Airline operational differences

MikeD

Administrator
Staff member
Going off on a tangent that Waco and I stumbled upon:


It is interesting though how different airlines flying the exact same equipment, fly them differently sometimes, with different checklist items and such. I noticed this a long time ago when I was looking at 727 checklists for two different major airlines. There were notable differences between the two checklists regarding steps, though they were for the same exact airplane.

WacoFan said:
This would be an interesting thread on its own merits. I believe that TWA used to have exceptional training. I believe that even the American pilots will say that the TWA guys had a better way of doing things for the most part. It would be interesting to see what differences existed between TWA-AA, NWA-DAL, USAir and America West, etc. What were the differences, which way was better, what procedures survived the merger, etc. I wonder if any airlines saw a better system at an airline they bought (DAL at NWA or AA at TWA) and adopted those procedures, of if they kept their own even if they were inferior. As I said, that would be a different thread but interesting.
 
To look at this topic in depth and write about it would probably be worthwhile enough to earn one a Doctorate.

My .02 cents...
 
You know, I had never really considered two airlines operating the same equipment to be drastically different in operating procedures, but this sounds extremely interesting. I guess I had always just assumed that with FAA oversight, a somewhat standardized approach to operating a specific type according to the manufacturer's specs would have been adopted.

I'm not really even sure how one would begin to study this from a data gathering point of view. I'm just going to throw out the WAG that getting this sort of information from an airline to study would be a difficult task.
 
I went through a merger between two companies flying a SIMPLE aircraft. The differences in checklists/call outs/procedures can be huge.
 
To look at this topic in depth and write about it would probably be worthwhile enough to earn one a Doctorate.

I'm looking at going for a human factors masters, and this sort of thing and the CRM issues involved are pretty damn interesting. Yeah, it's probably above and beyond master's level stuff, but maybe someday....

I guess I had always just assumed that with FAA oversight, a somewhat standardized approach to operating a specific type according to the manufacturer's specs would have been adopted.

There's a perfectly sensible reason to let airlines customize their procedures - the fewer new things you have to learn when changing types, and the less you have to change your overarching SOPs, the easier it is. It makes economic sense for the airline to standardize their cockpits across the fleet as much as possible (think about why Airbus has pretty much the same flight deck on all its aircraft since the 320 - going from a 320 to a 340 is a heck of a lot easier, quicker, and less expensive than going from a 737 to a 777). Obviously, there are limits to how much the manufacturers can cater to different airlines, but it's not uncommon to see even the overhead panel arranged slightly differently from one carrier to another.

And I think it makes sense to do it this way, since the airlines know their operating environment far better than the manufacturers do, and can alter the manufacturer's recommendations to suit their needs. Obviously, the FAA needs to sign off on it, and I'd presume that the manufacturer does as well, so it's not like the airline can operate the plane any way they damn well choose.
 
I flew the 737 for America West for 19 years. During that time the company came up with 8 completely different ways for flying that airplane pre merger. On the Bus now and haven't gone through a procedural change (yet) but the guys that have are still screaming about it!

Really doesn't make much difference to me how an airline wants us to fly their planes. The changes aren't all that major and not hard to adapt to and it will all change again in three years. I remember when we first got TCAS and listening to pilots you would have thought the world was coming to an end. I'll NEVER do what that piece of electronic crap says! Now pilots sometimes refuse to fly if it is inop. Just another day at the office. Same paperwork, different format.
 
The intracacies can fill a volume of books the size of a library. What it all boils down to is extremely simple.

We are given a box to operate the aircraft in by the manufacturer+FAA. The ways to stay inside that box are nearly infinite.
 
Can some people detail some of the following:

1) An AA pilot talking about TWA and their procedures, or a TWA pilot talking about switch to AA procedures and any "merging" of the operation of the airplanes.

2) A NWA or DAL pilot to address the same.

3) A USAir, America West pilot to do the same.
 
Can some people detail some of the following:

2) A NWA or DAL pilot to address the same.


We used a process called "Best Practices." Basically, the company reviewed both company's procedures, and chose the one they felt was the best. This was to facilitate the drive to SOC. The breakdown came to roughly 75% DAL to 25% NWA procedures.
 
I know Airways and AWA used Best Practices as well. From riding in the jumpseat (mostly on the Airbus fleet) neither side was too happy about what was chosen as "best".
 
It is interesting though how different airlines flying the exact same equipment, fly them differently sometimes, with different checklist items and such. I noticed this a long time ago when I was looking at 727 checklists for two different major airlines. There were notable differences between the two checklists regarding steps, though they were for the same exact airplane.

IF I have it right, UP was ON for United and DOWN was ON for Eastern. This is one reason reportedly for when Lockheed created the -1011, they came up with the push to engage/disengage switches.

Other obvious diffs were location of instruments and instrument selection (V-bars/dual cue). That was one great thing at PI.. YS-11 or 727.. the instrumentation was the same on ALL airplanes and in both seats.

And yes, jumpseating around on the 727 was interesting to say the least. Speeds were different, configs at different times different. Checklists were different and Eastern and I think American ran with one altimeter at QFE and others at QNH.
 
And yes, jumpseating around on the 727 was interesting to say the least. Speeds were different, configs at different times different. Checklists were different and Eastern and I think American ran with one altimeter at QFE and others at QNH.

I used to JS on the 727 often back in my civvie days (was a primary fleet plane back then). I did notice that NWA and United (the main ones I'd JS on) did things differently and at different times.

Wanted to see how 747 ops were, but only got to JS on one 747 in my time, a United 747SP.
 
Hey OrangeAnchor,

I bet you could give us some great insight into how USAir changed Piedmont's procedures when y'all merged. I heard that USAir basically said "You guys don't know how to fly this airplane, so you'll do it our way"...and got rid of things like the QRH, etc.

Another thing I've noticed is the difference between airlines that use "bat wings" on the flight director and others that use "the poles" (as I call them), such as Delta.
 
Hey OrangeAnchor,

I bet you could give us some great insight into how USAir changed Piedmont's procedures when y'all merged. I heard that USAir basically said "You guys don't know how to fly this airplane, so you'll do it our way"...and got rid of things like the QRH, etc.

I was on the 727 at the time of the merger and yes, big changes. There was a lot of scuffling over procedures and call-outs and even the FAA offices were pushing to see which would be THE office.

One thing that really surprised us was how we got our releases and how wt/bal was done. That change over cost us a lot of time waiting 'for numbers.'

We attended a conference for developing a new checklist and this was late 80s so we had people obviously from PSA, USAir, PI as well as guys who had flown for Eastern, TWA, Braniff and more than a few freight dogs.

The group was doing, "Well at ____ this is the way we did it" or "___ is a big operator and they do it this way." Being quite naive I suggested we toss ALL the checklists and manuals on the table, go through and cherry pick so that "our procedures are the best and the best procedures are ours." I was greeted with a response similar to Palin at an Obama rally.

Another thing I've noticed is the difference between airlines that use "bat wings" on the flight director and others that use "the poles" (as I call them), such as Delta.
Some use dual cue and others use the V-bars. I can fly both equally bad. It is just what you get used to. Prior to PI most of my experience was on V-bars. PI had dual cue. The only thing with the dual cue is when you satisfy the command and center the bars, the initial impulse is to roll out. That soon goes away.

And the min reserves were vastly different at airlines. Many guys at PI landed with a boatload of fuel. I jumpseated on Frontier (the old one) once and we TOOK OFF with about 7000-8000lbs of fuel and I thought we had left without sufficient fuel. The burn was about 3000-4000 for a short 1hr leg so we had plenty for landing and it was VFR from Fresno to Frankfurt. But it sure opened my eyes to the differences in the way companies operated.

But we did have to go through a 2-3 day class of 'mirror image'. The instructor was a haughty fellow who thought we were doing good to have shoes on. And we responded in kind. BUT at lunch before the end of the last day, I got 4-5 Captains to contribute and we got him a bottle of champagne, a dozen red roses for him to take to his wife. We told him not to worry. We could make it work. He was quite surprised.

At any rate, the story was the US guys were 'rustheads', the south 'bubbas' and the PSA guys 'beachboys.' It was not a smooth merger by any measure.
 
I used to JS on the 727 often back in my civvie days (was a primary fleet plane back then). I did notice that NWA and United (the main ones I'd JS on) did things differently and at different times.

Wanted to see how 747 ops were, but only got to JS on one 747 in my time, a United 747SP.


Oh yes, jumpseated many a times on a 727. At least the ones ATA operated had -17 engines, sometimes -15. Ceritified for 195K MTOW. Nothing like JS out of MDW on a hot day on a 727!!! End of the runway comes up very very quickly. Pucker factor was increased at least 10 fold.

Also jumpseated on a 72 mail run. It is was -100 series running -9 engines. Talk about no power!! Man what a pig. Luckily it was an ORD-SEA leg.

Don't remember the year but ATA popped an engine after V1 out of MDW, the gear took out someones chimney.
 
At PI before the merger we had 727s and 737s operating with -7 and -9 engines. We also had some -15 engines. You could 'intermix' the -7 and -9. I don't remember if on the 727 you could intermix the -9 and the -15 engines but it was interesting to drag a -7 down to IAH in the summer with the thunderstorms.
 
Having flown 747 classics for about a year, our procedures were based on Pan Am's. One time, I watched one of those "World Air Routes" videos featuring a 747-200, and I can say their checklists, callouts, etc, were totally different from what I was used to. Many ways to skin the cat--the important thing is standarization with the other crewmembers you fly with so you know what to expect from the other two in the cockpit and they know what to expect from you.

It makes perfect sense to standardize procedures as much as possible with existing fleet types. It would be a little ridiculus to have crews learn a totally different way of doing things every time they transition to another jet. So long as the operation is consistent with FAA and manufacturer guidelines, I don't see a problem.

EDIT: By the way, we had many sources for our airplanes, so they were all configured a little differently (particularly the JAL planes). We also had four engine variants.
 
Back
Top