Airlines oppose law increasing pilot flight hours

Seeing as how this regulation, even if enacted, would not have changed the outcome, I can't see where people are saying this will make airline travel safer. Both Colgan pilots had significantly more time than required under these regulations. The CA had ~3500 TT and the FO ~2200.

In fact, what crashes in the last 10 or 20 years have been pilot error with lower time pilots on board? The Comair crash had two experienced pilots. Not sure about the Republic flight that ran off the end of the runway. The AWAC crash in PVD had a pretty experienced CA, a new hire FO but not sure about their flight times. SWA that ran off the runway in MDW had very experienced pilots on it. How about the CAL aircraft in DEN that ran off the side of the runway due to bad crosswind correction? Experienced as well.

I agree with the airlines unfortunately, having this reg in place probably won't appreciably increase safety. It's a feel good reg.

Now, the rest/duty times, HECK yes that will go a long ways toward making it better and safer. Much more rested crews. I am all for that.

Speaking of which, I took this pic in the shared LGA crew room the other day.

But how much time did they have when they got hired. That's what this is about.
 
Is that a tent that somebody is sleeping in?

A few hundred might be high, I suppose it depends on the year really.

More so, the QOL has to be improved. You can't have pilots complaining about how much they hate their jobs then running RJ's off the end of the runway.
 
Your willingness to be abused and undervaluing your own worth is the problem. By apply to a job at Eagle you've fed the problem.

The race to the bottom is a race I'm not interested in winning. Sounds like your well on your way to getting there though!

Personally I don't think your in a position to make assumptions about me.

How am I willing to be abused when my goal has been to become an airline pilot? This is something I have WANTED since the age of 4 years old and I have my first application in and excited as hell about it.

I don't get it. So I am interested in hearing what types of flying jobs I can obtain right now with and ATP and just about 1900TT with 100 or so multi that is going to

A. Offer consistent reliable hours/flight time
B. Pay better than what a first year FO is going to make and...
C. Please don't tell me about a full time CFI gig at some flight school.

If the answer is nothing then I would appreciate you not looking down on those who may need to work for the regionals for a few years to get the type of hours they need in the future.

If I may ask what are your hours and such? How have you gotten all of the hours needed for whatever flying job(s) you have now? If your flying jets or corporate how did you get qualified without obtaining turbine PIC, which unless I am wrong, is really only obtainable at the regional/major airline level.

Correct me if I am wrong, but are there lots of corporate outfits that bring on relatively inexperienced guys to sit right seat and then years later move up to the left?

I haven't heard of any and I ask and talk to nearly every corporate crew that come into my home airport. We get a lot at times. Gulfstreams, Challengers, Falcons as well as smaller citations, but what I have taken away from them is, with the exception of a couple military guys, all of em were at regionals at one point or another and once they had enough turbine PIC went corporate.

So... I am genuinely most interested in your suggestions for flight jobs that will qualify me to fly some form of jets within the next 3-5 years and will not undervalue my pay.

Thank you.
 
Personally I don't think your in a position to make assumptions about me.

How am I willing to be abused when my goal has been to become an airline pilot? This is something I have WANTED since the age of 4 years old and I have my first application in and excited as hell about it.

I don't get it. So I am interested in hearing what types of flying jobs I can obtain right now with and ATP and just about 1900TT with 100 or so multi that is going to

A. Offer consistent reliable hours/flight time
B. Pay better than what a first year FO is going to make and...
C. Please don't tell me about a full time CFI gig at some flight school.

If the answer is nothing then I would appreciate you not looking down on those who may need to work for the regionals for a few years to get the type of hours they need in the future.

If I may ask what are your hours and such? How have you gotten all of the hours needed for whatever flying job(s) you have now? If your flying jets or corporate how did you get qualified without obtaining turbine PIC, which unless I am wrong, is really only obtainable at the regional/major airline level.

Correct me if I am wrong, but are there lots of corporate outfits that bring on relatively inexperienced guys to sit right seat and then years later move up to the left?

I haven't heard of any and I ask and talk to nearly every corporate crew that come into my home airport. We get a lot at times. Gulfstreams, Challengers, Falcons as well as smaller citations, but what I have taken away from them is, with the exception of a couple military guys, all of em were at regionals at one point or another and once they had enough turbine PIC went corporate.

So... I am genuinely most interested in your suggestions for flight jobs that will qualify me to fly some form of jets within the next 3-5 years and will not undervalue my pay.

Thank you.

I never suggested that flying a jet is the only way to be successful, happy pilot. If low pay and a terrible schedule after spending $50k and a few years on an education isn't abuse to you then by all means, go for it.

I've got a respectable salary, great lifestyle and a wonderful quality of life. I set my own schedule, run my own show and I'm home every night to see my wife and dog. I take the days off that I want off and probably spend 3 weeks/year on vacation. At the beginning of the day I don't have to use hair jell or polish my shoes, or put on epaulets and I don't get told which cheap hotel I'll be sleeping in. I also don't fly a JEEETTTT. The work I choose is irrelevant though because I don't think you'd be interested or willing to do it.

Whatever it is you decide to do with yourself though don't take a $24k/year job, and then ask what you can do to get better pay or QOL. Your willingness to work for low pay is exactly what fuels this industry and keeps it alive. Keep it up, I might need a ticket to Birmingham and I don't want to pay more than $49 each way.

A good friend of mine just turned down his final recall offer to an airline. He told me, "it just isn't worth it. I'm make more now (driving a bus) and don't need to be working for $30k/year. I can freelance on the side and have more fun flying GA. I'm done with the airlines." Sounds like your slot may have just opened up.
 
I don't get it. So I am interested in hearing what types of flying jobs I can obtain right now with and ATP and just about 1900TT with 100 or so multi that is going to

A. Offer consistent reliable hours/flight time
B. Pay better than what a first year FO is going to make and...
C. Please don't tell me about a full time CFI gig at some flight school.

The past few jobs I've had fit that criteria.

Skydive pilot
Oil & Pipeline
and, yes - Flight Instructor.

Each of those I'm making more than an FO, and meet the requirements you described. Now I'm looking corporate, light cabin aircraft and I'm hearing the same thing a lot: we're not hiring due to the economy. So all of those crews you're talking to that are telling you that you can get in on the right side may not have the biggest picture of what the reality of hiring is right now.

To give you a bigger picture of me, I have 2600/600 of which is about 600 in turbine aircraft.

So... I am genuinely most interested in your suggestions for flight jobs that will qualify me to fly some form of jets within the next 3-5 years and will not undervalue my pay.

Thank you.

Personally, I never expected skydiving to be so lucrative and valuable. If you get in on a king air, caravan or otter you not only can make some serious bank, but you're getting good time too.

$.02
 
Seeing as how this regulation, even if enacted, would not have changed the outcome, I can't see where people are saying this will make airline travel safer. Both Colgan pilots had significantly more time than required under these regulations. The CA had ~3500 TT and the FO ~2200.

In fact, what crashes in the last 10 or 20 years have been pilot error with lower time pilots on board? The Comair crash had two experienced pilots. Not sure about the Republic flight that ran off the end of the runway. The AWAC crash in PVD had a pretty experienced CA, a new hire FO but not sure about their flight times. SWA that ran off the runway in MDW had very experienced pilots on it. How about the CAL aircraft in DEN that ran off the side of the runway due to bad crosswind correction? Experienced as well.

I agree with the airlines unfortunately, having this reg in place probably won't appreciably increase safety. It's a feel good reg.

Now, the rest/duty times, HECK yes that will go a long ways toward making it better and safer. Much more rested crews. I am all for that.

Speaking of which, I took this pic in the shared LGA crew room the other day.

Your analysis misses the mark, and while it sounds compelling, you need to look at this from an instructors point of view to fully understand why higher hiring minimums will increase safety.

When people move from the left seat of a 172 with 250 hours, to the right seat of a regional jet, they are being shortchanged when it comes to fundamental knowledge of how to operate an aircraft. The Colgan crash is a great example; the guy did a departure stall into the ground. A departure stall? I can recover from a departure stall while waking up from a dead sleep after all the departure stalls I've done with my students.

By going to Gulfstream, and not flight instructing, this guy had HUGE holes in his fundamental skills. Requiring 1,500 hours before guys step into larger equipment with paying passengers provides a great assurance that these holes won't be there, but the only way to really find out is to wait for things to hit the fan.

So it's not the total number of hours when the incident/accident happens that matters, it's how you developed as a pilot hundreds, and possibly thousands of hours prior to that point that matter. This is the issue that this legislation is attempting to fix.
 
I never suggested that flying a jet is the only way to be successful, happy pilot. If low pay and a terrible schedule after spending $50k and a few years on an education isn't abuse to you then by all means, go for it.

I've got a respectable salary, great lifestyle and a wonderful quality of life. I set my own schedule, run my own show and I'm home every night to see my wife and dog. I take the days off that I want off and probably spend 3 weeks/year on vacation. At the beginning of the day I don't have to use hair jell or polish my shoes, or put on epaulets and I don't get told which cheap hotel I'll be sleeping in. I also don't fly a JEEETTTT. The work I choose is irrelevant though because I don't think you'd be interested or willing to do it.

Whatever it is you decide to do with yourself though don't take a $24k/year job, and then ask what you can do to get better pay or QOL. Your willingness to work for low pay is exactly what fuels this industry and keeps it alive. Keep it up, I might need a ticket to Birmingham and I don't want to pay more than $49 each way.

A good friend of mine just turned down his final recall offer to an airline. He told me, "it just isn't worth it. I'm make more now (driving a bus) and don't need to be working for $30k/year. I can freelance on the side and have more fun flying GA. I'm done with the airlines." Sounds like your slot may have just opened up.

I understand what your saying, but you really don't need to come across as arrogant.
I don't think you'd be interested or willing to do it.
You don't know anything about me so please do not act like you do. Even if I were payed a lot more as a CFI I do not ENJOY being a CFI (keyword) ANYMORE. It is apparent you ENJOY being a CFI. But I am sure as hell not going to waste life away doing something that doesn't make me happy anymore.

Thats great you are career CFI it really is. They are needed throughout the industry, but for a majority of people there becomes a point when its not exciting and they don't enjoy it anymore. Most CFI's I know that operate out of small FBO's and not major flight schools barely crack $10,000/yr. Its funny you talk about pay because do you want to know what I make right now? How about in the past three years an average of $6500. But I'm not complaining. It was needed and now I have my hours and had some fun doing it, but I am ready for something more. If I had 135 minimums 2 years ago before the economy tanked I would easily have been doing charter in our 421s. Now I would definitely stick around if that were still the case, but we have only an average of 2 charters a week now.

I get it you hate the airlines for whatever reason. Funny thing is this "abusive pay" isn't permanent. Take a look at what a first year captain makes. (Average between all types in the fleet)

- $65 x 72monthly hrs x 12 months = $56,160

Lets jump ahead to year 5 (Avg of $73)

- $73 x 72 x 12 = $63,072

Sure sounds abusive and undervalued to me. But everyone has their own opinion.

Personally I wouldn't hone in on the first year pay. This concept isn't just in aviation.

I have a friend of mine who started working as a graphic designer. He started at $29,000. Now if you look at what freelance designers can make an hour this pay was below the normal. Two years later he is in the low 40's. What company doesn't do this? I think it is smart to do so. Risk management. Not everyone your going to hire is going to be some special gem and work out. Make them show you they are what you thought they were and then increase their comp.

I started out as a CFI at $12.50, but now I am at $25.
 
Perhaps. The guy running ATP in Phoenix told me in his class on the Embraer 145 said that, the airline, pretty much just taught you enough to pass the 121 ride. Nothing more/nothing less.

This is exactly the same format as our FAA test. They are not effective in my opinion. Basically you study and just memorize the answers. After enough study you can take the entire test and can get through all 60-80 questions in about 10 minutes because you know what the answer is without even reading the question just based on the possible answers. What does that teach you?

I have had so many students who got in the high 80's and 90's on their private written and were totally clueless when going over ground before their chekrides.

Going back to my the ATP director, he said this basic bottom line training had resulted in some pretty BAD FO's. Since they were learning nothing more than just what passed their checkride some of them had basically no substantial knowledge of what they were even doing. They were just operating as robots programmed flipping switches and making call outs.

The troubling thing is how many of these floated around and made captain. He told me he flew with more than one captain who were way behind the airplane. Here this guy was as a first year FO and he was ahead of the plane, knew more and had more of a sense of what was happening than a freaking captain with YEARS on him. That in my opinion is downright SCARY!

It is hard to answer, but I think there are instances where some first year FOs could be valued less based on their flying and overall knowledge.

Maybe they should require a lot more flights with designated check captains flying the line who really evaluate you for quite awhile to help figure things out.
 
So wet certificate pilots are incapible of building hours? All of the sudden there are no more 1500hr pilots because the FAA decides to raise mins.? Years and years ago, there were still thousands of apps being sent in to airlines with guys having 3-4k hours, turbine time, military time, etc. Granted this was before de-regulation, so pay was better. But the same "lure's" were still there. There was no pilot shortage then, so what makes you think there will be one now? Serious question.

TOTALLY different era. How many guys were in the right seat after only one or two years as an FO? You could afford to have lower time guys in the right seat because they CA had been flying the same route for 10 years before he upgraded. Even then, it was more of a "Sit down, shut up and don't touch anything unless I tell you" type environment. Not exactly the best as far as people getting along, but it did have his advantages. I never said anything about a pilot shortage. I said a shortage of QUALIFIED PILOTS. We've already had that. It's why airlines went from hiring 1000 hour guys to anyone with wet ink on their commercial. Guys weren't leaving their freight jobs anymore because they were actually BETTER in the pay and sometimes QoL than a regional. If they didn't have the alternative of lowering minimums to the lowest possible, what was their other option? Bringing the pay up to where those guys WOULD leave their frieght or other flying job.

The number of commercial pilot being produced each year, and the number of availible jobs doesn't match up with a pilot shortage. And there is a long way to go before the number of jobs passes up the number of pilots being produced. With the current state of the economy, unless the governement wins the lotery, I doubt I'll ever see it in ym life time when the two pass each other up.

Once again, I'm not talking about guys with wet ink on their commercial. I'm talking about guys that have been around the block enough to bring more than memorized flows and limitations to the right seat.
 
TOTALLY different era. How many guys were in the right seat after only one or two years as an FO? You could afford to have lower time guys in the right seat because they CA had been flying the same route for 10 years before he upgraded. Even then, it was more of a "Sit down, shut up and don't touch anything unless I tell you" type environment. Not exactly the best as far as people getting along, but it did have his advantages. I never said anything about a pilot shortage. I said a shortage of QUALIFIED PILOTS. We've already had that. It's why airlines went from hiring 1000 hour guys to anyone with wet ink on their commercial. Guys weren't leaving their freight jobs anymore because they were actually BETTER in the pay and sometimes QoL than a regional. If they didn't have the alternative of lowering minimums to the lowest possible, what was their other option? Bringing the pay up to where those guys WOULD leave their frieght or other flying job.



Once again, I'm not talking about guys with wet ink on their commercial. I'm talking about guys that have been around the block enough to bring more than memorized flows and limitations to the right seat.

^back when i was flying boxes i was making more than any of the regionals were paying to start, and it was 2 turbine engine pic. flying through the night in snowstorms isn't for everyone, but it was a lot better for me than any commuter.
 
... Take a look at what a first year captain makes. (Average between all types in the fleet)

- $65 x 72monthly hrs x 12 months = $56,160

Lets jump ahead to year 5 (Avg of $73)

- $73 x 72 x 12 = $63,072


Sure sounds abusive and undervalued to me. But everyone has their own opinion.

So I'm guessing 5 years to upgrade at Eagle (I may be totally off but I know it takes a while to flow to the left seat) then another 5 years in the left to end up making $63k/year. 10 years working one job.

If that is OK to you then I guess were just going to have to disagree on this one.

I didn't mean to sound arrogant, it just came off really odd to me that in a single post you inquired about improving working conditions and pay and then also commented that you'd be insane to not take a job if offered at $24k.

Regardless, I am happy to remain in GA and don't have a strong desire to drive tourists around in a jet. For me it is perfect, I met Dick Rutan (the man, the legend holly sta... staa.. ahh uhhh... Mrrrr... Ruuttaaannn!), went on an incredibly fun cross country with a great student and at the end of the day he told me he was very pleased to have spent his day with me. I love what I do, but I also understand that it isn't for everybody.

Best of luck and blue skies with whatever it is you choose to do with your career. Seems your passionate about it and that is a wonderful trait to have!
 
Just read in another article that ALPA is backing the airlines/committee on lowering the hours....YGTBSM
 
Just read in another article that ALPA is backing the airlines/committee on lowering the hours....YGTBSM

I'm confused. Are you talking about lowering the duty day hours? Because if you meant flight hours I thought in 3 years everyone had to have 1500 minimum.

Although is there anything against the airline the day before the 1500 hour rule takes affect to hire someone with say 800TT?
 
This thread is about flight hours. The airlines are opposing the 1500 hour rule. I just added that ALPA is backing the airlines here on lowering the flight hours.
 
I'd be fine with lowering the hour minimums, BUT I want strict and frequent oversight of airline training departments. If you hire 500 hour guys, they need to be trained like 500 hour guys, not 1500 hour guys with experience flying in weather, using the ATC system, etc. Right now, our radar training program is "You'll learn it on the line" or "Just play around with it, you'll get the hang of it." Yeah, 'cause you want to "get the hang" of the radar when you're trying to figure out if that return is St Louis, a level 4 t-storm or just heavy rain.
 
1500 hrs TT will eventually require more money. Reduced hours and increased training will require more money. I don't see a way around this personally. I wish there were. Either way the airlines are going to find a way to cut costs, save money, skimp employees, etc, just for cheap labor, and Congress will fold because it's more money in their pocket. I hope the legacies get scope back, however, I can't see that happening without the pilots taking even more concessions. They've already taken enough for every pilot out there that they don't need more.

Again, call me a pessimist, but at least I can never be let down. :rolleyes:
 
Back
Top