Airbus v. Boeing - In Court!

TrinidadGT20

Vice President of Awesome
It looks like the talks are over and that the US will formally file a lawsuit tomorrow with the World Trade Organization regarding Airbus receiving launch aid from the European Union for development of new airplanes.

This ought to be interesting as both sides have some valid claims against each other. My $0.02 is I hope Airbus' subsidies are put to an end.

Let the real Airbus v. Boeing battle begin...

Washingtonpost.com Article
 
I wonder what the a.net forums will look like after the trial.
crazy.gif
 
[ QUOTE ]
Boeing must win! This would be a miracle for loyal Boeing customers (such as Delta and Continental).

[/ QUOTE ]

Sorry but I think that your posting on the wrong board. Point your cursor up at the toolbar again and this time type:

w-w-w.a-i-r-l-i-n-e-r-s.n-e-t

sarcasm.gif


Look I'm a huge,huge boeing fan but if you think both companies hands are clean then your the fool!
I however do believe that competition is good for both companies otherwise design and imagination would grow old and stale.
If Airbus is going to compete with Boeing in the global market it is very unfair they recieve subsides from their consortium governments to pad their bottom line.
Thus being able to low ball Boeing when negotiations with airlines heats up. By selling planes and training sims at dirt cheap rates/prices.
That Boeing can't match because they are actually in the business to make and post a profit.
That having been said lets keep the mindless cheerleading to a highschool pep rally and not on this board.

-Matthew
 
[ QUOTE ]
Boeing must win! This would be a miracle for loyal Boeing customers (such as Delta and Continental).

[/ QUOTE ]

Could I have your well thought out, cogent, non-emotional reasons why this is so?

And "if it ain't a Boeing, I ain't going" does not count as one.
 
Rumor has it most of the airlines that said "If it ain't Boeing, I ain't going" really didn't get much of a deal on new aircraft financing either! But that's just what a little bird told me!
smile.gif
 
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Boeing must win! This would be a miracle for loyal Boeing customers (such as Delta and Continental).

[/ QUOTE ]

Could I have your well thought out, cogent, non-emotional reasons why this is so?

And "if it ain't a Boeing, I ain't going" does not count as one.

[/ QUOTE ]

I would just like to know how should Boeing win .The victory would in anyway be a miracle for loyal Boeing customers. Such as Delta or Continental?

-Matthew
 
While reading posts at A.net, I noticed that some have claimed that Airbus is aiding US Airways/America West to hurt Delta. Take a guess where does Airbus get the money to aid them? ILLEGAL SUBSIDIES!
 
LOL!

It actually makes business sense from Boeing's standpoint. If you know someone isn't going to go to the competition, you don't have to price things as aggressively as you do with someone who very well may.

I'm pretty sure that Air Asia, for example, beat Airbus up hard. I'm sure they said something along the lines of, we're flying 737s right now just like Southwest does, and unless you give me a very good reason to change to your planes, I'm going to go back to Boeing.

Airbus did. You gotta wonder just how much they undercut Boeing by and whether they turned a profit on those planes.
 
[ QUOTE ]
While reading posts at A.net, I noticed that some have claimed that Airbus is aiding US Airways/America West to hurt Delta.

[/ QUOTE ]

Consider the source.

That's like someone telling me, it's gotta be true, O'Lielly said so!
 
Airbus really hasn't an incentive to cut a profit. Considering the levels of subsidies that they're getting from the participating countries, it's nothing more than a good airplane and a good EU jobs program.
 
Yup. That's the problem. Boeing has to do deals that make business sense, and Airbus, well, a profit is like the icing on the cake.

Which airline was it -- Ryanair? -- where Airbus came in, offered planes at prices that even the execs at the airline said were ridiculous, and picked up the costs of retraining the crews to fly their aircraft?

If that ain't a perfect case of how Airbus doesn't have to make money, I don't know what is.

BTW, I wonder if they are making the same mistake that Boeing did with the 787 when they announced they'd have 200 orders by the end of the year. Airbus has promised triple digit orders by the time the Paris Air Show rolls around.

They've got about two weeks.
 
Hey, you and I could come together with enough capital to lease an A-318 and start a PFT operation here in AZ!

Doood, we'll be rich!
 
[ QUOTE ]
While reading posts at A.net, I noticed that some have claimed that Airbus is aiding US Airways/America West to hurt Delta. Take a guess where does Airbus get the money to aid them? ILLEGAL SUBSIDIES!

[/ QUOTE ]

The whole America West/US-Airways mergers was directed at SWA.
SWA kills America West in both of it's hubs. And is posied to move in and dominate US in theirs (PIT,PHL).
Also the merger at least on paper suits one another very well. US-Airways is mostly an east coast airline with very little west coast presents.
Likewise America West is the inverse of US but on the west coast and lacks major east coast presence.
As for Airbus funding the merger of both airlines from a strictly business stand point it makes good sense.
I don't have a problem with them doing it.
Or Boeing following suit in the Delta/Continental, Delta/United merger!


-Matthew
 
[ QUOTE ]
Hey, you and I could come together with enough capital to lease an A-318 and start a PFT operation here in AZ!

Doood, we'll be rich!

[/ QUOTE ]

Well I'ma size queen so I couldn't be caught dead flying/training in anything smaller then a A320!

sarcasm.gif


-Matthew
 
[ QUOTE ]

While reading posts at A.net, I noticed that some have claimed that Airbus is aiding US Airways/America West to hurt Delta.

[/ QUOTE ]

Okay, first thing: I wouldn't consider A.net a very good source of info. Second, Airbus is helping the merger along for one reason, to SELL AIRPLANES. Delta isn't anywhere near a position to buy anything from Airbus or Boeing, so claiming Airbus is doing this for some sort of vindictive, high school reason is just stupid.

[ QUOTE ]
Take a guess where does Airbus get the money to aid them? ILLEGAL SUBSIDIES!

[/ QUOTE ]

The point is BOTH companies aren't exactly squeaky clean. Look at Boeing's government deals, some of which got their CEO fired and the company in serious hot water. I agree that Airbus is probably getting some nice kick backs from EU tax dollars, but don't think that Boeing is totally blameless.
 
I don't know. Airbus is looking at Charleston as a possible ocation to build tankers for the Air Force if they win the contract (which I imagine they will since Boeing originally lost it due to corrupt business practices and kick backs. Giving it to Boeing is going to just "look bad." Word on the street herre in town for anyone in the manufacturing world is that they are going to be paying pretty good if they build it here. Thats a lot of ifs but if it comes true, I may not be such a Boeing fan for too much longer.
 
I would be an Airbus fan if they would just put a yoke in their airplanes...I mean...are we flying FS2004? No...so lets put a real control in there.
 
[ QUOTE ]
I would be an Airbus fan if they would just put a yoke in their airplanes...I mean...are we flying FS2004? No...so lets put a real control in there.

[/ QUOTE ]

Okay...dude gotta ding ya thats just assinine!

confused.gif


-Matthew
 
Back
Top