Airlines oppose law increasing pilot flight hours

Is this article legit? Associated press articles usually cite their sources and include things like quotes and facts. I agree with everyones thoughts but I'm not sure this thing was cranked out by the AP.
 
The supply of low time pilots with wet ink on their commercials may not dry up, but we're talking about the supply of QUALIFIED pilots. At least with 1500 hours there's a CHANCE you might see more and actually make a command decision. I've flown with FOs who's only PIC decisions were on their solo cross countries for their PPLs. Guess what? They won't make another unitl they're PIC in a jet with passengers in the back. That scares the crap out of me with some of these guys. Some will "get it" and pay attention while becoming sponges in the right seat. Others will just "fake it" until they have the seniority to upgrade.

So, how about putting it at 1500 PIC?
 
What worries me about this process is simple: Sure, Congress backs the 1500 rule. They put it into law... but they left a big loophole in the law.

That, and a good number of those sitting might not be occupying those seats when the deadline to post the new rule comes about.

There's a lot that can change in the political landscape when you factor in that fourth dimension.

The airlines.. and aviation employers at large... recognize that with an increase in intrinsic value comes an increase in intrinsic cost. Maybe not today, or tomorrow, but someday. Narrowing the pipeline of supply means things won't move like they do now. So in the meantime, they're going to fight tooth and nail and pull every dirty trick they can. Most of all, they're going to wait for people to forget why the rule was changed or what the change was meant to accomplish.
 
Increasing the hours required is going to do nothing for pay. Look at the minumum hours required right now, and people are still falling over one another to go fly for a regional for $19k a year. Show me one regional who is asking for less than 1k hrs right now that is hiring, and droves of people are still more or less spamming them with apps and resumes to make less than one could make working at In&Out full time for a year. Last I heard at In&Out starting pay (flipping burgers mind you) was $10.00. 40 hrs a week for 52 weeks is darn near $30k. And I have a friend of a friend I was talking to at her 30th B-day party who is an assistant manager at one near here who says his boss, the store manager, makes $120k a year.


Bottom line is people are falling over one another to fly for the regionals, and there is a ton of guys out there with +1500hrs that still want into the regionals. This will change nothing.

Best thing I've read on the forum in quite a while.

Until pilots gather their self respect and realize that spending $50k on an education and they are worth more than fast food pay this abuse will go on.

I don't blame any law nor the airlines for the pilot pay situation.

I blame every regional pilot who's ever said yes to a pathetic 24k/year job offer. It's a race to the bottom of the poverty barrel at 400kts.

If nobody said yes to a $24k/year job guess what the airlines would do?
 
Interesting discussion, no doubt, but this flight crew each had well over 1500 hours. The captain had 3300+ and the FO had 2200+. I don't see how raising the mins solves the problem. I've flown with high time pilots that pretty much suck, and low time pilots that are pretty darn good. Must just be too hard to rergulate training and competence. Much easier to just look at a number in a log book.
 
Why don't the airlines just tell the media:

"The safety of the flying public isn't worth our money."

Its true, right? I mean that's what I just read.
 
Why don't the airlines just tell the media:

"The safety of the flying public isn't worth our money."

Its true, right? I mean that's what I just read.

People think that the airlines are safe enough, and it probably is. People are willing to watch a few hundred people die a year as long as they can take an RJ to Fresno for $49.
 
People think that the airlines are safe enough, and it probably is. People are willing to watch a few hundred people die a year as long as they can take an RJ to Fresno for $49.
Not sure how anyone could blame the public. On a cost basis, the price of a ticket wouldn't go up in proportion to pilot pay. Why should they care? They deserve quality service, and safety no matter what.

Blame management, puppymills, ALPA, congress, the RLA, or Tea Partiers- whoever-just not the flying public.
 
The supply of low time pilots with wet ink on their commercials may not dry up, but we're talking about the supply of QUALIFIED pilots. At least with 1500 hours there's a CHANCE you might see more and actually make a command decision. I've flown with FOs who's only PIC decisions were on their solo cross countries for their PPLs. Guess what? They won't make another unitl they're PIC in a jet with passengers in the back. That scares the crap out of me with some of these guys. Some will "get it" and pay attention while becoming sponges in the right seat. Others will just "fake it" until they have the seniority to upgrade.


So wet certificate pilots are incapible of building hours? All of the sudden there are no more 1500hr pilots because the FAA decides to raise mins.? Years and years ago, there were still thousands of apps being sent in to airlines with guys having 3-4k hours, turbine time, military time, etc. Granted this was before de-regulation, so pay was better. But the same "lure's" were still there. There was no pilot shortage then, so what makes you think there will be one now? Serious question.

The number of commercial pilot being produced each year, and the number of availible jobs doesn't match up with a pilot shortage. And there is a long way to go before the number of jobs passes up the number of pilots being produced. With the current state of the economy, unless the governement wins the lotery, I doubt I'll ever see it in ym life time when the two pass each other up.
 
They deserve quality service, and safety no matter what.
Safety, of course! Quality service? I don't agree there. What's the point? Airlines take care of their frequent fliers, but why break your back for the person who books the cheapest fare from point A to point B regardless of flight times and connections? You don't know how often I hear people, flying for pleasure, say "Cool I'm on Jetblue this time" or "Damn, I'm on American this time". Like they don't have a choice, as if the lowest $ amount is what they're stuck with, like its set in stone, regardless of any other factors.

Example, I have a friend who goes to school in PHL. He flew United back from PHL and told me how awesome it was, how the movies were great, how it was cool to listen to ATC, ect. The next few times he flew US Airways, talked about how there was nothing but a window, no buy on board, ect. As years went by and he kept complaining about US Airways, I finally asked him "Well why don't you fly United if you loved them so much?". His reply? "Us Airways is usually about $30 cheaper". I kid you not.

It doesn't matter how great the service is. Everyone I know who has flown Virgin America tells me they'll "Never fly another airline again", guess what, they do. Sometimes just to save $20. The regular flying public who travels once or twice a year LOVES to complain about this and that and the lack of free meals and what not. They also love to snicker at the attention the frequent fliers get. But it should be no surprise to them that when they go by price and price ONLY, the airline is more likely to get their buisness in the future by cutting services and keeping the prices down than it is by wowing them on board.

Sure, there are exceptions. I myself when I have to buy a revenue ticket go by on-board service. For example, Virgin America coming home from Vegas is a little more than United, Southwest, and Us Airways. However, I'll pay a little more to have a more comfortable flight if I do buy a ticket. But as far as the majority of the flying population goes, you'd have a VERY hard time convincing me otherwise.
 
Don't believe the hype, son, it's never been about safety, and it will never be about safety. I'll bet you dollars to donuts that dollars win every time, and that buys you a lot of donuts.
If it was all about safety then we wouldn't fly, safety is never first. It is all about risk vs reward. Accidents cost money, so naturally it is in their best interest not to have accidents..to a point.
 
So wet certificate pilots are incapible of building hours? All of the sudden there are no more 1500hr pilots because the FAA decides to raise mins.? Years and years ago, there were still thousands of apps being sent in to airlines with guys having 3-4k hours, turbine time, military time, etc. Granted this was before de-regulation, so pay was better. But the same "lure's" were still there. There was no pilot shortage then, so what makes you think there will be one now? Serious question.

The number of commercial pilot being produced each year, and the number of availible jobs doesn't match up with a pilot shortage. And there is a long way to go before the number of jobs passes up the number of pilots being produced. With the current state of the economy, unless the governement wins the lotery, I doubt I'll ever see it in ym life time when the two pass each other up.

Don't forget that back then they didn't outsource the flying like they do now. More small aircraft require more crews. There are more Irvine pilots now than in the past. The idea is that people won't want to build 1500 hours and qualify for food stamps.
 
Best thing I've read on the forum in quite a while.

Until pilots gather their self respect and realize that spending $50k on an education and they are worth more than fast food pay this abuse will go on.

I don't blame any law nor the airlines for the pilot pay situation.

I blame every regional pilot who's ever said yes to a pathetic 24k/year job offer. It's a race to the bottom of the poverty barrel at 400kts.

If nobody said yes to a $24k/year job guess what the airlines would do?

I agree, but how can we go about creating such a resurgence of fist hire guys to say no?

Most people, especially mid 20's or younger guys, want to get to the regionals as fast as possible so they can get to Captain and the almighty turbine PIC time. This way they can possibly have (for arguments sake) a decent salary going forward and the required type of time for corporate or majors.

I just put my app in at American Eagle. I hope to hear from them and if I do and am offered a job it would be insane for me, as hard as I have worked to reach more than just basic minimums, to politely decline their offer because of the pay.

I know what my goals are in aviation and my visions. The unfortunate truth is you need hours and specific types of hours in order to make that happen.

It is embarrassing to know that of all my friends, who work basic level office jobs, I won't make close to them. It certainly should be the opposite. I have spent a lot of money and a lot of work on a very specialized trade as opposed to some of my friends with 2 yr or basic bachelor degrees.

I agree with your notion to just say no, but how can we make this happen?

I know it sounds like a daunting task, but things are possible. Could we create a network with new hires or get something rolling?

Firebird - Just helped launch, along with the families, and put into motion the new legislation after the Colgan crash.

Is there anyway to create some movement just us? I'm really serious about this. I like the way you think and you are totally spot on that nothing will change until people do things about it.

Let me know if you have any ideas as well as anyone for that matter.

James
 
I just put my app in at American Eagle. I hope to hear from them and if I do and am offered a job it would be insane for me, as hard as I have worked to reach more than just basic minimums, to politely decline their offer because of the pay.

yay...another one. :sarcasm:
I know what my goals are in aviation and my visions. The unfortunate truth is you need hours and specific types of hours in order to make that happen.

It is embarrassing to know that of all my friends, who work basic level office jobs, I won't make close to them. It certainly should be the opposite. I have spent a lot of money and a lot of work on a very specialized trade as opposed to some of my friends with 2 yr or basic bachelor degrees.

I agree with your notion to just say no, but how can we make this happen?
um, by saying no or not appling for crap pay gigs. Believe it or not, there are some people on this board who adhere to those standards because they value their worth. It's hard when we're undermined, but still we can and do say no.

Is there anyway to create some movement just us? I'm really serious about this. I like the way you think and you are totally spot on that nothing will change until people do things about it.

Let me know if you have any ideas as well as anyone for that matter.

James

yeah, the movement is not taking poor pay for professional work. it's already begun,
 
I agree, but how can we go about creating such a resurgence of fist hire guys to say no?

Most people, especially mid 20's or younger guys, want to get to the regionals as fast as possible so they can get to Captain and the almighty turbine PIC time. This way they can possibly have (for arguments sake) a decent salary going forward and the required type of time for corporate or majors.

I just put my app in at American Eagle. I hope to hear from them and if I do and am offered a job it would be insane for me, as hard as I have worked to reach more than just basic minimums, to politely decline their offer because of the pay.

I know what my goals are in aviation and my visions. The unfortunate truth is you need hours and specific types of hours in order to make that happen.

It is embarrassing to know that of all my friends, who work basic level office jobs, I won't make close to them. It certainly should be the opposite. I have spent a lot of money and a lot of work on a very specialized trade as opposed to some of my friends with 2 yr or basic bachelor degrees.

I agree with your notion to just say no, but how can we make this happen?

I know it sounds like a daunting task, but things are possible. Could we create a network with new hires or get something rolling?

Firebird - Just helped launch, along with the families, and put into motion the new legislation after the Colgan crash.

Is there anyway to create some movement just us? I'm really serious about this. I like the way you think and you are totally spot on that nothing will change until people do things about it.

Let me know if you have any ideas as well as anyone for that matter.

James

Your willingness to be abused and undervaluing your own worth is the problem. By apply to a job at Eagle you've fed the problem.

The race to the bottom is a race I'm not interested in winning. Sounds like your well on your way to getting there though!
 
Don't forget that back then they didn't outsource the flying like they do now. More small aircraft require more crews. There are more Irvine pilots now than in the past. The idea is that people won't want to build 1500 hours and qualify for food stamps.


Show me a job that a guy with 1500hrs can get and not qualify, or nearly so, for food stamps. Fact of the matter is, even though the mins say 1500TT, think about the other requirements, and the guys that are, and have been competing for those jobs, 121 or otherwise.

As for outsourcing, there was a steady flow of new pilots back then, like there is now, and like there will be in the future. If people are doing it for pennies, and using the "stepping stone" methidology, it will continue.

Nothing will change in terms of applicants, people will just have to be CFI's for longer, like it used to be, or fly traffic watch, or pipe, or whatever.

Sorry, I know this post kinda rambles.
 
Seeing as how this regulation, even if enacted, would not have changed the outcome, I can't see where people are saying this will make airline travel safer. Both Colgan pilots had significantly more time than required under these regulations. The CA had ~3500 TT and the FO ~2200.

In fact, what crashes in the last 10 or 20 years have been pilot error with lower time pilots on board? The Comair crash had two experienced pilots. Not sure about the Republic flight that ran off the end of the runway. The AWAC crash in PVD had a pretty experienced CA, a new hire FO but not sure about their flight times. SWA that ran off the runway in MDW had very experienced pilots on it. How about the CAL aircraft in DEN that ran off the side of the runway due to bad crosswind correction? Experienced as well.

I agree with the airlines unfortunately, having this reg in place probably won't appreciably increase safety. It's a feel good reg.

Now, the rest/duty times, HECK yes that will go a long ways toward making it better and safer. Much more rested crews. I am all for that.

Speaking of which, I took this pic in the shared LGA crew room the other day.
 
People think that the airlines are safe enough, and it probably is. People are willing to watch a few hundred people die a year as long as they can take an RJ to Fresno for $49.

A few hundred people a year? Really? Fear monger much? Please.
 
Back
Top