assume for the purposes of this degenerating conversation that that ice fog allows 3sm of VIZ, yeah, right)... but still, you're in visible moisture. Any moisture you can see that touches the airplane... you're in visible moisture. (and yes, science guys, there are probably some extremely rare conditions in which sublimation could put ice on a wing... and if you're worried about encountering those conditions, you'd do well to start buying lotto tickets too.)
If you want to do some Alaska Johnson swinging, knock yourself out. Been there, done that, lived to get the T-shirt. But let's stick to the basics. Basic VFR = 3sm and 1000. Basic axiom of icing: it occurs in visible moisture (and for all you amateur attorneys who seem to be ignoring the unstated assumptions here and going after exceptions implied by ommissions, that's if structural and in flight).
We good yet??
 
I was flying that morning and heard this guy talking to ATC. The actual events may not be as cut and dry as the NTSB report makes it sound.

From what I heard, he was VFR and got caught off guard by rapidly deteriorating weather, which was not in the forecast. Shortly after I took off, ATC offered Rhinelander to him as a VFR airport and within minutes had to change plans, as the field had gone IFR. I told ATC the conditions I took off in 45 miles south of there, which was MVFR, and thought he might head that way. I changed frequencies before I heard the outcome.

This guy may be a dumbass, but if so, it's probably more for believing the forecasts. And no one here has ever done that before, right?
Don't get me wrong. Stuff happens. If you knew me, you'd know I cut folks a great deal of slack, but that doesn't mean I'm not going to go after a teachable moment when it's offered. And I'm not going to rationalize or apologize for poor decision making. I was flying in the area that day too. I filed. It was marginal VFR at best. And if one has even a smidgen of experience flying in the upper Midwest in the winter, one assumes the trend is going to be toward the worse, not the better. Since Happiness = Expectations - Reality, one will likely end up much happier too... or something like that. ;)
 
Back
Top